Kaitlynn McCartney

Kaitlynn McCartney

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Social Media

Facebook LogoFacebook
Instagram LogoInstagram
  Compass Concierge Logo Kaitlynn’s Concierge Page

Client Testimonials

Scroll down for more


Kaitlynn provided my family and I with an amazing experience finding our forever home, and selling our starter home. She had a team of experts who, along with her expertise and skill set, could not have created a better experience for us. I would recommend Kaitlyn to anyone looking for a smart, knowledgeable, personable and authentic agent who will advocate for you during the entire process.- Gina Sartori


We recently had the absolute pleasure of working with Kaitlynn as she helped us find our dream home! Throughout the whole process Kaitlynn was responsive, honest, straightforward and always kind- qualities that are tough to come by in real estate these days. She was there for us in the early stages of house hunting when we weren't exactly certain of what we were looking for. She eventually introduced us to our dream home- an off market property that we never would have seen had we not been working with Kaitlynn! She is truly amazing at what she does and we could not thank her enough for helping us through the entire house hunting process! - Kaitlin McLaughlin


My husband and I recently worked with Kaitlynn when purchasing our new home! Her attention to detail, amazing communication, and warm, caring personality are only a few of the reasons why we love her. She gave us white glove service every step of the way. If you’re looking for the best in the business, look no further! - Danielle Cruz


Kait is great! She was patient, listened to our needs, and gave us professional advice that ultimately landed us in the perfect home. Her team (attorney, inspector, mortgage broker) were all exceptional and made the transaction streamlined and simple. Highly recommended! - Michael Beasly

I worked with Kaitlynn to buy my first apartment! Kaitlynn is very knowledgeable about the market and was able to give me great advice throughout the entire buying process. She guided me, step by step, from beginning to end. I can’t recommend Kaitlynn enough for her knowledge, dedication and exceptional communication!.- Erica Jacobs

5 stars!!! From open house to closing, and finally move in day… our experience could not have been more smooth. Working with Kaitlynn was easy and of course had a super personal touch. Her passion shows in her work and she has a natural talent for helping others. My husband & I absolutely loved having the pleasure of working along side Kaitlynn and her team. Not once did we have any doubts and everything was explained thoroughly during the entire process. She is the most genuine and down to earth person who truly loves her job & we are so grateful to have found our dream home with her guiding us along the way. - Kristina Sippel

We recently had the pleasure of working with Kaitlynn to purchase a new home, and we cannot express enough how impressed we were with her professionalism, expertise, and dedication. From the first open house to closing day, Kaitlynn went above and beyond to make the entire process smooth and enjoyable. She helped us navigate through an extremely competitive housing market from ’21-’23, and never once let off the gas. She made sure we were the first set of buyers to see a new listing on the market. She truly is a “buyers” agent and went above and beyond to ensure we had our bases covered during the contract negotiation. Kaitlynn is a true professional and we have already recommended her to several close friends. - Richard Madramuthu

Kaitlynn has been nothing short of amazing. She has been professional, personable and knowledgeable throughout the entire experience. I felt comfortable asking her any and all questions and she was always quick to respond. This entire process has been smooth and positive I would recommend Kaitlynn 1000 times over! - Claudia Kennedy

It was such an awesome and easy experience working with Kaitlynn! Told her the type of house we were looking for and within hours she had a list of houses that checked off all of our boxes. Kaitlynn was on top of everything and kept us in the loop with all the moving parts of buying a home. She truly made this whole process stress-free and I will be recommending her to anyone I know looking to buy/sell a home. - Joe Kennedy

I cannot say enough when it comes to Kaitlynn. She is amazing at everything she does. She guided me through the home buying process the entire time with extreme ambition and dedication in finding the perfect home for me. Kaitlynn assisted me in my journey every step of the way. She answered my constant questions professionally with the patience of a saint. She put me in contact with trusted associates. She gave me her honest opinions and advise until together we found my dream home. I recommend Kait 1000%. She is a true professional with an amazing friendly attitude like no other. - Lauren R

