Andrew McElhinney

Andrew Mcelhinney

RealtorĀ®

Awards

RealTrends Verified - 2025

Specialties

  • Luxury & Waterfront Properties
  • Golf Course Properties
  • Off-Market Opportunities
  • Land & Development
  • Investment Properties
  • Real Estate Consulting
  • Client Testimonials

    Scroll down for more

    ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…
    "We are currently working with Andrew after being referred. The trust factor hit immediately with Andrew as he hit the property putting together a punchlist, action plan and educating us on the market in preparation to hit the market quickly. In week 1 of marketing Andrew had matured 8 showings and 1 solid offer with others potentially coming. Andrew is passionate about the island building a fantastic reputation. He is the type of individual who puts 110% in every client engagement opportunity he gets. We can't recommend him enough." - James

    ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…
    "Andrew is the person you’ve been looking for to buy/sell your home or property on MVY. You will not find a more knowledgeable honest nice and collaborative person in real estate — and he won’t stop working for you until you get what you want. Andrew helped us find our dream house on the Vineyard because of his attention to detail and ability to find a property that met our needs." - Jenny

    ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…
    "Andrew is a gem. He’s honest, reliable and was always both easy to reach and totally supportive and proactive. Yet, he’s calm and kind and just made the whole nerve wracking process much less stressful. I’ve bought and sold a few homes and he was by far uniquely competent. Beyond that he showed real interest in the process so I felt as if I had a true ally. Thank you for all, Andrew!!" - Jayne

    ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…ā˜…
    "Andrew was a fantastic partner in our efforts to purchase a home on Martha’s Vineyard. His knowledge of the island and history and value of real estate on the island plus his honest approach signaled to us that we were in great hands. Andrew was also collaborative in our search and definitely took the time to hear what we were looking to buy. In the end we found the perfect home with Andrew and even though the sale closed he still checks in with us as we establish ourselves on the island. We would recommend Andrew to anyone looking for a home or rental on the island for the best, most comprehensive, caring, and knowledgeable service." - Jenny


    ​​
    About Andrew

    Andrew McElhinney is a Martha’s Vineyard native with deep roots in the island community and a strong reputation for representing some of the Vineyard’s most notable properties. Since launching his real estate career in 2017, he has consistently delivered results across luxury waterfront, golf course, and development properties.

    His notable sales include one of the largest transactions in Edgartown in 2020, the historic 70-acre Cagney Estate in Chilmark, once owned by James Cagney, the highest single-family and land sale on Farm Neck Golf Club, and the sale of ā€œThe Swindleā€ at 662 Chappaquonsett Road in Vineyard Haven.

    Known for his discretion, local network, and strategic approach, Andrew works closely with buyers and sellers to provide a highly personalized real estate experience backed by deep market knowledge and strong island relationships.

    Outside of real estate, Andrew enjoys golf, boating, pickleball, and spending time with his wife and daughter on Martha’s Vineyard.

    Andrew Mcelhinney’s Listings

    a view of a big yard and front of a building
    an aerial view of a house with a garden
    a front view of a house with a yard
    a view of a city with tall buildings
    a view of a city
    a view of an ocean
    a living room with furniture a fireplace and a large window
    a dining room with furniture a floor to ceiling window and wooden floor
    a living room with furniture white walls and white walls
    a view of a livingroom with furniture a fireplace chandeliers fan
    a living room with stainless steel appliances kitchen island granite countertop a sink cabinets and wooden floor
    a dining hall with stainless steel appliances kitchen island granite countertop a sink and large windows
    a dining room with furniture and a floor to ceiling window
    a bedroom with a bed and a large window
    a white bath tub sitting in a bathroom
    a spacious bathroom with double vanity a bathtub mirror and a shower
    a bedroom with a bed and a window
    a view of empty room with wooden floor and window
    a view of a dining room with furniture
    a bathroom with a sink double vanity and a mirror
    a spacious bedroom with a large bed and a large window
    a bathroom with a sink a toilet and shower
    a living room with furniture gym equipment and a fireplace
    a bathroom with a sink and a mirror
    a bedroom with a bed and ceiling fan
    a bedroom with a white bed and a chandelier
    a bathroom with a shower sink and mirror
    a living room with furniture and flat screen tv
    a bathroom with a double vanity sink mirror and a bathtub
    a living room with furniture and a wooden floor
    a bedroom with a bed and a chandelier
    a bathroom with a sink toilet and shower
    a bedroom with a bed and a table in it
    a bathroom with a sink a toilet and mirror
    a living room with furniture and a table
    a view of a room with gym equipment
    a bathroom with a toilet a sink and a mirror
    a kitchen with white cabinets and sink
    a view of a walk in closet
    a view of an empty room with a window
    $8,900,000 | 150 East Chop Drive, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
    1/41
    Listed By Compass

