Lindsay Rothman, Agent in Westchester, NY - Compass

Lindsay Rothman

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Social Media



Check out our website!

Client Testimonials

Scroll down for more

Lindsay put us in the house of our dreams, negotiated a great price below our budget and expertly navigated us through a very difficult short-sale process. She also took the time to show us dozens of houses throughout Westchester County and helped us to craft our needs and preferences. I highly recommend her!"

Just worked with Lindsay on a short sale that took FOREVER... I truly believe that most agents would have checked out... not Lindsay. After nearly a year... she saw it through to the closing table while remaining on top of it all and giving emotional support throughout. As a professional and a human being, I strongly endorse LR!! "

Lindsay was knowledgeable, professional, and extremely flexible! She would always make herself available to us at any hour -- meeting early in the morning or late in the afternoon to work with our schedule. Lindsay helped us to find our first home - I'd recommend her to anyone!"

Speaking from the perspective of a buyer in today's hot market, you should choose Lindsay as your buyer's agent. She has a ton of knowledge in regard to all of the towns in Westchester, and you certainly want someone quick & eager to find all of the listings that match your wish list and present you with a lot of great options. Furthermore I think she has a really great understanding on pricing and gives buyers good honest feedback on their budget and finds options that demonstrate the trade offs between location and home size/ lot size, etc... She also takes the time to show you a neighborhood and doesn't focus solely on the home- Lindsay really understands that a home purchase isn't just about the house- it's about the community.

If you are a seller I have no doubt Lindsay would give you the same incredible service and would price your home right and be tough in negotiations with other agents in order to get you the highest price.

We very much enjoyed working with Lindsay. She is professional, hard-working and responsive, and also a lovely person to be around, all of which made our home purchase experience a very pleasant one. We are grateful for all her help and highly recommend her. - Tanja B.

Lindsay and her colleagues Maya and Ari from the Compass office in Dobbs Ferry are amazing! In one week, they listed my home, took photos, held an open house and found me an amazing tenant. I've used other real estate companies before but I will never use any other company other than Compass and particularly, Lindsay and Maya. Words fail to express how truly impressed and humbled I am by them.'

Lindsay is a true professional, combining market knowledge, attention to detail, and a willingness to truly listen to us as clients describe what we were looking for. We very much enjoyed working with her and would recommend her without hesitation." - Marge F.

Lindsay and Maya were excellent to work with and the teamwork made it easy to reach and schedule showings, inspections, and other necessary appointments. They were very knowledgeable about the area, always available to show us houses or answer any questions we had throughout the process, including after the closing. They both went well above and beyond the home purchase aspect alone with recommendations on yard work, childcare, and handyman services in our new neighborhood. Furthermore, they were even able to get us a discount on a new washer and dryer after we moved in, they gave us baby gifts for our newborn, and they even held the baby during our home closing. Truly was much more than we expected from our realtors. I would recommend them and certainly would use them for future real estate needs. - Steve, Trang and Zoe

About Lindsay

With an amazing eye for design, Lindsay Rothman helps clients see possibilities they might otherwise have missed, whether that's helping a seller to maximize their own property's best features or guiding a buyer who has overlooked a diamond in the rough.

Lindsay got her start in the business three years ago by staging the homes of friends and family members, nearly all of which sold within weeks, proving that she had a natural gift for real estate marketing. To date, Lindsay has has closed over $10 Million in transactions and continues to apply that talent throughout her native Westchester County. Lindsay loves helping assisting those relocating to the suburbs from the city, as she did herself six years ago.


Dutchess Manor

The Dutchess Manor is one of Dutchess County’s premier catering and wedding event halls. Located on the banks of the Hudson River, The Dutchess Manor was originally built as a private residence for the Timoney family in the 1860’s and was a showpiece Hudson River estate. Nestled between trendy Beacon and quaint Cold Spring, the Dutchess Manor holds endless possibilities.


SR Team Westchester

Designer real estate duo, Lindsay Rothman and Maya Sheehan, offer buyers the rare experience of impressive Westchester market knowledge and a direct connection to NYC. Lindsay and Maya have remarkable first-hand experience navigating the relocation process--since leaving the city to pursue life in suburban Westchester, they've bought, sold, and built homes as well as helped countless people find their place in the suburbs. As Westchester natives, they can help guide you from city to suburb, covering all of your relocation needs.


PENDING | 25 Kipp Avenue | Fishkill, NY

This adorable Cape is located in the quiet neighborhood of Eastern Fishkill and just outside the Village. Situated on a flat .3 acre lot, this home boasts 4 bedrooms, 2 renovated full baths and kitchen, partially finished basement, 3 season room and in-ground pool. The pool liner is two years young and the roof was replaced this past year. An exceptional value and amazing home just steps from the shops and restaurants in the village of Fishkill and less than a minute to Rt. 84.


PENDING | 91 Tappan Landing Rd | Tarrytown, NY

This gorgeous 1940 Colonial has been deftly re-designed & improved to maximize both space & the enjoyment of all the natural beauty that surrounds it. Features: countless sun-drenched new windows, new hardwood floors, a spacious living room, separate dining room --both with river views-- 1st floor bedroom/home office, family room, custom designed & installed closets, & a reno'd eat-in windowed kitchen with quartzite counters, custom built cabinetry and storage, Viking & GE Monogram appliances, & new sliders out to the large deck. Upstairs, the gracious landing doubles as a home office. There is a second hall bath & 3 bedrooms -- including the impressive Master with it’s custom built walk-in closet and built-in window seat to enjoy the sunset. The en-suite spa-like bathroom has a deep soaking tub & a separate tile shower. Basement has new W/D & water filtration system. Furnace & AC replaced in 2018. Foot bridge to MNR (39 mins to Grand Central). To schedule a private tour, kindly email.

Lindsay Rothman’s Listings

Lindsay Rothman’s Recent Transactions

Recent Sales
Recent Rentals