Working with Kaitlynn was the best experience from start to finish! As first time home buyers we had many questions and concerns throughout the process. Kaitlynn was always very responsive and walked us through the entire process putting us at ease. She really took the time to get an idea of what we were looking for and worked hard to get us the perfect house! She is attentive, knowledgeable, and a true professional. We couldn’t be happier! You will not be disappointed going with Kaitlynn!! - Amanda Johnson

Working with Kaitlynn was an absolute pleasure! I recently worked with her to purchase my first home in Nassau County. She was very informative, responsive and helped guide me throughout this process as a first time buyer. Kaitlynn was very professional and was always willing to go above and beyond to help me througout this purchase. I would absolutely recommend working with Kaitlynn!. - Tara Riordan

After looking for years, we were about to give up on finding a home that checked all of our wants/needs. As soon as our house hit the market, she knew it was the perfect home, she got us an appointment immediately and worked tirelessly to make it ours. To us, we never wanted to be pushed into buying something we didn’t want. She always listened, and showed us what fit our criteria, and then took note of what we liked/didn’t like. She is a true professional and we will recommend her to all who have real estate needs. We are forever in her debt for finding our forever home. - Sue C

Kaitlynn is the best. Knowledgable, caring and very professional. She provides a world class experience.. - Michelle Giaccio

My sister and I engaged Kaitlynn’s services in the sale of our childhood home. The sale of this house was a very emotional experience for us both. Kaitlynn, however, held our hands throughout the entire process. She was patient, understanding, knowledgeable and a true professional. I highly recommend Kaitlynn for all your real estate needs. She is by far the best in the business. - Carol Solferino

Kaitlyn helped us with the purchase of our home in Nassau County. She was knowledgeable and swift, and always had a recommendation for any type of professional we needed to close our transaction and move to our new place. Highly recommend! - Joanna Moloney

In my life I dealt with several realtors but the one that impressed me the most is Kaitlynn. She is professional, personal, caring, reliable and a pleasure to work with. Whenever I had a question she was very responsive to my texts or calls, she took the time to listen and give an answer. She has great follow through and on top of everything. She goes above and beyond and I strongly recommend her. - Dorothy W

What can we say about Kaitlynn?! She delivered us a fantastic experience with even better results. She was able to sit down with us and make us feel super comfortable on what or goal and objectives were. Her communication was superb and we were in-the-loop throughout the whole process. Upon listing, an open house was scheduled and shortly after the open house, offers started to come in. We had a meeting to discuss all the options. s Some negotiation took place with our eventual buyer, which Kaitlynn was again spectacular. She sold our home and took care of everything as if it was her own property. Can't say enough on how grateful we were for her assistance. If you're looking for a realtor for a sale, purchase, or both, there is only one call to make and it's to Kaitlynn McCartney - Michael Mauro

Kaitlynn McCartney is the BEST! Kaitlynn listed our home and she was so thorough, professional, and great to work with every step of the way. Having Kaitlynn was like having a friend on the “inside” that is working for you. She really cares about her clients as if she were going through this process to sell her own home. Any questions we came to her with, she had an answer for us right away. HIGHLY recommend Kaitlynn for the purchase and/or sale of any future homes. We are so happy we chose Kaitlynn!!! - Alexa W

Great realtor , informative , on time , supportive alone with being the best interior designer.. - Vanessa B

Kaitlynn is a real MVP in Real Estate! She went above and beyond to help us find and buy our first home! She is a real go getter and does anything she can to help make the process as easy as possible for us. If you need an agent she is your girl. You will not be disappointed!!!. - Tania W

Education

MBA, Finance - Adelphi University
BBA, Marketing - Adelphi University
About Kaitlynn
Born and raised on Long Island, Kaitlynn has vast knowledge and a wide understanding of real estate, spanning from Brooklyn to Montauk. Kaitlynn’s exposure to Long Islands' many towns and neighborhoods began early on. Growing up on Long Island, Kaitlynn's family and friends resided all across the island, from the north shore to south shore, and everywhere in between! Kaitlynn was instantly fascinated with Long Island and all its offerings. She also developed a strong love for homes and architecture from a very young age. When traveling from place to place, Kaitlynn would ask her parents and relatives to drive through specific streets and neighborhoods, just so she could admire her favorite homes. Through this natural attraction, her love for beautiful homes grew and her passion for real estate blossomed.

