ToniAnn Cusumano

ToniAnn Cusumano

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson | Licensed as ToniAnn Cusumano-Solarz


Multi Million Dollar Club - 2018/2019
Top Producers Brooklyn - July 2019
Top Sales Team - 2018
Real Trends 100 Top Agents


Brownstone Brooklyn Sales Specialist
Buyers Agent
Certified Negotiation Expert
Construction Project Manager


New York University - Hotel Management
Swedish Institute College of Health Sciences
New York Real Estate Institute

Client Testimonials

Scroll down for more

"Our sale was not easy for many reasons, and personally difficult because 409 Union was our wonderful and loving home, for most of our lifetime. Upon meeting Toniann, I felt strongly that she would have the integrity that would be important for us throughout this process. Now, I wouldn’t be able to express all the heartfelt gratitude to her for everything she has done to make our sale a seamless process. She went over and above for us in many ways, and she has great contacts to make things happen when needed. Toni always remained sensitive and caring to our needs, with the patience to explain things as many times as it took for understanding. She is very generous. No one does what she does and that is what sets her apart from others. Toniann is a great person and a great business lady. We will always look forward to recommending her." - PattyAnn Morgera, Seller | 409 Union Street, Carroll Gardens | 03/20

"Toni is articulate and experienced. We were quickly impressed with the pride and passion in her work style. She has a strong knowledge of the business which protected us as her clients. She was responsive, respectful, and kind with us -- yet she was a formidable defender on our behalf when it was required. Toni is an influential businesswoman, and a complete pleasure to work with." -Kelly G., Seller | 291 Union Street, Carroll Gardens | 12/19

"Toni is a genius when it comes to staging and we sold for much more than I thought I could ever get. Had I known how well she would rearrange and fix up my apartment, I may have never moved! She managed every aspect on her own while I was already moved across the country. From doormen to moving companies to painting, cleaning, design, co-op board -- I mean everything. I did not have to do a thing. I signed her agreement and cashed my check. I am grateful she was my agent and I would recommend her to anybody."-David F., Seller | 111 Hicks Street, Brooklyn Heights | 01/17

"We were very fortunate to have ToniAnn on our team. She made our lives easier because she knew just what we needed before we knew we needed it. She proved that time and again with her knowledge of construction and the local market. Every time we viewed a property she would perform a methodical inspection, looking for signs of problems and commenting on the quality of the construction, foundation, finishes, appliances, etc. She protected us from overpaying and led us through multiple rounds of negotiations to get to the price and financing that suited us best. She was always available for us and our many questions. Her professionalism, mentorship, knowledge, honesty, and hard work ethic are much respected and greatly appreciated. ToniAnn is a true professional, bright, ambitious, articulate, and incredibly patient."- Susan Zeller, Buyer | Brooklyn Heights | 06/16

"I can't say enough about ToniAnn’s professional and true caring nature. She has this sense of calm trustworthiness that made us feel secure through the many twists of our complicated sale. She solved difficult problems for us and was always thoughtful and considerate. She really makes things happen. Great effort! She is an exceptional broker and special person."- Estelle Crosby, Seller | 164 Ainslie Street, Williamsburg | 08/16

"Toni is a real miracle worker. It was hard to believe everything would be completed on time there was so much to do, but somehow she did it all! She took care of everything. Cheers and many thanks!"- Alex O., Buyer | Carroll Gardens | 06/15

About ToniAnn
A highly experienced, award winning sales specialist, ToniAnn Cusumano has a long, steady history of achieving clients’ goals. Due to her unique background, she brings a wealth of knowledge to her clients, a nuanced negotiating style and the highest level of customer service to every transaction.

Specializing in residential sales, first-time buyers, and condo conversions from Brooklyn to Manhattan's Upper West Side, ToniAnn manages every aspect of the buying and selling process for her clients. From strategic pricing, negotiating, staging, marketing, to building effective rapport with the attorneys, bankers, appraisers, and agents affiliated with your deal.  Be it the smallest task to the most important detail, she delivers unparalleled service to meet the unique needs of every client- from the first conversation to the closing table. “I did not have to do anything! I signed her agreement and cashed my check.”- David F.- Seller, Brooklyn Heights.

Toni’s extensive experience literally begins from the ground up. As the daughter of the President of Construction for Ian Schrager and Lowes hotels, she grew up on construction sites and was hands-on building her family's homes. From learning how to sheetrock and use power tools, to reading blueprints and electrical maps, she excelled in the field at a young age. Inevitably she went on to buy, renovate and sell homes of her own, ultimately parlaying her passion for the business into a successful career. 

Having personally experienced every side of a deal, both personally and professionally, ToniAnn has a deep commitment to the significance of owning real estate and protects her client's interest as she would her own. As a result, she has successfully positioned nearly every one of her listings to sell at or above the asking price. She recently broke a record for negotiating the highest per-square-foot price ever paid for a condo resale in Carroll Gardens -291 Union Street, Brooklyn.  As a Brooklyn native, she not only has extensive knowledge of the ever-changing borough, but also a natural devotion to the success of her hometown neighborhood.

Prior to real estate, ToniAnn studied hospitality management at New York University and worked for some of the city's top hotels, catering to an international and celebrity clientele with the utmost care and discretion. She also holds a degree from the College of Oriental Medicine at the Swedish Institute and puts her knowledge of traditional oriental modalities to work in feng-shui staging and design.

Working with ToniAnn gives you the advantage of a having a seasoned professional with decades of experience and a concrete understanding of sales, business management, major construction components and good old-fashion integrity.  You will find her combined experience and refreshingly sincere approach helps set her apart as an insightful and effective representative who will expertly guide you through the complexity of one of life's most important decisions.

Exceptional Country Estate- Less Than 60 Minutes From NYC

Exceptional country dream home, only 60 minutes north of NYC. This custom built 6400sf palatial masterpiece over three levels includes five bedrooms, four full baths, three massive stone fireplaces, an au-pair or in-law guest home, a music studio, a family lounge with wet bar, cedar wood sauna and an in-ground heated swimming pool- all with no expense spared. Cathedral and vaulted ceilings with skylights in every main room, along with a tremendous amount of floor to ceiling windows gives you north, south, east and west exposures and a near impossible amount of natural light that brings the intricate patterns in the four-inch marble slabs, Brazilian hardwood floors and polished granite stone to life. The bi-level wrap around porch gives you the most breathtaking panoramic views of your full 1.1 acre whose unobstructed west facing backyard is a birds eye view of sizzling summer sunsets over the in ground pool and surrounding forest. There is also a four car garage allowing storage and protection for those who collect, or for every family members vehicle.

Less than 60 miles from NYC in Orange County, a stones throw to Woodbury Commons, Storm King and several skiing venues, 69 Helms Hill Road is an impressive country estate ready to welcome and indulge its lucky new owner.

Exceptional Country Estate- Less Than 60 Minutes From NYC

ToniAnn Cusumano’s Listings

Listed By Compass
Contract Signed
2 BD
1 BA