Stephen Baymack's Profile Photo

Stephen Baymack

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Social Media



 
Client Testimonials

Scroll down for more

★★★★★
"Stephen and Laura Baymack recently sold our house in Garden City and the entire experience greatly exceeded our expectations. The game plan from staging, marketing, negotiating and finally closing the property was flawlessly executed. We received several offers on the property and we were in contract within 2 weeks. The Baymack’s professionalism, knowledge and guidance proved invaluable and we would highly recommend speaking with them if you are thinking of selling your house."

★★★★★
"Imagine what you face when deciding to sell your house after residing there for 50 years. And you are going to downsize! Well, it seemed insurmountable to me until I met with Steve and Laura Baymack. They were at my side every step of the way with their kind support and professional expertise. I would like to call them the dynamic duo of Garden City real estate. To anyone who is planning to sell or buy a home, my wholehearted recommendation is contact Steve and Laura Baymack."

★★★★★
"My wife and I engaged Steve as our buyer’s agent when we purchased a larger home in Garden City. Steve successfully negotiated a sales price and terms to our liking. He exceeded our expectations of a real estate agent to ensure a seamless transaction. Key benefits of working with Steve include: 1. His strong interpersonal skills and his ability to quickly identify his clients’ needs; 2. His extensive knowledge of the Garden City real estate market; 3. His relationships and connectivity to local professionals to ensure a seamless sales process. It was a pleasure getting to know both Steve and his wife, Laura during the process. We would highly recommend Steve and Laura to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in Garden City."

★★★★★
"Absolutely perfect! Very knowledgeable about our exact location and Stephen and Laura were very friendly and helpful. We had been in this house for 39 years and in another a few blocks away for 18 years before that. Not having moved much, we were overwhelmed by the whole process however, Stephen and Laura calmed us down and held our hands through the whole process."

★★★★★
"The Baymack team sold our home in two days. It was the right price and the suggested advice to make the house sell quickly paid off. Very professional and highly experienced. We also purchased our next home with Stephen and it was a very smooth transaction also."

★★★★★
"Steve Baymack is everything you would want in a realtor. He is knowledgeable, honest, responsive, realistic and strategic. After living in GC for over 25 years, we made the decision to downsize. It was bittersweet leaving a home where you raised your children but Steve was compassionate and understanding. He made the process go smoothly from the beginning by staging the house and developing an amazing video to bringing the process to a close by negotiating the best deal - all during the typical low sales period after the holidays. He also went above and beyond in providing advice on buying a condominium that helped us move forward in that purchase. We would highly recommend Steve as the best realtor to use in Garden City and other Long Island areas. He is well connected to the communities he serves and really listens to your requests and keeps you focused. He is truly the best!"

★★★★★
"Stephen is the best real estate agent my wife and I have ever had the measure to work with but more importantly, he’s a genuine and amazing person. Stephen spent more than two years working with my family, quickly demonstrating his expert sense of both the market and our taste in location and homes. We came away from each visit with Stephen learning more about the community and housing market, and he NEVER made us feel the slightest bit of pressure, while ALWAYS proving to be our advocate. In the end he found us our dream home which was a byproduct of his hard work and ultimately incredible negotiating skills. We view Stephen as a friend now, and would find it incredible to believe anyone interested in homes to buy or sell in this area would think of using anyone else. He works harder than anyone I’ve seen, knows this market cold, and is an absolute pleasure to partner with."

★★★★★
"We had our home on the market for over a year with another agent - price range 2.7 million . My husband and I are professionals with a busy schedule .We were very disappointed at the lack of showings with our previous agent- we relied on our previous agent to price the home for sale . . We interviewed several top agents in town and Steve was the only one that came prepared with his lap top , knew we grieved our taxes got a great result , knew what permits were opened vs closed. Most of all took the time to show us all the listings he was successful on over the $2.0 price point ( without asking ). Steve was brutally honest when asked what price should we list to sell .. We followed his advice and had two offers an numerous serious showings with in several weeks . Sold the home 40 days later all cash deal , no contingencies. In summary - he is professional , ALWAYS available , extremely knowledgeable about infrastructure and our town /neighborhoods . Steve chose to come see us to discuss and speak face to face for weekly updates .. no texting or email - the real deal !!!"

