• Our Agents
  • Buy
  • Sell
  • Rent
  • New Developments
  • Lindsay Rothman, Agent in NYC - Compass

    Lindsay Rothman

    Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

    About Lindsay

    With an amazing eye for design, Lindsay Rothman helps clients see possibilities they might otherwise have missed, whether that's helping a seller to maximize their own property's best features or guiding a buyer who has overlooked a diamond in the rough.

    Lindsay got her start in the business by staging the homes of friends and family members, nearly all of which sold within weeks, proving that she had a natural gift for real estate marketing. Today, Lindsay applies that talent throughout her native Westchester County where loves helping clients see the possibilities in something that isn't perfect and assisting those relocating to the suburbs from the city, as she did herself.

    Prior to real estate, Lindsay was a special education teacher, an experience that formed important skills she uses to this day. "Being a teacher not only taught me how to communicate clearly, but it also taught me how to really listen, with patience and empathy," she explains. "It also gave me the thickest skin you can imagine!" In her free time, Lindsay loves spending time with friends and family, staying active and sampling Westchester's amazing restaurants.

    Lindsay has joined The Spiegelman-Rothman Team at Compass as their Westchester specialist.


    2 El Retiro, Irvington, New York

    An oasis only 19 miles from New York City, 2 El Retiro is one of Westchester's premier Mediterranean estates. Totaling over 2 acres, this former residence of the famed NYC developer, Michael E. Paterno, has been restored to its original glory and updated with all modern luxuries. The main mansion features 7 bedrooms, 9 bathrooms (7 full, 2 half), boasts soaring ceilings, original stained glass windows and doors, a terra-cotta roof and multiple Juliette balconies, terraces and stone patios. The living and dining rooms are ideal for formal large gatherings. The open floor design offers an elegant custom kitchen and a great room that flows seamlessly out to sweeping lawns and gardens, creating a unique space to accommodate any lifestyle. The spacious Master Suite features 2 fireplaces, a luxurious bathroom and sitting room. State-of-the-art geothermal technology assures energy efficiency throughout the ~11,357 sq.ft. main home.

    In addition to the main home, there is a detached 3,000 sq.ft. Guesthouse that includes 3 bedrooms, 4 baths, its own 2 car garage and an additional 2,000 sq.ft. pool house with an indoor heated pool, sauna, private deck, to create a spa-like retreat. The total sq. ft. for the estate is ~16,857.

    The grounds at El Retiro have been landscaped to evoke comfort and privacy. The "Quad" shaped lawn is surrounded by multiple seating areas including an outdoor fireplace providing endless days and nights of relaxation and enjoyment; perfect for intimate gatherings or events.

    Located in picturesque Irvington, NY only 19 miles outside Manhattan. Enjoy easy access to the Hudson River, Parks, Ball fields, Schools, Restaurants and the Metro North Railroad Station. A quick 35 minute ride to Grand Central Station.

    2 El Retiro is a true gem.

    For more information click here

    This is a co-exclusive with William Raveis Legends Realty Group.


    1419 Salt Point Turnpike

    Dutchess County country home just an hour and a half from New York City. Set back off the road, 1419 Salt Point Turnpike, which totals over 47 acres of land, offers an unmatched sense of tranquility. Drive up the extended driveway past the guest house and horse stable to arrive at your ideal country home. The current configuration includes the primary home, a detached guest house and a horse stable.

    For more information click here

    Lindsay Rothman’s Recent Transactions