Sara McNeil, Agent in NYC - Compass

Sara McNeil

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Individual revenue of $70 Million since 2014
Team revenue of over $860 Million since 2014


WSJ Top 6 Teams in New York City

2017 Top East Side Sales Team & 2nd in Sales in Manhattan Overall

Consistently ranks within the list of top brokers city-wide and nationwide


Pre-war beauty in Riverside’s ‘Marvelous Mrs. Maisel’ Building Asks $1.8M - 6sqft

Live in the building made famous by 'Marvelous Mrs. Maisel' - The New York Post

5 Alluring Apartments with Glass-Walled Showers - Brick Underground

Roosevelt Island apartments open for viewing this weekend - Brick Underground

This amenity-packed co-op is well worth the tram trip to Roosevelt Island - Brick Underground

Get a Head Start on the Creative Possibilities in This $2.5M Funky Tribeca Live/Work Loft - 6sqft

Roosevelt Island's new deal - 6sqft

Social Media



New York University, Master of Social Work (M.S.W.)

John Jay College of Criminal Justice of The City University of New York, Bachelor of Arts (B.A.), Forensic Psychology

About Sara

A highly respected and skilled real estate agent, Sara McNeil has gained valuable experience working with a top-producing team for the last five years. Sara is thrilled to join Compass and focus on guiding buyers and sellers through the entire real estate process with ease, always keeping their best interest top of mind.

Sara loves real estate and it shows. She has a magnetic vibe much like the city she represents and is a total pleasure to work with according to her many happy clients. She maintains these relationships gracefully in order to take care of her clients when they need her most. Sara is known for having special qualities that set her apart as an agent, including her professionalism, calm demeanor, and optimistic outlook.

Sara expertly navigates the city and helps buyers find and secure the home that best suits their needs and lifestyle. She is a savvy negotiator who has closed countless deals and prepared co-op board packages that led to smooth approvals. Sellers are just as confident in Sara’s talents for marketing their property with a customized plan, maximizing exposure to buyers and breaking records for the highest sales price in multiple buildings.

Born in Pittsburg, PA and raised in Florida, Sara has called NYC home for over 15 years. Enamored with the city, Sara is proudly raising her son on the Upper West Side. She loves the diverse mix of architecture, from the timeless beauty of prewar buildings to the exciting condos and new development emerging downtown.

Outside of work, Sara enjoys spending time with family, walking her dog in Riverside Park, riding a citibike along the West Side Highway, and practicing Pilates.

Sara McNeil’s Listings

Sara McNeil’s Recent Transactions

Recent Sales
Recent Rentals