Toni Nicolo

Toni Nicolo

Licensed Associate Broker

Education

Client Testimonials

Scroll down for more

★★★★★
"It may be odd to say that your real estate agent is one of your favorite people, but I know of no other way to describe Toni Nicolo. I had never purchased a home in the City, and was torn about when I wanted to move, where I wanted to move, or even what type of home I wanted to buy – I felt overwhelmed and daunted, and told Toni that I had no idea how or when or where to begin. Toni jumped into action, and had me send her some apartments and homes I liked – and she was off. She started making appointments, made herself available at all hours and all days, and put up with me looking at places in both Manhattan and basically every corner of Brooklyn. We saw new construction, we looked at plans together, and we saw house and apartment after apartment (and discussed design and renovation tips all along the way), and ultimately made it possible for us to see what has become my house on the very first day it was on the market. She knowledgably guided me through the dreaded bidding war, and advised me on the letter I wrote to the sellers that made the difference – although I was not the highest bid, they accepted my offer – and the seller’s agent commented on how appreciative he was of Toni’s approach, and how reasonable she was to deal with. She continued to help me negotiate after the draft contract, and showed up for the inspection ready to test every electric socket. She held my hand – figuratively, this was all Covid, after all – through the whole process with the perfect balance of support, encouragement, excitement, and patience. Along the way she became my friend because she is also wonderful to spend time with, and has a true sense of design and appreciation for the aesthetic I was seeking, which I truly valued. I trust her, I value her opinion, and I would recommend her, unconditionally, to anyone looking to buy a home they love in New York. " - Brooke


​​
About Toni
Combining an analytical approach, abundant creativity and a passion for helping people, Toni Nicolo is a natural choice for buyers and sellers seeking a true advocate on their path to real estate success. She's incredibly detail-oriented and motivated by challenges, meaning there's no task too difficult or goal too lofty for her exceptional skill. Believing that every home should be a sanctuary, Toni feels a deep sense of commitment to her clients and works hard to execute seamless and successful transactions.

Toni honed her determination and negotiating prowess working as a litigator for more than a decade. She also nurtured her love of design as the proprietor of a Boerum Hill home furnishings store. In real estate, Toni is particularly skilled at understanding and connecting with people, assessing their needs, and providing thorough education and advice.

A native New Yorker, Toni is a graduate of the State University of New York at Albany and received her Juris Doctor from Brooklyn Law School. Having resided in Brooklyn since the 1990s, she is proud to remain rooted here with her husband and two children. She enjoys being surrounded by friends and family and dancing to music, whether in her living room or the cycling studio. Being a positive member of her community is of tantamount importance to Toni, and she gives generously to a variety of causes, including organizing an annual team for NY Cares Winter Wishes.

Toni Nicolo’s Listings

Listed By Compass
Contract Signed
VIRTUAL TOUR
$3,350,000
4 BD
3.5 BA
2,824 SF
Listed By Compass
Contract Signed
VIRTUAL TOUR
134 Summit Street

Carroll Gardens

$2,995,000
5 BD
4 BA
3,600 SF
Listed By Compass
Contract Signed
$1,995,000
2 BD
2 BA
1,200 SF
Listed By Compass
VIRTUAL TOUR
710 6th Avenue, Unit 6C

Greenwood Heights

$1,490,000
3 BD
3 BA
Listed By Compass
VIRTUAL TOUR
$1,349,000
2 BD
2.5 BA
2,158 SF
Listed By Compass
Contract Signed
VIRTUAL TOUR
$1,295,000
2 BD
2 BA
1,136 SF
Listed By Compass
VIRTUAL TOUR
$1,199,000
2 BD
2 BA
1,343 SF
Listed By Compass
VIRTUAL TOUR
710 6th Avenue, Unit 4C

Greenwood Heights

$1,079,000
2 BD
2 BA
Listed By Compass
VIRTUAL TOUR
49 Carroll Street, Unit 42A

Columbia Street Waterfront

$925,000
2 BD
1 BA