Shelter Island, NY Apartments & Homes for Rent
Homes near Shelter Island
Explore more results near Shelter Island by adjusting your filters
Search tips
“3 bedroom homes with backyard in Shelter Island”
“Condos with balcony in Shelter Island”
“Open houses this weekend in Shelter Island”
Explore additional listings by widening your search area (from neighborhood to city, or ZIP to county).
Remove all filters to view every available property in your chosen location.
For Rent:
Discover Your Perfect Home
Explore Nearby Homes
- Dering Harbor Homes for Rent
- The Hamptons Homes for Rent
- Southampton Town Homes for Rent
- North Haven Homes for Rent
- Greenport West Homes for Rent
- North Fork Homes for Rent
- Southold Town Homes for Rent
- East Hampton Town Homes for Rent
- East Hampton Area Homes for Rent
- Northwest Harbor Homes for Rent
- Northwest Woods Homes for Rent
- Sag Harbor Village Homes for Rent
- Noyac Homes for Rent
- Wainscott North Homes for Rent
- Sagaponack North Homes for Rent
- Shelter Island Heights Homes for Rent
- Sag Harbor Homes for Rent
- Greenport Homes for Rent
- East Marion Homes for Rent
- Southold Homes for Rent
- Orient Homes for Rent
- Wainscott Homes for Rent
- Peconic Homes for Rent
- Sagaponack Homes for Rent
- Bridgehampton Homes for Rent
- Southampton Homes for Rent
- Cutchogue Homes for Rent
- Water Mill Homes for Rent
- New Suffolk Homes for Rent
- Amagansett Homes for Rent