5 Reynolds Street

Closed 2/24/25
Closed 2/24/25
Gallery Image 1
Gallery Image 2
Gallery Image 3
Gallery Image 4
Gallery Image 5
Gallery Image 6
Gallery Image 7
Gallery Image 8
Gallery Image 9
Gallery Image 10
Gallery Image 11
Gallery Image 12
Gallery Image 13
Gallery Image 14
Gallery Image 15
Gallery Image 16
Gallery Image 17
Gallery Image 18
Gallery Image 19
Gallery Image 20
Gallery Image 21
Gallery Image 22
Gallery Image 23
Gallery Image 24
Gallery Image 25
Gallery Image 26
Gallery Image 27
Gallery Image 28
Gallery Image 29
Gallery Image 30
Gallery Image 31
Gallery Image 32
Gallery Image 33
Sold
Last Sold Price
$320,000
3 beds1,250 sqft$256/sqft
5 Reynolds St, Proctor, VT 05765
Single FamilyProperty Type
9,583 sq ftLot Size
1900Year Built
$256/sq ftPrice per sq ft
1 carParking Spaces

Description

Nestled in the heart of historic Proctor, Vermont, this timeless 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom home has been lovingly cared for by the same family for over 40 years. With its rich history and character, including a dining room hand-carved by the original owner, this property offers both warmth and craftsmanship rarely found today. Enjoy mornings in the delightful 3-season porch and evenings by the cozy fire pit. The large, detached workshop offers endless potential—whether as a creative space, home office,...Nestled in the heart of historic Proctor, Vermont, this timeless 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom home has been lovingly cared for by the same family for over 40 years. With its rich history and character, including a dining room hand-carved by the original owner, this property offers both warmth and craftsmanship rarely found today. Enjoy mornings in the delightful 3-season porch and evenings by the cozy fire pit. The large, detached workshop offers endless potential—whether as a creative space, home office, or even additional living quarters. This property is ideally situated just 10 minutes from Rutland, offering easy access to shopping, dining, and entertainment. Outdoor enthusiasts will love being close to Pine Hill Park’s hiking and biking trails, Chittenden Reservoir for kayaking and fishing, and just a short drive from Killington and Pico Mountain for skiing in the winter. You'll also enjoy proximity to the serene waters of Lake Bomoseen and Lake St. Catherine, perfect for boating, swimming, and lakeside relaxation. Located in a walkable neighborhood, you'll be close to local amenities while enjoying the charm and tranquility of Proctor. Don’t miss the chance to own a piece of local history! Delayed Showings starting 09/16/2024.

    Sold By Four Seasons Sotheby's Int'l Realty

    • Listed by: Morriah Adams • BHG Masiello Brattleboro
    Listing closed: 02/24/2025 12:00 AM • Source: New England Real Estate Network, MLS#: 5014379

    Recent comparable sales

    Median sold price

    $249,000

    Avg days on market

    55

    Sale-to-list ratio

    95.1%

    Proctor, VT

    9 comparable properties found

    $300,000 | 18 Pleasant Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/41
    1

    $300,000

    Sold 10/01/24

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,296
    Square Feet
    1.92
    Acres

    18 Pleasant Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $290,000 | 33 Gibbs Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/36
    2

    $290,000

    Sold 12/03/25

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,422
    Square Feet
    0.23
    Acres

    33 Gibbs Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $215,000 | 13 Pleasant Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/56
    3

    $215,000

    Sold 01/29/26

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,296
    Square Feet
    0.21
    Acres

    13 Pleasant Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $269,500 | 37 Taylor Hill Road, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/43
    4

    $269,500

    Sold 06/30/25

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,546
    Square Feet
    0.51
    Acres

    37 Taylor Hill Road, Proctor, VT 05765

    $230,000 | 50 North Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/46
    5

    $230,000

    Sold 06/12/25

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,220
    Square Feet
    0.56
    Acres

    50 North Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $176,250 | 43 Taylor Hill Road, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/26
    6