    $8,900,000

    8
    Bedrooms
    8,170
    Square Feet
    0.64
    Acres
    a view of a lake in middle of the town
    a view of a city
    a view of a lake
    a view of a lake
    an aerial view of a houses with a lake view
    a view of a lake
    a view of a lake with a houses
    a view of a city
    a view of a terrace with chairs
    $3,995,000 | 98 Farm Neck Way, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
    1/10
    Listed By Compass

    $3,995,000

    Unavailable
    Bedrooms
    Unavailable
    Bathrooms
    Unavailable
    Square Feet
    1.92
    Acres
    an aerial view of a houses with a yard
    an aerial view of houses with yard
    an aerial view of residential houses with outdoor space and trees
    1/3
    Listed By Compass

    $675,000

    Unavailable
    Bedrooms
    Unavailable
    Bathrooms
    Unavailable
    Square Feet
    0.23
    Acres
    an aerial view of a houses with a yard
    an aerial view of a house with a garden and yard
    a view of a green field
    1/3
    Listed By Compass

    $625,000

    Unavailable
    Bedrooms
    Unavailable
    Bathrooms
    Unavailable
    Square Feet
    0.34
    Acres

    Andrew Mcelhinney’s Transactions

    Past Sales
    a view of a swimming pool with an outdoor seating and a garden

    $12,900,000

    6
    Bedrooms
    3,751
    Square Feet
    1.2
    Acres
    a view of a lake with a floor

    $6,825,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,914
    Square Feet
    1.58
    Acres
    a view of a large garden with a house in the background

    $6,600,000

    6
    Bedrooms
    2,914
    Square Feet
    69.2
    Acres
    an aerial view of a houses with outdoor space and lake view

    $6,400,000

    4
    Bedrooms
    5,023
    Square Feet
    2.56
    Acres
    a front view of a house with garden

    $2,500,000

    5
    Bedrooms
    4,982
    Square Feet
    2
    Acres
    a front view of a house with garden

    $2,500,000

    4
    Bedrooms
    2,364
    Square Feet
    0.78
    Acres
    an aerial view of a house with a yard and trees

    $2,300,000

    5
    Bedrooms
    4,329
    Square Feet
    2.11
    Acres
    an aerial view of residential houses with outdoor space and trees

    $2,250,000

    3.50
    Acres
    $1,935,000 | 34 Davis Street, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568

    $1,935,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    2,453
    Square Feet
    0.34
    Acres
    a view of a city with an ocean beach

    $1,925,000

    4
    Bedrooms
    3,376
    Square Feet
    5.01
    Acres
    front view of a house with a yard

    $1,739,000

    5
    Bedrooms
    5,012
    Square Feet
    0.94
    Acres
    a view of a house with a yard

    $1,585,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    2,853
    Square Feet
    4.95
    Acres
    a front view of a house with a garden

    $1,575,000

    4
    Bedrooms
    2,770
    Square Feet
    1.40
    Acres
    $1,525,000 | 26 Davis Street, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568

    $1,525,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    2,200
    Square Feet
    0.44
    Acres
    $1,525,000 | 26 Davis Street, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568

    $1,525,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    2,200
    Square Feet
    0.44
    Acres
    a front view of house with yard and outdoor seating

    $1,485,000

    5
    Bedrooms
    3,020
    Square Feet
    1.91
    Acres