★★★★★
"We recently purchased a home in Garden City and Steve Baymack did an incredibly masterful job navigating the process on our behalf. Steve’s level of responsiveness, communication and overall professionalism made the entire experience a pleasure and we really appreciated his win-win mentality. We highly recommend speaking to Steve Baymack if you are in market for a new home!"

★★★★★
"There are not enough superlatives to laud on Stephen Baymack. When the time came to sell our childhood home (after 59 years) in Garden City, I sensed we were in expert hands from the outset. Steve has a deep passion for what he does, and he does it with expertise, charm, and care. Ours was not a typical sale during the height of the pandemic, but Steve was with us at every turn, delivering to us a record sale price. And while selling a beloved childhood home is never easy, Steve somehow made it so. I highly and enthusiastically recommend, Stephen Baymack."

★★★★★
"When it came time to sell our house in Garden City, we knew there was only one call we needed to make – that was to Stephen Baymack. We had previously bought and sold a home in Garden City with Steve and once again the experience was tremendous. From start to finish Steve handled every aspect of the sale with precise detail and care and once again as in the past, we had multiple offers on the house within days that were just below, at, and even slightly above our ask price. With Steve’s guidance we selected the offer that worked best for our needs. I can say with confidence that if you are ever considering a real estate transaction there is just one call to make – that is to Steve Baymack!"

★★★★★
"Steve sold my wife and I our 1st home in Garden City 5 years ago and when it was time to look for another house, we both knew that Steve was the only realtor we would contact. Steve is an amazing realtor and a true professional - honest and very thorough. Steve's knowledge of Garden City and its market is outstanding. Steve would always provide us with his honest opinion and was patient with all of the questions we had on houses we saw on Zillow. Steve is also a great guy and we recommend Steve without any reservation to anyone looking to buy or sell their home."

★★★★★
"I felt during the listing process Steve and I had been working together for years. He is decisive and communicates well. We had several offers after the first open house. Steve handled the staging, photography, and any third party arrangements. He informed me of his plan and we just followed his advice, but if you don't have the time to commit to selling your house, Steve will take the reigns and treat your home like his own."

★★★★★
"First and foremost, Stephen's level of professionalism is second to none! From the first meeting to the closing, Stephen is there with you every step of the way. He is not simply an agent - he truly is a partner with you throughout the process and looks out for his client's best interests. Stephen is extremely knowledgeable, trustworthy, very thorough, honest, diligent and overall provided us with exceptional guidance and expertise! Our experience with Stephen was first rate and we would not hesitate to highly recommend him to anyone buying or selling a home. Thank you again for a great experience!"

★★★★★
"We trusted Stephen Baymack with the recent sale of a house. We were selling from out of state but never worried about the property, process, or closing with Stephen handling things. Stephen was pro-active in listing and selling the house - we had multiple, full price offers within days of listing. He was responsive to all of our out of state inquiries, and helpful with all of our local needs. He went above and beyond to meet our needs and handle all issues. He made a difficult situation easy. And he's a wonderfully nice person!"

★★★★★
"My family had the most amazing experience looking for and purchasing a home with Steve. Steve is a first class real estate professional and even better person. His vast knowledge about the buying process was extremely helpful for my fiancé and I, especially as first time buyers. We will recommend him to all of our friends and family who will go through this process. We look forward to continuing the friendship that was fostered over the past couple months."

★★★★★
"Steve is the #1 broker in Garden City. He helped us buy our new house and sell our existing simultaneously. The entire process was painless. Easy buy, quick sale, great prices, no stress. Can't ask for anything more. And his knowledge about the entire process is second to none. He guided us not only through the buy/sale, but he also recommended several top notch professionals, contractors, and mortgage brokers. Could not recommend enough. Thanks again, Steve."