    $176,250

    Sold 06/30/26

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,190
    Square Feet
    0.24
    Acres

    43 Taylor Hill Road, Proctor, VT 05765

    $227,000 | 34 School Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/27
    7

    $227,000

    Sold 05/08/26

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,456
    Square Feet
    0.55
    Acres

    34 School Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $290,000 | 1336 West Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/39
    8

    $290,000

    Sold 07/31/25

    2
    Bedrooms
    1,140
    Square Feet
    2.56
    Acres

    1336 West Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $249,000 | 41 Pine Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/33
    9

    $249,000

    Sold 10/15/24

    4
    Bedrooms
    1,424
    Square Feet
    0.3
    Acres

    41 Pine Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1

    Location

    Add your commute

    Payment Calculator

    Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1

    $1,861 per month

    30 year fixed, 6.55% Interest

    Principal and Interest

    $1,627

    Property Taxes

    $235

    HOA Dues

    $0

    The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

    Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

    Rocket Mortgage1

    Property Information for 5 Reynolds Street

    Property Details
    • Taxes: $2,815 / year
    • MLS Type: Residential / Single Family
    • County: Rutland County
    • Zoning: Residential
    Building Information
    • Stories: 2
    • Year Built: 1900
    • Lot Size: 0.22 AC / 9,583 SF
    Summary
    Location and General Information
    • City: Proctor
    • County: VT-Rutland
    • Latitude: 43.656991097295069
    • Longitude: -73.032075728836062
    • Road Frontage: TBD
    • Seasonal: No
    • State: VT
    • Street Designation: Street
    • Zip Code: 05765
    Taxes and HOA Information
    • SPAN Number: 498-157-10218
    • Tax Year: 2024
    • Taxes TBD: No
    Parking
    • Garage: Yes
    • Garage Capacity: 1.00
    • Driveway: Paved
    Property
    Lot Information
    • Lot - Sqft: 9583.0
    • Lot Features: Curbing
    • Lot Size Acres: 0.22
    • Square Feet Apx Finished Above Grade: 1250.0
    • Square Feet Apx Finished AG Source: Estimated
    • Square Feet Apx Finished Below Grade: 0.0
    • Square Feet Apx Finished BG Source: Estimated
    • Square Feet Apx Total: 1255.0
    • Square Feet Apx Total Finished: 1250.0
    • Square Feet Apx Unfinished Above Grade: 0.0
    • Square Feet Apx Unfinished Below Grade: 5.0
    • Square Feet Apx Unfinished BG Source: Estimated
    Property and Assessments
    • Property Class: Residential
    • Property Type: Single Family
    • Flood Zone: No
    • Foundation: Axle, Stone
    • PreConstruction: No
    • Surveyed: Unknown
    • Year Built: 1900
    Utilities
    • Electric: 100 Amp
    • Sewer: Public
    • Water Source: Public
    • Utilities: Cable - Available, Telephone Available
    • Internet: High Speed Intrnt -Avail
    Interior and Exterior Features
    Exterior Features
    • Construction Materials: Wood Frame, Wood Siding
    • Roof: Shingle - Architectural
    Interior Features
    • Basement: Yes
    • Basement Access Type: Interior
    • Basement Description: Concrete Floor
    • Baths - Total: 2
    • Baths - Full: 1
    • Half Baths: 1
    • One Quarter Baths: 0
    • Three Quarter Bath: 0
    • Rooms - Total: 10
    • Bedrooms - Total: 3
    • Heating: Oil, Baseboard, Other
    • Cooling: Mini Split
    • Total Stories: 2

    Property History for 5 Reynolds Street

    DateEvent & SourcePriceAppreciation
    Feb 24, 2025

    Sold (Public Record)

    Public Record #1552075380

    		$320,000—
    Feb 24, 2025

    Sold

    New England Real Estate Network #5014379

    		$320,000—
    Feb 24, 2025

    Pending

    New England Real Estate Network #5014379

    		—
    DateEvent & SourcePrice
    02/24/2025

    Sold (Public Record)

