291 Main Street

Closed 5/20/25
Closed 5/20/25
Gallery Image 1
Gallery Image 2
Gallery Image 3
Gallery Image 4
Gallery Image 5
Gallery Image 6
Gallery Image 7
Gallery Image 8
Gallery Image 9
Gallery Image 10
Gallery Image 11
Gallery Image 12
Gallery Image 13
Gallery Image 14
Gallery Image 15
Gallery Image 16
Gallery Image 17
Gallery Image 18
Last Sold Price
$2,200,000
3 beds1,636 sqft$1,345/sqft
291 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Description

Discover the chance to own a true piece of Sag Harbor Village history with Holton House, located 2,100 ft from the center of the village. This charming 3 bed, 2 bath home remained in the same family since the mid-1800s, with only 1 owner since. Renowned for its association with Sag Harbor's famous "Tomato Lady" farmstand, this was her family home where she sold her beloved tomatoes. The entire downstairs underwent a meticulous renovation down to the studs in 2018, including updated electrical, plumbing,...Discover the chance to own a true piece of Sag Harbor Village history with Holton House, located 2,100 ft from the center of the village. This charming 3 bed, 2 bath home remained in the same family since the mid-1800s, with only 1 owner since. Renowned for its association with Sag Harbor's famous "Tomato Lady" farmstand, this was her family home where she sold her beloved tomatoes. The entire downstairs underwent a meticulous renovation down to the studs in 2018, including updated electrical, plumbing, and central AC systems. The eat-in kitchen is a standout feature, marrying the original brick hearth with modern appliances. A generous covered front porch, recently reconstructed, offers a welcoming entrance, while the first floor also includes a guest bedroom and a full bath. Upstairs, the spacious primary bedroom boasts an en-suite bath, complemented by another guest bedroom. A shaded back patio overlooks the picturesque backyard, which is adorned with mature landscaping. The interior design adds a touch of contemporary elegance to this historic home. Holton House is ready for your personal touch and an unbelievable investment opportunity or the chance to own one of the Village's legendary historic homes.
LISTING CLOSED: 05/20/2025 12:00 AM

Listing Agents

  1. Cindy Scholz

    Cindy Scholz

    Listing Agent

    Bridgehampton

    P: (914) 837-9339

    M: (914) 837-9339

    CallText
  2. Chris Ritchey

    Chris Ritchey

    Alternative Listing Agent

    East Hampton

    P: (646) 981-7954

    M: (646) 981-7954

    CallText

Property Details for 291 Main Street

Status
Closed
MLS #
381713
Days on Market
306
Taxes
$4,429 / year
HOA Fees
-
Condo/Co-op Fees
-
Property Type
Single Family
MLS Type
Residential
Year Built
1880
Lot Size
0.17 AC
County
Suffolk County
Buyer's Agent Compensation
2%
Water access
false

Recent comparable sales

Median sold price

$1,900,000

Avg days on market

26

Sale-to-list ratio

108.1%

Sag Harbor, NY

9 comparable properties found

1

$2,300,000

Sold 11/26/24

3
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,529
Square Feet
0.24
Acres

16 Palmer Terrace, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

2

$2,350,000

Sold 10/08/25

3
Bedrooms
1,600
Square Feet
0.1
Acres

132 Jermain Avenue, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

a living room with furniture a fireplace and a large window
1/17
3

$2,100,000

Sold 04/23/25

3
Bedrooms
1,462
Square Feet
0.7
Acres

36 Carroll Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

a front view of a house with a garden and trees
4

$1,855,000

Sold 01/13/26

3
Bedrooms
1,628
Square Feet
0.14
Acres

300 Madison Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

5

$1,790,000

Sold 04/11/25

3
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,462
Square Feet
0.17
Acres

70 Glover Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

a view of a house with swimming pool and sitting area
1/24
6

$1,900,000

Sold 06/09/26

3
Bedrooms
1,400
Square Feet
0.51
Acres

114 Harrison Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

a view of a house with a yard and pathway
7

$1,750,000

Sold 01/10/26

3
Bedrooms
1,456
Square Feet
0.57
Acres

36 Denison Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

8

$1,850,000

Sold 08/22/25

3
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,406
Square Feet
1.8
Acres

29 Round Pond Lane, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

9

$2,350,000

Sold 04/28/26

3
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,764
Square Feet
0.47
Acres