With a Bachelor’s degree in Marketing and an MBA in Finance, Kaitlynn possesses the ultimate combination of creativity and business acumen. Kaitlynn’s background in financial budgeting allows her to serve and guide her clients far beyond the closing table. Her proficiency in finance enables her to serve clients through informative decision-making strategies, providing them the necessary tools to meet their real estate-related goals. A former USA gymnast, Kaitlynn approaches negotiations with the same competitive flare that she later mastered in business school. Today, Kaitlynn treats her clients like family as she guides them through the most important transaction of their lives. Kaitlynn’s passion for homes and helping others shines through as she goes above & beyond to serve her clients and make their dreams a reality. Her unwavering attentiveness and a deep sense of compassion toward her clients are truly unmatched in today’s real estate industry. Kaitlynn’s clients are guaranteed a stress-free and enjoyable experience, so they can relax and focus on their next move!

Kaitlynn McCartney’s Listings

a aerial view of a house with garden
a view of an entryway with wooden floor and door
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop a stove refrigerator and cabinets
a view of an empty room with wooden floor and a window
an empty room with wooden floor cabinet and windows
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances a stove and cabinets
a large kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a wooden cabinets
a view of an empty room with window and cabinet
a living room with furniture and kitchen view
a living room with a flat screen tv and a fireplace
a living room with furniture and a flat screen tv
a bathroom with a sink a mirror and a toilet
a view of staircase with railing and a chandelier
a view of empty room with wooden floor and fan
a spacious bathroom with double vanity sink a two mirror a window a bathtub and vanity
a spacious bathroom with a shower sink and mirror
a view of walk in closet with empty racks
a view of a livingroom with a window and wooden floor
a view of an empty room with wooden floor and a window
a view of empty room with wooden floor and fan
a bathroom with a sink a mirror and a bathtub
a utility room with dryer and washer
an empty room with wooden floor and windows
a view of an empty room with wooden floor
a view of an empty room with wooden floor and windows
a view of an empty room with wooden floor and a window
a bathroom with a granite countertop toilet sink and mirror
an aerial view of a house with pool
a view of a house with a backyard
a view of house with yard and trees in the background
a view of a swimming pool with a patio
an aerial view of a house with a garden
a front view of a house with a yard and garage
a picture of a bathroom
1/35
Listed By CompassPending

$1,249,900

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
2.5
Square Feet
Unavailable
Acres
0.25
front view of a house with a yard
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop a sink stove and cabinets
a living room with furniture and a table
a living room with furniture a rug and a window
a kitchen with sink cabinets and wooden floor
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop a sink dishwasher a stove a dining table and chairs with wooden floor
a dining room with furniture and window
a living room with furniture and a fireplace
a bathroom with a sink a toilet and mirror
a spacious bedroom with a bed and wooden floor
a bathroom with a granite countertop toilet a sink and bathtub
a living room with furniture and a table
a bedroom with a bed and a dresser next to a window
a view of a storage room with gym equipment
a backyard of a house with lots of green space
a view of a house with a big yard and potted plants
a view of a house with backyard and sitting area
a view of a chairs on the roof deck
1/18
Listed By CompassPending

$849,000

Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1.5
Square Feet
Unavailable
Acres
0.12
1/10
Listed By Compass

$329,000

Bedrooms
1
Bathrooms
1
Square Feet
Unavailable