Keith Jacoby

Scroll down for more

"Keith brings a stellar skill set, a wealth of experience and a fantastic attitude to his work. We had a challenging property to sell in a prestige building, with a complicated ownership structure. In Keith, we had the perfect captain calmly and reassuringly guiding us all through the entire process, from pricing to staging, to listing, to contract negotiation, to financing, to closing. Nothing about this sale was simple, but it all went off without a hitch, thanks to Keith. He is completely indispensable!" - Jon L.

"We’ve had the pleasure of working with Keith on two property purchases on the Upper West Side, and we couldn’t recommend him more highly. From start to finish, Keith was incredibly thoughtful, communicative, and organized. He kept us informed and on task throughout every step of the process. His deep knowledge of the market and genuine care for his clients made what could have been a stressful experience feel seamless. Keith truly goes above and beyond to make sure his clients find the right home, and we’re so grateful for his guidance and professionalism. If you’re looking for someone you can trust to help you navigate the NYC real estate market, Keith is the one!" - Laura & Howard R.

"Keith was above and beyond any expectation that I had of a real estate agent. He was kind, warm, personable, and easy to talk to. He always made sure to center my needs and really took the time to listen. I never felt pressured at all. In fact, Keith was always encouraging about not settling until I truly felt satisfied. He combined authenticity and sincerity with a deep knowledge of the market, which was simply invaluable. Keith became much more than a real estate agent to me; he also became a friend. I feel so lucky that we crossed paths and I'm so grateful to him for all his help with all of my real estate endeavors". -E G.

"I worked with Keith to sell my apartment about a year ago, and I couldn’t have asked for a better experience. From our first meeting, he was organized, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping me achieve the best possible outcome. He guided me through every step of the process, from pricing strategy to staging and negotiation, with clarity and confidence. What stood out most was his calm professionalism and patience. I can be a bit anxious, especially during such a major life event, but Keith always took the time to listen, reassure me, and keep things in perspective. He anticipated potential challenges before they arose and handled everything seamlessly, which made a stressful process much easier to manage. I recommend him wholeheartedly to anyone looking for a real estate agent who combines deep market knowledge with honesty, communication, and care." - Liz H.

"Keith is not only an exceptional, respected and knowledgeable agent in this industry, but he is a kind, trusted and warm human being. He understands and respects the need of his clients first and foremost and handles them with sincere care and attention. To this date, I trust him to always find me the best tenants for my home and provide me with his utmost honest opinion. To add to the much complex residential market we all live in, he ensures to find the best value for my place and has ensure the process from start to finish (from execution of contracts, etc) is seamless. His acumen and personality make him rare in this industry and I am proud to have him on my team during this process and also now my friend!" - Payal P.

"Buying an apartment in NYC is notoriously stressful and complicated, but having Keith by our side made the entire experience manageable and ultimately successful. And dare I even say fun?From our very first meeting, Keith provided expert guidance through every confusing step of the co-op/condo process. What impressed us most was how incredibly knowledgeable he was about the market, current pricing, and neighborhood specifics. He could anticipate potential hurdles and always had clear solutions ready. Also, Keith is refreshingly honest and kind. We always felt like he prioritized our best interests over simply closing a deal. His guidance helped us make a confident, well-informed decision. The real test of how great our experience was with Keith is that when we decided to sell the apartment, we asked to work with him again! If you are looking to buy or sell property in New York, we would highly recommend Keith without any hesitation. He is a true and honest professional and an absolute asset to have on your team." - Allison A. & Tony R.

"I originally connected with Keith when he was representing the seller of a multi-family home in Williamsburg. I was not represented by a broker and Keith was a valuable partner in helping to navigate the sale while providing an honest and thoughtful perspective. Over the years, I have kept in touch with Keith, referred friends, and asked for a few favors. Keith has always been responsive, kind, authentic and genuine. One thing that I’ve always valued is that Keith never applied pressure tactics or made me want to avoid his calls :) he knows that if it was meant to be, it will work out and he’s there to make the process as seamless as possible for all parties. Highly recommend." - Leslie B.

"My husband and I first met Keith Jacoby in 2018, and since then, whenever we have needed a tenant or had questions about buying or selling real estate, we have reached out to Keith for his advice. From the very beginning, Keith has been approachable, attentive, and truly listens to our needs. He consistently provides the right solutions and ensures a proper match with tenants. What stands out most about Keith is his responsiveness and professionalism—he communicates quickly via email or text and is always available when we need guidance. He is honest, trustworthy, and genuinely cares about his clients. We feel confident and supported working with him, and it’s easy to see why so many people have said how much they enjoy working with a realtor who is reliable, knowledgeable, and personable. We highly recommend Keith for anyone seeking a real estate professional who combines expertise with a warm, client-focused approach." - Apriya J. & Ishwar B.

