Last Sold Price
1 bed950 sqft$84/sqft
3310 Shay Rd, Italy, NY 14512

Description

Converted School House in the heart of the Finger Lakes. 11.5 acres and pond for hunting and recreation. Wine country, Hi Tor, even a golf course nearby. Open floor plan, stone fireplace, bed and bath. Deck, and outbuildings. Wonderful views of the hills and valleys. Skiing, boating, year'round fun. Square footage per tax records, acreage per new survey.Converted School House in the heart of the Finger Lakes. 11.5 acres and pond for hunting and recreation. Wine country, Hi Tor, even a golf course nearby. Open floor plan, stone fireplace, bed and bath. Deck, and outbuildings. Wonderful views of the hills and valleys. Skiing, boating, year'round fun. Square footage per tax records, acreage per new survey.
LISTING CLOSED: 05/27/2010 12:00 AM

  1. Listed by Catherine M. McWilliams • Nothnagle REALTORS
    P: (585) 398-2140 C: (585) 396-5299 cathymcwilliams@nothnagle.com

Property Details for 3310 Shay Road

Status
MLS #
R927423
Days on Market
189
Taxes
$2,045 / year
HOA Fees
-
Condo/Co-op Fees
-
Property Type
MLS Type
Residential / Single Family Residence
Year Built
1885
Lot Size
11.50 AC / 500,940 SF
Styles Of Residence
Historic Antique, Ranch
On Waterfront
No
Parking Description
No Garage
Nearest Cross Street
Route 364

Recent comparable sales

Median sold price

$230,000

Avg days on market

51

Sale-to-list ratio

85.9%

[Italy, NY]

9 comparable properties found

$75,000 | 3927 Shay Road, Italy, NY 14512
1/2
1

$75,000

Sold 03/11/25

1
Bedrooms
576
Square Feet
0.36
Acres
$249,900 | 2271 Dunn Road, Italy, NY 14418
1/2
2

$249,900

Sold 11/05/25

1
Bedrooms
960
Square Feet
5.00
Acres
$270,000 | 3861 Keysor Road, Italy, NY 14512
1/2
3

$270,000

Sold 07/23/25

2
Bedrooms
866
Square Feet
4.81
Acres
$275,000 | 2693 Pulver Road, Italy, NY 14418
1/2
4

$275,000

Sold 08/21/25

2
Bedrooms
874
Square Feet
6.72
Acres
$230,000 | 5423 Highlands Drive, Italy, NY 14418
1/2
5

$230,000

Sold 01/10/25

1
Bedrooms
653
Square Feet
10.22
Acres
$165,000 | 6088 Italy Valley Road, Italy, NY 14512
1/2
6

$165,000

Sold 10/20/25

2
Bedrooms
886
Square Feet
3.87
Acres
$110,000 | 3306 Flint Hill Road, Italy, NY 14512
1/2
7

$110,000

Sold 08/07/26

2
Bedrooms
1,900
Square Feet
4.24
Acres
$445,000 | 5515 Highlands Drive, Italy, NY 14418
1/2
8

$445,000

Sold 11/05/25

2
Bedrooms
1,414
Square Feet
10.03
Acres
$85,000 | 529 Poplar Street, Italy, TX 76651
9

$85,000

Sold 08/07/26

2
Bedrooms
928
Square Feet
0.27
Acres

Location

Listing Courtesy of Nothnagle REALTORS

Sold By Nothnagle REALTORS

Add your commute

Building Information for 3310 Shay Road

Stories1Year Built1885Building Size-Lot Size11.50 AC / 500,940 SF

Payment Calculator

$577 per month

30 year fixed, 6.55% Interest

Principal and Interest

$407

Property Taxes

$170

HOA Dues

$0

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Rocket Mortgage1

Property Information for 3310 Shay Road

Summary
Location and General Information
  • Elementary School District: Marcus Whitman
  • High School District: Marcus Whitman
  • Middle Or Junior School District: Marcus Whitman
  • Village: Not Applicable
  • Human YN: No
Parking
  • Garage Spaces per Apt: .00
  • Garage YN: No
Taxes and HOA Information
  • Association Fee: $.00
  • Area NYSWIS Code: Italy-572400
  • Tax Annual Amount: $2,045.00
Property
Lot Information
  • Building Area Total: 950.0
  • Land Features: Irregular Lot, Rural Lot, Wooded
  • Num Of Acres: 11.5
  • Lot Size Area: 11.5
  • Lot Size Units: Acres
  • Parcel Number: 572400-056-001-0001-016-000-0000
Property and Assessments
  • Property Condition: Resale
  • Senior Community YN: No
  • Assessed Value: $66,600
  • Year Built: 1885
  • Year Built Description: Existing
Utilities
  • Electric Service: Circuit Breakers
  • Sewer Description: Septic Tank
  • Water Supply: Well
Interior and Exterior Features
Exterior Features
  • Construction Materials: Aluminum Siding, Steel Siding
  • Exterior Features: Dirt Driveway, Deck
  • Foundation Description: Other, See Remarks
  • Other Equipment: Satellite Dish
  • Other Structures: Barns, Outbuilding, Sheds, Storage
  • Patio And Porch Features: Deck
Interior Features
  • Appliances: Dishwasher, Electric Oven, Electric Range, Electric Water Heater, Microwave, Refrigerator
  • Basement Description: None
  • Basement YN: No
  • Num Of Possible Bedrooms: 1
  • HVAC Type: Zoned
  • Num Fireplaces Total Calculated: 1
  • Fireplace YN: Yes
  • Floor Description: Hardwood, Varies
  • Heating: Propane, Zoned, Wall Furnace
  • Heating YN: Yes
  • Interior Features: Kitchen Family Room Combo
  • Laundry Features: Main Level
  • Levels: One
  • Sq Ft Total: 950.0
  • Main Level Bathrooms: 1
  • Num Bedrooms 1 St Floor: 1
  • Num Of Rooms: 3
Multi Family
Multi-Family Information
  • Number Of Units Total: 0
  • Stories: 1
  • Stories Total: 1