12 Breezy Drive, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1

Location

Add your commute

Building Information for 291 Main Street

Stories-Year Built1880Building Size-Lot Size0.17 AC

Payment Calculator

Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1

$11,551 per month

30 year fixed, 6.55% Interest

Principal and Interest

$11,182

Property Taxes

$369

HOA Dues

$0

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Rocket Mortgage1

Property Information for 291 Main Street

Summary
Location and General Information
  • City: Sag Harbor
  • Coordinates: -72.299197, 40.993893
  • Latitude: 40.993893
  • Longitude: -72.299197
  • Amenity names: Heat,OHA,Basement,Crawl,Central AC,Hardwood Floors,Bathroom on First Floor,None / Mainland
  • Cul de sac location: false
  • Near jitney sunrise bus line: true
  • Near train station: false
  • Subarea: Sag Harbor Village
  • Title: Historic Sag Harbor Village Gem
  • Unit type: Single-Family
  • Year Built: 1880
Taxes and HOA
  • Tax Annual Amount: $4,429
  • Tax Map Number: 0903006000100007000
Property
Lot Information
  • Building Area Total: 1636.0
  • Living Area: 1636.0
  • Lot Size Acres: 0.17
  • Corner lot: false
  • Lot with trees: false
Property and Assessments
  • Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
  • Property Type: Residential
Utilities
  • Water Source: Town
Interior and Exterior Features
Interior Features
  • Bathrooms Full: 2
  • Bathrooms Total Decimal: 2.0
  • Bedrooms Total: 3
Exterior Features
  • New Construction: No

Public Records for 291 Main Street

Taxable ValueLand$571,400Additions$232,200Total$803,600
Tax Record2024$2,232 ($186 / month)
Home Facts
Beds3Baths2Total Finished SqFt1,636 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt1,636 SqFtStories2Lot Size7,405 SqFtStyleSingle Family ResidenceYear Built1995Year Renovated1995ZoningVILLACountySUFFOLKAPN0903-006.00-01.00-007.000

Schools near 291 Main Street

This home is within Sag Harbor Union Free School District.
Rating
School
Type
Grades
Distance
Sag Harbor Elementary School
Public - PK to 5
Pierson Middle High School
Public - 6 to 12
Rating
School
Distance
Sag Harbor Elementary School
PublicPK to 5

Pierson Middle High School
Public6 to 12

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

New listings in 11963

$5,999,000 | 25 Church Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
1/29
Listed By Compass

$5,999,000

4
Bedrooms
3,509
Square Feet
Unavailable
Acres

25 Church Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

an outdoor sitting area with furniture and a garden
1/29

Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Open: 8/20 10:00AM - 12:00PMVirtual Tour

$3,500,000

3
Bedrooms
2,000
Square Feet
1.17
Acres

2723 Deerfield Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$2,195,000 | 18 Sunset Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
1/19
Listed By Compass

$2,195,000

3
Bedrooms
1,368
Square Feet
0.59
Acres

18 Sunset Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$2,695,950 | 36 Breezy Drive, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
1/39

Listing Courtesy of Handsome Real Estate Inc

$2,695,950

4
Bedrooms
2,578
Square Feet
0.58
Acres

36 Breezy Drive, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$2,195,000 | 15 Church Street, Unit G108, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
1/19
Listed By Compass

$2,195,000

1
Bedrooms
1,070
Square Feet

15 Church Street, Unit G108, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$2,195,000 | 15 Church Street, Unit G108 G108, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
1/22
Listed By Compass

$2,195,000

1
Bedrooms
Unavailable
Square Feet

15 Church Street, Unit G108 G108, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$2,275,000 | 723 Brick Kiln Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
1/43
Listed By Compass

$2,275,000

3
Bedrooms
1,879
Square Feet
1.2
Acres

723 Brick Kiln Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$1,695,000 | 1350 Brick Kiln Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
1/34

Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Open: 8/20 12:30PM - 02:30PM

$1,695,000

3
Bedrooms
1,307
Square Feet
0.62
Acres

1350 Brick Kiln Road, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

a view of a house with pool and chairs
1/28

Listing Courtesy of ZI Realty LLC; Saunders & Associates

$4,495,000

6
Bedrooms
4,519
Square Feet
0.35
Acres

66 Hillside Drive East, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Nearby home values

AddressSold priceBedsBathsSqftLot (Sqft)
This home: 291 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$2,200,000
3
1,636
7,405
295 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$975,000
3
2
2,854
9,583
283 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$925,000
–
–
1,278
3,049
281 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$625,000
–
–
350
6,534
303 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$1,663,500
–
–
–
10,890
279 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$1,092,500
3
2
1,834
8,712

Explore Nearby Homes

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of any information, descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified through appropriate means, including, but not limited to, in person inspection and public records, and Compass International Holdings, its subsidiaries, affiliates and independently owned and operated franchisees, and their affiliated agents and associated third parties expressly disclaim any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the seller's discretion. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

All data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by Compass. See Terms of Service for additional restrictions. Compass · Tel: 212-913-9058 · New York, NY