    Public Record #1552075380

    $320,000
    02/24/2025

    Sold

    New England Real Estate Network #5014379

    $320,000
    02/24/2025

    Pending

    New England Real Estate Network #5014379

    —

    For completeness, we often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

    Public Records for 5 Reynolds Street

    Taxable ValueLand$31,200Additions$112,000Total$143,200
    Tax Record2025$1,824 ($152 / month)
    Home Facts
    Beds3Baths1Total Finished SqFt1,652 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt1,652 SqFtStories2Lot Size9,583 SqFtStyleSingle Family ResidenceYear Built1900Year Renovated1900CountyRUTLANDAPN(157) 450005

    Schools near 5 Reynolds Street

    This home is within Quarry Hill Unified Union School District.
    Rating
    School
    Type
    Grades
    Distance
    Proctor Elementary School
    		Public - PK to 6
    Proctor Junior/Senior High School
    		Public - 7 to 12
    Rating
    School
    Distance
    Proctor Elementary School
    PublicPK to 6

    Proctor Junior/Senior High School
    Public7 to 12

    School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

    Similar Homes

    New listings in 05765

    $499,000 | 25 North Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/46

    $499,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    Unavailable
    Bathrooms
    3,978
    Square Feet
    5.66
    Acres

    25 North Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $599,000 | 25-31 North Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/60

    $599,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    Unavailable
    Bathrooms
    3,978
    Square Feet
    16.78
    Acres

    25-31 North Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $119,900 | 92-94 North Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/22

    $119,900

    6
    Bedrooms
    2
    Bathrooms
    2,412
    Square Feet
    0.6
    Acres

    92-94 North Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $260,000 | 45 Eden Avenue, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/26

    $260,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,352
    Square Feet
    1.1
    Acres

    45 Eden Avenue, Proctor, VT 05765

    $240,000 | 2 Charles Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/39
    Active Under Contract

    $240,000

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,296
    Square Feet
    0.37
    Acres

    2 Charles Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $335,000 | 48-50 Taylor Hill Road, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/23

    $335,000

    4
    Bedrooms
    1,998
    Square Feet
    0.71
    Acres

    48-50 Taylor Hill Road, Proctor, VT 05765

    $175,000 | 2 Willow Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/48
    Active Under Contract

    $175,000

    1
    Bedrooms
    768
    Square Feet
    0.49
    Acres

    2 Willow Street, Proctor, VT 05765

    $299,000 | 38 Olympus Road, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/35

    $299,000

    4
    Bedrooms
    1,105
    Square Feet
    2.04
    Acres

    38 Olympus Road, Proctor, VT 05765

    $480,000 | 61 Ormsbee Avenue, Proctor, VT 05765
    1/59
    Active Under Contract

    $480,000

    5
    Bedrooms
    3,183
    Square Feet
    0.47
    Acres

    61 Ormsbee Avenue, Proctor, VT 05765

    Nearby home values

    AddressSold priceBedsBathsSqftLot (Sqft)
    This home: 5 Reynolds Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    $320,000
    3
    1,250
    9,583
    21 Reynolds Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    –
    –
    –
    –
    1,089,000
    55 South Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    –
    4
    2.5
    2,160
    18,295
    9 Reynolds Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    $187,500
    3
    1
    1,567
    20,909
    59 South Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    –
    6
    1
    2,356
    14,810
    51 South Street, Proctor, VT 05765
    $130,000
    5
    2,444
    16,117

    Explore Nearby Homes

    No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of any information, descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified through appropriate means, including, but not limited to, in person inspection and public records, and Compass International Holdings, its subsidiaries, affiliates and independently owned and operated franchisees, and their affiliated agents and associated third parties expressly disclaim any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the seller's discretion. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

    Listing Courtesy of BHG Masiello Brattleboro

    Copyright 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this Site comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated 09/07/2026 12:53 AM