Buyer's Agent, Listing Agent, Relocation, Luxury Homes, Waterfront Specialist, Investment Properties


University of Washington - Bachelor’s Degree, Communication and Media Studies

Client Testimonials

Scroll down for more

"The moment I met Amy I knew she had my best interest in her heart and mind as a local Bainbridge Island realtor. Her enthusiasm and happy nature was very clear and, her sensitivity about the competitive current real estate market assisted me in building a trusting relationship with her. She provided me with facts, figures and avoided showing me properties that were not a good fit for my lifestyle. She had a team approach and respected my ideas, desires and economy. We closed on a sweet bungalow in Winslow in late February 2021 and I am very happy. Amy is a wonderful person and a very knowledgeable real estate agent that I would work with again an again! She is a true gem!" - Margaret

"Amy helped us find an island property and brought equal parts tenacity and patience which we needed during our long journey that brought several unforeseen challenges. Highly recommend Amy to anyone who needs a partner and an advisor to find the home they are seeking!" - Nichole

"We have been working with Amy on an extremely difficult piece of property Kitsap County for some time. Amy has repeatedly gone above and beyond the scope of her responsibilities to research and suggest ways to market this unusual property, to include the possibility of a charitable donation. She is knowledgeable and doesn’t hesitate to tackle challenges. She has been unfailingly responsive to us, government agencies, interested parties, surveyors, engineers and others. Not only all that, she is also kind, generous and has a great sense of humor. I would not hesitate to recommend her as a buyer's or seller’s agent. I give her at least six out of five stars." - Caroline

"Selling a home can be a stressful process. Amy couldn’t have been more available and accommodating and answered all of my questions. She kept me informed every step of the way. She promptly my home and gave it maximum and has excellent knowledge of the marketplace. It didn’t take long to get a offer, and I now believe the process of selling a home can be low stress if you work with Amy McFarland! Thank-you for the excellent professional service! I will be using Amy’s services for all of my future real estate needs." - Loriann

"Amy helped me and my wife buy a lovely beach house in Port Ludlow over the summer. We had been looking for a vacation home for the past few years but could never find the right combination of location, amenities and price. When we found this house we knew the timeline would be tight (offers were being reviewed within 10 days of first seeing it) and there would be multiple offers. Amy provided expert advice on how to approach the offer and was in constant contact as we the offer and waited for the news. And after it was accepted, she was very hands-on in helping with a smooth transaction. In fact, we closed several days early, very much due in part to Amy's excellent management and process. Aside from all of this, Amy is just a wonderful person to speak with and be around - a really positive and encouraging presence during a major decision like a home transaction!! My wife and I couldn't recommend her strongly enough and I hope our paths cross again!!" - Jeremy

"Having never purchased a house my wife and I were a bit nervous and not sure how everything worked. After working with Amy we immediately felt comfortable and we were able to find the perfect house for our family. Amy is knowledgeable, polite and very easy going. I highly recommend her for your next home purchase." - Aaron

"Amy McFarland is phenomenal! We highly recommend Amy, without reservation. Amy was crucial to our recent purchase of a home on Bainbridge Island. In addition to her thorough and impressive knowledge of Bainbridge Island, its real estate market, communities, neighborhoods, coastal and land use specifics, Amy is extremely professional, responsive, and a committed, loyal advocate for us and all of her clients. She facilitated the successful result to our thorough due diligence process, locating experts, researching information, and communicating seamlessly with us, the seller's agents and all else involved in the process. Amy makes the real estate transaction process, which can be onerous and difficult at times, feel easy and enjoyable. We are grateful to Amy for her help in finding us the perfect island getaway. It is everything we hoped for and more!" - Pamela

"Amy is great to work with. Extremely responsive to my so many questions and is very knowledgeable about the house-buying process. Thoroughly enjoyed working with her would recommend her highly."

"Amy was delightful to work with! She was very knowledgeable about Bainbridge Island and all of the things you want to know before buying a home and relocating your family. She is responsive, knows her stuff and is a joy to work with."

About Amy
Compass Founding Bainbridge Island Broker, Amy McFarland is the local expert on everything Island life. As a Bainbridge resident and active member of the community, Amy values relationships, home, and family, making sure every experience with her clients is one they will remember. Recognized by RealTrends as the top 1.5% of Realtors for sale volume in the nation and proudly voted Top 5 Best Real Estate Agents and Real Estate Team on Bainbridge Island 2021, 2022 and 2023-Amy is known for going above and beyond to provide her clients top-notch concierge level service. 

Specializing in Bainbridge Island and the surrounding neighborhoods, Amy works every day with Buyers and Sellers in all price ranges throughout the Kitsap Peninsula. Beyond the world of traditional real estate, Amy has extensive knowledge of the luxury waterfront market, investment properties, vacation homes, and relocation. She is an intuitive businessperson and able to manage the expectations of her clients with the highest levels of personal attention, efficiency, and sharp business acumen. Amy's business on Bainbridge has been built on referrals, which is a testament to the loyalty and trust that she establishes with her clients, colleagues, and community.

With over 20 years of sales & experience, Amy has worked for high-end hotels, pharmaceuticals, and now real estate. Her continued success has come from her strong work ethic, outstanding communication skills, genuine passion for people, market knowledge, and strategic execution. She takes great pride in providing her clients with top-notch concierge-level service.

As a Pacific Northwest native who marvels every day at all the Northwest has to offer, she has a seasoned knowledge of the diverse neighborhoods and an appreciation of what makes each of them unique. Real estate is Amy's passion and she considers it a privilege to assist her clients make one of the largest financial investments of their lives.

Outside of real estate, Amy’s favorite thing to do is spend time with her family which includes her husband Casey, daughter Stella (11), and daughter Zoe (8). Amy loves anything outdoors and in her downtime, you will find her golfing, boating, hiking, and entertaining family & friends.

A logo with the text STAND READERSPICYSLAD READERSPICY2402124021
A text banner with the text SAD BEADERSPICY200222002220022

Amy McFarland’s Listings

a front view of a house with a garage
a living room with furniture and wooden floor
a living room with kitchen island furniture and a chandelier
a kitchen with a table and chairs
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances kitchen island granite countertop a sink a stove a refrigerator and island with wooden floor
a kitchen with refrigerator and cabinets
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances kitchen island granite countertop a sink and cabinets
a living room with furniture a rug and a fireplace
a living room with furniture and a fireplace
a living room with furniture a fireplace and a flat screen tv
a bedroom with a bed lamps and window
a bedroom with a bed and a window with chair
a bathroom with a sink toilet and shower
a living room with furniture and a window
a living room with furniture and a window
a bathroom with a sink a toilet and a mirror
a living room with furniture and a couch
a living room with furniture and wooden floor
a living room with furniture and a rug
a bathroom with a toilet a sink a vanity and mirror
a utility room with dryer and washer
a view of a room with wooden furniture
a view of a house with a yard and sitting area
a view of balcony with deck wooden floor and outdoor seating
a view of deck with patio
a front view of a house with a yard

Courtesy of NWMLS

Listed By CompassPending


Square Feet