Property History for 3310 Shay Road

DateEvent & SourcePriceAppreciation
May 27, 2010

Sold (Public Record)

Public Record #1255825898

$80,000
May 27, 2010

Sold

WNYREIS #R927423

$80,000
May 27, 2010

Sold

New York State Alliance of MLSs (Buffalo) #R927423

$80,000
DateEvent & SourcePrice
05/27/2010

Sold (Public Record)

Public Record #1255825898

$80,000
05/27/2010

Sold

WNYREIS #R927423

$80,000
05/27/2010

Sold

New York State Alliance of MLSs (Buffalo) #R927423

$80,000

For completeness, we often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

Public Records for 3310 Shay Road

Taxable ValueLand$49,800Additions$112,700Total$162,500
Tax Record2025$3,840 ($320 / month)
Home Facts
Beds1Baths1Total Finished SqFt855 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt855 SqFtStories1Lot Size490,050 SqFtStyleMiscellaneous ResidentialYear Built1885Zoning01 - NOT ZONECountyYATESAPN572400 56.01-1-16Fireplace TypeHas Fireplace

Schools near 3310 Shay Road

This home is within Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman).
Rating
School
Type
Grades
Distance
Public - PK to 2
Public - 3 to 5
Public - 6 to 8
Public - 9 to 12
Rating
School
Distance
Middlesex Valley Elementary School
PublicPK to 2

Gorham Elementary School
Public3 to 5

Marcus Whitman Middle School
Public6 to 8

Marcus Whitman High School
Public9 to 12

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

New listings in 14512

$35,000 | 105 Indian Village Park, Naples, NY 14512
1/22
New

$35,000

1
Bedrooms
264
Square Feet
0.25
Acres
$400,000 | 6345 West W Hollow, Naples, NY 14512
1/47
New

$400,000

3
Bedrooms
1,584
Square Feet
10
Acres
$400,000 | 6345 West Hollow Road, South Bristol, NY 14512
1/47

eXp Realty, LLC • MLS #R1705228

New

$400,000

3
Bedrooms
1,584
Square Feet
10
Acres
$124,900 | 7012 County Road 12, Naples, NY 14512
1/9

Kevin R. Battle Real Estate • MLS #R1701803

$124,900

Unavailable
Bedrooms
Unavailable
Bathrooms
Unavailable
Square Feet
5
Acres
$59,000 | 5481 Highway 53, Prattsburgh, NY 14512
1/20

Howard Hanna The Rohr Agency • MLS #R1701851

$59,000

Unavailable
Bedrooms
Unavailable
Bathrooms
Unavailable
Square Feet
2.55
Acres
$640,000 | 6600 Fribolin Road, South Bristol, NY 14512
1/27

$640,000

2
Bedrooms
2,438
Square Feet
8.09
Acres
$369,999 | 160 Martin Road, Italy, NY 14512
1/44

$369,999

3
Bedrooms
2,339
Square Feet
14.84
Acres
$189,900 | 218 South Main Street, Naples, NY 14512
1/36
Active Under Contract

$189,900

3
Bedrooms
1,820
Square Feet
0.5
Acres
$334,900 | 8071 Hunt Hollow Road, Naples, NY 14512
1/50

$334,900

6
Bedrooms
2,952
Square Feet
3.8
Acres

Nearby home values

AddressSold priceBedsBathsSqftLot (Sqft)
This home: 3310 Shay Road, Italy, NY 14512
$80,000
1
950
500,940
720
139,828
1
1
672
216,929
2
1
1,228
217,800
3
2
1,152
82,764
$143,750
1,029,323

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of any information, descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified through appropriate means, including, but not limited to, in person inspection and public records, and Compass International Holdings, its subsidiaries, affiliates and independently owned and operated franchisees, and their affiliated agents and associated third parties expressly disclaim any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the seller's discretion. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Listing Courtesy of Nothnagle REALTORS

Based on information from one of the following Multiple Listing Services: WNYREIS and Greater Binghamton Association of REALTORS. Information being provided is for the visitor's personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties visitor may be interested in purchasing. The data contained herein is copyrighted by WNYREIS and Greater Binghamton Association of REALTORS is protected by all applicable copyright laws. Any dissemination of this information is in violation of copyright laws and is strictly prohibited. Property information referenced on this web site comes from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the MLS. This web site may reference real estate listing(s) held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent who owns this web site. For the avoidance of doubt, the accuracy of all information, regardless of source, is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be personally verified through personal inspection by and/or with the appropriate professionals.