"I moved back to New York in 2013 and had the good fortune of being introduced to Keith as I searched for a new residence. I was sort of in between buying and renting and Keith was incredibly patient and willing to work on both possibilities. Initially I ended up renting for a couple years but ended up purchasing. Once again, I leaned on Keith to lead me through the byzantine world of NYC real estate. He patiently showed me dozens of properties over more than a year before I finally settled on a co-op in Tribeca. But it didn't end there. I was relocated out of the country a few years later and found a need to sell, remotely and during pandemic!. Once again, Keith stepped up and ended up securing a deal, all while I was out of country. Keith is not just an amazing professional realtor but a genuine stellar human being!" - Terri M.

"I’ve worked with Keith on every place I’ve lived in New York, starting as a renter and then as a buyer. He is very honest about the market and immensely patient—we spent over a year finding the perfect place to buy, and he never pressured me to make a hasty decision. He made the complicated process clear and easy for me as a first-time buyer, and gave great advice on what questions to ask and what to look for. He’s also flexible, arranging viewings on short notice and in limited timeframes, and he’s gone above and beyond on a number of occasions, including connecting me with a broker when I moved out of state for a few years. Should I need a broker in the future, he’s my first choice." - Zoe T.

"Keith was indispensable in working through the crazy process that is buying a home in New York City. He was a true partner in the process from day one, taking the time to understand what we were looking for and helping us find the best home that fit our unique needs. His detail-oriented approach helped us stay organized during the purchase process and streamline what can otherwise be a confusing process for a first-time home buyer. Keith is a true expert when it comes to real estate and I highly recommend working with him!" - Vineeth R.

"I first met Keith over a decade ago when he helped me find a rental in the city, and I've gone back to him again and again since whenever I needed help navigating the market. He most recently helped my wife and I sell our old place and buy a new one within a tight window. We always appreciated his diligence and his patience, but what drew us back to him time and again was how he made us feel he had our best interests in mind. We never felt pressured towards any particular option, and we never felt judged about our criteria for a perfect home, however pie-in-the-sky they may be. He understood what we wanted, and he kept helping us look until we found what we wanted, and not what we could tolerate. We couldn't have found a better person to be our guide." - Jeff D.

"Working with Keith Jacoby was genuinely incredible. Manhattan real estate is famously chaotic, but Keith made the entire process feel clear, manageable, and even fun. His patience is unmatched — he took the time to really understand what we wanted, answered every question, and walked us through each step with so much calm and confidence that we always felt supported. What really stood out was how deeply he cared about getting it right for us. He showed up with thoughtful guidance at every turn, anticipated challenges before they hit, and somehow made even the complicated parts feel like we had all the time in the world. His knowledge of Manhattan is exceptional, but it was his kindness and genuine investment in our experience that made all the difference." - Jenni R.

"Keith was instrumental in securing the last two tenants for my Manhattan apartment. I am most impressed with his understanding about the ever changing local real estate market. He is super organized and kept me updated throughout the process when handling applications, background checks and in preparing the lease agreements. He is always available to answer questions at any time during the year even when a deal is not in process. Keith is a true professional with strong communication skills and is personable, honest and just a nice guy. I feel so fortunate to have found Keith and will continue to deal with him in any of my future real estate needs." - James G.

"Working with Keith was a delight. He is a calming presence in what could otherwise be a stressful process. Our needs were always at the center of the discussion and we always felt our interests were prioritized. Thanks Keith!" - Ginny C. & Gustave K.

"Working with Keith was an excellent experience from start to finish. He was responsive, knowledgeable, and truly went above and beyond to make the home buying/selling process smooth and stress-free. I couldn’t have asked for a better partner in such an important decision." - Charlotte W.

"Highly recommended! We met Keith as first time buyers in 2018. He made us feel comfortable throughout the process of navigating the daunting NYC landscape. Keith is intelligent, professional, genuine, patient, and committed. We continue to recommend him to this day." - Liz S. & Joe D.

"You are AWESOME. I have loved seeing how you've built your practice through building genuine connections with people and having such a good sense of the market. I've appreciated your time and attention over the course of the last 15 (!!) years, and I hope we will actually get something done soon! Thank you, also, for the many connections you've made with your family for me at different points in time. It's been so nice to meet everyone!" -Aveek M.