★★★★★
"Steve made our homebuying experience so much smoother. He helped us understand so many things - from building regulations and certificates of occupancy to the differences in neighbourhoods and the subtle advantages of each one. He also advised us in putting forward the most appealing offer in a highly competitive market. When it comes to local knowledge, I’m not sure how Steve could be beaten - he seems to know everybody, and made many helpful introductions. Truly a pleasure to work with."

★★★★★
"My wife and I couldn’t be happier with the level of service provided by Steve. From our very first meeting, until we found our house, he was insightful, friendly and seemed to understand exactly what we were looking for. He always made time to suit our schedules and we felt he truly went the extra mile for our family. Wouldn’t hesitate for an instant to recommend him to others."

★★★★★
"My husband and I cannot recommend Stephen Baymack enough! He is unlike any other agent with his unmatched knowledge of real estate and the community, and his warm and friendly demeanor. We were very discerning and particular buyers but Stephen worked with us for several years, never losing patience or pushing us in the wrong direction. As first time buyers we required additional support and guidance and Stephen went above and beyond in every way! His insight and years of successful experience empowered us as we navigated a very competitive market. He was an absolute pleasure to work with both in the search and closing of the deal. We will certainly recommend Stephen to any buyer or seller in need, and will definitely use him for our future needs!"

★★★★★
"I first met Steve when he sold me my house in 2015. I was so impressed with his professionalism, patience and approachability that when I decided to sell that very same house this year (2021), I knew I wanted Steve to be my agent. He was beyond amazing! Steve took care of every detail, answered every question, and even helped with referrals for needed repairs (and the people he referred were fantastic too!). From the photos, to the open house, to the closing, Steve made sure that everything went as smoothly as possible and helped me deal with any issues that arose. He was on top of everything and knew exactly what was needed to get my house sold. Between that, his attention to detail and his patient, calm demeanor, he made one of the most stressful processes you can go through seem easy. I highly recommend him!"

Specialties

Buyer's Agent, Listing Agent, Relocation,
Staging, Property Management

Education

- Seton Hall University
- SUNY University at Albany

About Stephen
Stephen Baymack an accomplished full time real estate associate broker based in the Compass Garden City office has been providing exceptional customer service to his clients for the last 14 years. He and his team, including his wife, Laura, a full time real estate agent, treat every client with respect while focusing precise detail on every aspect of each transaction from start to finish. The results of this exemplary commitment to the highest standards in customer service are memorialized in the client testimonials at Zillow.com

A retired Captain of the New York Police Department, Stephen served the city as a dignified, reliable and trustworthy public servant. Stephen's final assignment in the department at the Facilities Management Division provided him with a unique insight into the mechanics, infrastructure and construction of buildings. Stephen’s in-depth knowledge of the local market, the real estate process and his ability to negotiate favorable terms for his clients are the cornerstone of his team's exceptional service.

Stephen possesses Master of Art degrees from Seton Hall University and SUNY University at Albany.

Over the last decade Stephen has consistently earned Top Producer awards and his team’s success is evidenced with their past sales: 

$405 Million sold over the last 9 years including $84 Million in closed and pending sales in 2023!

The Baymack Team’s commitment to their clients and their passion for real estate is the driving force behind their success!

Stephen Baymack’s Listings

1/36
Listed By Compass

$4,200,000

Bedrooms
8
Bathrooms
8
Square Feet
Unavailable
Acres
0.99
Listed By CompassPending

$4,100,000

Bedrooms
7
Bathrooms
6.5
Square Feet
6,000
Acres
0.46
1/36
Listed By CompassPending

$1,875,000

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
2.5
Square Feet
Unavailable
Acres
0.18
1/36
Listed By Compass

$1,758,000

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
3.5
Square Feet
3,200
Acres
0.14
1/36
Listed By Compass

$1,588,000

Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
4
Square Feet
3,000
Acres
0.18
1/33
Listed By CompassPending

$1,150,000

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
2
Square Feet
1,592
Acres
0.06
1/36
Listed By CompassPending

$999,000

Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
2
Square Feet
1,888
1/30
Listed By CompassNew

$888,000

Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
2.5
Square Feet
1,466
Acres
0.06