Marsha Andrews

Marsha Andrews

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker


Top 1% Producer of Closed Sales 

#1 Top Grossing Agent in Office/190 Agents


Certified Negotiation Expert
Client Testimonials

Scroll down for more:  

"Marsha Andrews is a miracle worker!  We undertook to sell my late mother’s apartment under far less than ideal circumstances; in addition to the apartment needing more cosmetic work than I was willing to subsidize, we were hampered by the restrictions imposed due to the COVID pandemic at its inception and the subsequent months of lockdown.  Marsha persevered with amazing good nature and a fierce determination, and despite obstacles that other brokers told me were insurmountable, she succeeded in selling the apartment for an excellent price in a less-than-friendly market.  She exceeded my expectations on every level.  Her can-do attitude, attention to detail, and willingness to always be available to me and to the prospective buyers made the entire sale process run much smoother than I could have hoped for.  Especially given the difficult circumstances we faced, Marsha truly did amazing work.  I cannot recommend her highly enough." - Craig Rhyne


"To Whom it May Concern:

     My spouse, Michael, and I have known Marsha Andrews for approximately six years when we moved into our apartment 9D.  She had represented the seller of our unit when we initially purchased back in 2016. That transaction went off without a hitch.

     During the subsequent years we have known her, Marsha has been a wonderful neighbor and a good friend.  Living primarily in NJ, Michael and I would only use the apartment a few times each month.  Living in the apartment next door to us, Marsha would check ours if asked and would inform us if there were any potential issues. Her help was invaluable during the Covid pandemic when neither of us went into the city for almost two years. She graciously assisted in being our eyes and ears when we had a plumbing issue that needed to be addressed when neither my spouse nor myself could oversee.

     When we decided to sell our apartment in 2021, Marsha was absolutely the person we wanted to handle our listing.  She knows the building like the back of her hand and living on-site has a vested interest to make sure everything goes off without incident. Through her network of connections she immediately found buyers for our unit and it was off the market in a flash.  As a matter of we didn’t we have to do an Open House!!

     In short, I would absolutely employ the services of Marsha Andrews as realtor again and would wholeheartedly recommend to anyone considering her." - Rick Holloway & Dr. Michael Cali

"Marsha has been my “rock” during the difficult time of selling a dear friend’s apartment. Not only is she a consummate professional, she is an amazing person. Marsha went above and beyond; staging the apartment, helping with things that didn’t fall under her job description, keeping me updated on everything that was happening, answering every question, and always being there to lend a helping hand. Marsha knows every aspect of the real estate business and will be able to guide you through the process of buying and/or selling your property, and makes it feel almost effortless. I highly recommend Marsha, and would definitely use her again. " - Marilyn Wexler

"I can’t imagine any broker being more dedicated to the sale of my apartment. Marsha went the extra mile, going above and beyond what the typical agent would do to market my apartment. In a very short period, she brought me a qualified buyer at a meaningful price. She’s also a delightful human being, and she made process as effortless as possible.”  - Kyle Young

"Looking for a new home can be enjoyable, but it is often stressful. Marsha really understands the many challenges one encounters in this process and her knowledge and positive attitude helped us navigate the maze of protocol and paperwork that is the New York City real estate market. We now live in a lovely apartment thanks to her, and I appreciate her patience and perseverance.– R.N.

"Marsha couldn't have been more helpful. Since I was a first-time buyer I had many questions and anxieties. She was incredibly sensitive to my schedule and time constraints and always helped me remember deadlines. She had immediate answers for all of my questions and has a large pool of resources. After she sold me my condominium, I asked her to help me find a renter. She was thorough and careful and I'm very pleased with the result. Marsha is a gem and I would definitely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or rent an apartment." - Ann S.

"I know several residential real estate agents that understand the Manhattan cooperative and condominium markets very well. But only one person would I recommend 1000%, Marsha Andrews. Why? Numerous reasons but most relevant are the following: (1) experience; (2) works for one of the most prestigious Manhattan real estate firms; (3) personality (down to earth, a Midwestern woman); and most importantly (4) hungry with a relentless drive to satisfy her clients and do so with grace. I have known Marsha for 12 years, she was a neighbor on the Upper West Side and for the record Marsha is an accomplished opera singer. I highly encourage you to use her services. I would bet my twin girls on her!" - David H.


"Marsha came to the rescue in the middle of a long and arduous search for a new apartment. She found me a great apartment that fit all of my requirements. She was also persistent in tracking down and following up with the agents at another real estate company who had promised, and then not delivered, money back when a deal fell through."   - Minda A.

"Marsha is easy going, non-assuming, personable and she is honest and works really closely with the client. She is a good listener so she understands what the client wants. She helped us find a great apartment on the Upper West Side, in which we have been happily living in for the last eight months. I appreciated all that she did and she found us the best apartment in NYC. I would definitely work with her for my next home." - Peter L. & Eric Yu

"Marsha is a rare breed in the world of realtors: her top priority is that she actually wants her clients to find the best home. She is honest, easy to be around, works hard and also has an excellent way of diffusing tense situations that may occur during the process of finding a living space." - Peter C.

"Marsha is a great friend and supporter. I would not have found the home of my dreams without her expertise and caring, knowledge and honesty. I have known her for many years and this aspect of her talent has proven to be another seal of a great rapport and talent!"- Juliette S.


"The only thing worse than moving - and the horrors of packing and unpacking - is selling your current abode and buying a new one. Wherever you are in that process, the only way to survive with your sanity intact is to have an ally. Enter Marsha Andrews, a consummate professional who will listen (there's a lost art) to you and what you're looking for and then mobilize her resources and apply her knowledge and multiple skills on your behalf. Call Marsha and you will discover one of the most caring human beings in the real estate business- a pro who routinely works around the clock on behalf of her clients. How do I know? I'm a former client. A satisfied client. A grateful client. And I highly recommend her." - Sanford E.

About Marsha
Marsha Andrews’s passion for real estate is born of the reality she is hard-wired to help people and find harmonious solutions to every challenge. What better way to help than finding a home to suit the dreams, needs, and tastes of a buyer or renter and, conversely, finding the perfect price and buyer for the seller? Marsha is originally from the Midwest but has lived in New York City for more than 30 years. She knew immediately upon arrival she was finally home and is a resident of the Upper West Side. As time is always of the essence, buyers, sellers and renters appreciate her extensive knowledge of Manhattan, the real estate market climate and her relentless expedition to help her clients reach their goals.

Having enjoyed a fulfilling career singing opera, concerts, oratorios, and recitals throughout the USA, Europe and at the Metropolitan Opera, Marsha seamlessly translates her opera stage mis-en-scène vision to real estate. She has a trained eye for quality using it to stage apartments and her goal has been to research every minute detail, no matter what the task.  She has weathered every market having started July 1, 2008, just before the "downturn!" She works tirelessly to get her clients to the closing table.

Marsha earned a BA in music and French from Alma College, an MM in vocal performance from The Cleveland Institute of Music and Case Western University, and a Diplôme de Langue Française and Certificat de Français parlé from L'Alliance Française and L'Institut Catholique, Paris. She is fluent in French and Italian and has a working knowledge of German. She is a member of the Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY), has a love for life and people and a commitment to excellence.

141 W 26th Street, 2nd Floor


239 Central Park West, Unit 6B


212 W 75th Street, 5G


875 5th Avenue, 19A


15 West 72nd 19F

Marsha Andrews’ Listings

Listed By Compass
3 BD
3.5 BA
Listed By Compass
3 BD
3 BA
3,500 SF