Dustin Sickinger, Real Estate Agent

Social Media

Facebook

Dustin’s Concierge Page

Specialties

First time Homebuyers | Indianapolis, IN
Relocation REALTOR® Indianapolis, IN
New Construction Expert | Indianapolis, IN

Education

CRS Certified Residential Specialist, RRC 2020

Real Estate Academy of Leadership 2016

Butler University, Marketing 2005

Client Testimonials

★★★★★

Dustin was a critical part of making our relocation from Chicago to Indianapolis as seamless as possible. In helping us find our new home, he was so great about listening and understanding our "wants/needs" while also making sure he set expectations appropriately. A perfect balance. He is smart, hard working and extremely knowledgeable about real estate/the Indy Market. From the beginning of the process to the end (including follow-up after we moved in), Dustin was thorough and attentive in every way. He is a true professional and we are certain that one of the best decisions we made was to hire him as our realtor. We will be recommending him and family and friends in the future! Melissa N.

★★★★★

Working with Dustin was a great decision for us. As first time homebuyers, we knew little about how the process worked or what to expect. Dustin made us comfortable from the beginning by taking the time to explain things and listening to our thoughts on what we wanted so he could find us the places we were most likely to call home. We so appreciated his honesty and persistence in helping us narrow down what we wanted and, ultimately, finding the perfect home for us. We would absolutely work with Dustin again - highly recommended! - Jessica R

★★★★★

Dustin was a great ally throughout the process of selling our home and buying a new one. He did a pre-sale walkthrough of our existing home showing us areas we needed to fix before we put the home on the market. He gave us extremely valuable insight on how to price our home competitively. Based on his advice and the photography he and his team shot of our home, we had two excellent offers on the day we listed the property! While finding our new home, Dustin was a tireless and essential advisor, providing insight into costs associated with upgrading or fixing elements of the homes and guiding us through the buying process. We couldn't be happier with the process or the outcome, which says a lot about Dustin. -Todd B

★★★★★

My husband, Derek and I were blessed to have the pleasure to work with Dustin on the sale of our last home. Though not our first selling experience, Dustin and his team made the process a breeze, from start to finish. He was extremely knowledgeable, provided unique marketing ideas and was always right there to guide us through the process...from offer to closing. He worked tirelessly to spread the word and utilized innovative marketing techniques to drive traffic and interest in our home. We highly recommend Dustin for the sale or purchase of your next home. Trust us, you'll be thankful you did. -Julie B

About Dustin

Executive Summary

Referral based Realtor in Indianapolis with 16+ years of industry experience, full time Realtor since June of 2013. Recognized for a consultative approach, deep expertise in new construction and redevelopment, and a reputation for exceptional client service. Trusted Real Estate Advisor, and industry leader committed to strengthening communities and advancing professional standards. Dustin lived across the U.S. and in Canada and Switzerland before arriving in Indianapolis in 2001. Having lived here for more than half his life, he considers himself an adopted Hoosier at heart. Dustin holds a bachelor's degree in marketing from Butler University and resides in Steinmeier Estates in Washington Township.

Career Highlights

• 200+ homes sold in Central Indiana with a strong referral-based business model

• Five Star Professional for Customer Service (2020–2025)

• Featured in Forbes Magazine and Indianapolis Business Journal

• Rookie of the Year (2014) Keller Williams Indy Metro N

• Rising Star Award (August 2016 Issue) – Indy Real Producers Magazine

Leadership & Industry Involvement

• Secretary Treasurer — MIBOR REALTOR® Association (2026)

• Board of Directors – NAR National Association of REALTORS® (2026)

• Board of Directors -BAGI Builders Association of Greater Indianapolis (2026)

• Secretary Treasurer Elect — MIBOR REALTOR® Association (2024)

• Board of Directors — MIBOR REALTOR® Association (2022, 2023)

Education & Credentials

• MPRO Graduate – MIBOR Master Professional (2025)

• The Residential Real Estate Council – CRS Certified Residential Specialist (2020)

• Graduate, REAL Real Estate Academy of Leadership MIBOR (2016)

• Bachelor of Science in Marketing — Butler University (2005)