91 Nottingham Road

Closed 7/25/25

Last Sold Price

$490,000

3 beds2 baths1,466 sqft$334/sqft

91 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214

Description

Charming Cape Cod in the heart of Beechwold situated on a spacious 75' x 155' lot! This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers timeless character and thoughtful updates in one of Columbus's most walkable neighborhoods. The main level features hardwood floors, a spacious living room with a cozy fireplace, and a formal dining area ideal for entertaining. A screened porch off the living room provides a quiet retreat overlooking the side yard and raised beds. The kitchen boasts rich wood...Charming Cape Cod in the heart of Beechwold situated on a spacious 75' x 155' lot! This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers timeless character and thoughtful updates in one of Columbus's most walkable neighborhoods. The main level features hardwood floors, a spacious living room with a cozy fireplace, and a formal dining area ideal for entertaining. A screened porch off the living room provides a quiet retreat overlooking the side yard and raised beds. The kitchen boasts rich wood custom cabinetry, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances. Upstairs, you'll find a light-filled bedroom with hardwood floors—also perfect for a home office, playroom, or studio. A second full bath with a walk-in shower is conveniently located in the lower level, offering additional comfort and functionality. Step outside to a fully fenced backyard with mature trees and a large paver patio—ideal for summer gatherings, grilling, or simply relaxing. The detached two-car garage and long driveway provide ample parking and storage. Located just blocks from the shops and restaurants along High Street, this home offers unbeatable proximity to Clintonville hotspots, parks, and commuter routes. Classic charm meets modern convenience in this move-in-ready gem!

LISTING CLOSED: 07/25/2025 12:00 AM

Listed by Matthew T Schirtzinger • Brokerage DRE #0000394437 • RE/MAX Premier Choice
P: (614) 580-3945 C: (614) 580-3945 mschirtz@aol.com

Property Details for 91 Nottingham Road

Status

Closed

MLS #

225019804

Days on Market

Taxes

$6,186 / year

HOA Fees

Condo/Co-op Fees

Property Type

Single Family

MLS Type

Residential / Single Family Residence

Year Built

1941

Lot Size

0.27 AC / 11,761 SF

County

Franklin County

Architectural Style

Cape Cod

Subdivision Name

Clintonville Beechwold

Recent comparable sales

Median sold price

$484,500

Avg days on market

Sale-to-list ratio

102.4%

1/37

$485,000

Sold 07/29/26

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1,564
Square Feet: 0.22
Acres

46 Garden Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/38

$500,000

Sold 10/18/24

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,499
Square Feet: 0.15
Acres

225 West Weisheimer Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/47

$530,500

Sold 04/24/26

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,431
Square Feet: 0.11
Acres

211 Garrett Place, Columbus, OH 43214

1/42

$481,000

Sold 06/18/26

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,568
Square Feet: 0.17
Acres

197 West Henderson Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/28

$460,000

Sold 02/21/25

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,634
Square Feet: 0.15
Acres

100 East Weisheimer Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/57

$484,500

Sold 06/06/25

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,454
Square Feet: 0.17
Acres

174 East Dominion Boulevard, Columbus, OH 43214

1/28

$425,000

Sold 09/24/25

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,612
Square Feet: 0.15
Acres

164 East Weisheimer Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/43

$525,000

Sold 12/01/25

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,606
Square Feet: 0.23
Acres

255 Garden Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/88

$460,000

Sold 07/28/26

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,643
Square Feet: 0.22
Acres

72 Garden Road, Columbus, OH 43214

Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage¹

Location

Listing Courtesy of RE/MAX Premier Choice

Sold By Keller Williams Consultants

Add your commute

Building Information for 91 Nottingham Road

Stories-Year Built1941Building Size-Lot Size0.27 AC / 11,761 SF

Payment Calculator

Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage¹

$3,006 per month

30 year fixed, 6.55% Interest

Principal and Interest

$2,491

Property Taxes

$516

HOA Dues

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Property Information for 91 Nottingham Road

Summary

Location and General Information

Longitude: -83.02241
Latitude: 40.05681

Directions: West of High, south of Morse and north of Henderson
Corp Limit Per Auditor: Columbus

Taxes and HOA

Association: No
Parcel Number: 010-086379

Tax Year: $2,024.00
Tax District: 010
Tax Abatement: No

School Information

High School District: COLUMBUS CSD 2503 FRA CO.

Parking

Attached Garage: No
Garage: Yes

Garage Spaces: 2.0
Parking Features: Detached Garage

Property

Lot Information

Lot Size Square Feet: 11761.2
Lot Size Acres: 0.27

Lot Size Area: 0.27
Lot Size (Front): 75
Lot Size (Side): 155

Property and Assessments

Building Area Source: Realist
New Construction: No

Year Built: 1941
Building Area Total: 1466.0
Living Area: 1466.0
Baths Full & Halh: 2.0
ATFLS Source: Realist
Built Prior to 1978: Yes

Building Features

Levels: One and One Half
Other Structures: Shed(s)

Foundation Details: Block
Common Walls: No Common Walls
Construction Materials: Stone, Vinyl Siding
Existing Accessory Dwelling Unit: No

Financial Information

Leased Items: No
Commercial Development Charge: No

Green Features

Green Features: No

Utilities

Sewer: Public Sewer
Water Source: Public

Interior and Exterior Features

Exterior Features

Patio And Porch Features: Patio, Screened
Exterior: Stone, Vinyl Siding

Interior Features

Total Bedrooms: 3
Appliances: Dishwasher, Gas Range, Microwave, Refrigerator

Cooling: Central Air
Total Fireplaces: 1.0
Has Fireplace: Yes
Window Features: Insulated All
Has Heating: Yes
Total Bathrooms: 2
Has Cooling: Yes
Basement: Full
Main Level Bedrooms: 2.0
Flooring: Ceramic/Porcelain, Wood
Has Basement: Yes
Heating: Forced Air, Gas
Interior Amenities: Dishwasher, Gas Range, Microwave, Refrigerator
Rooms: Dining Room, Eat Space/Kit, Living Room, LL Laundry
Accessible Features: No

Room Information

Bedrooms

Bedroom Level : Upper: 1.0

Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms: 2.0
Full Baths Level : Down: 1

Full Baths Level : Entry: 1

Dining Room

Dining Room Level : Entry: 1

Eating Space

Eating Space Level : Entry: 1

Living Room

Living Room Level : Entry: 1

Utility Space

Utility Space Level : Down: 1

Mobile Home

Mobile Home Information

Is Manufactured Housing: No

Rental

Tenant Information

Tenant Occupied: No

Property History for 91 Nottingham Road

Date	Event & Source	Price	Appreciation
Jul 25, 2025	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #225019804	$490,000	—
Jul 25, 2025	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #225019804		—
Jul 22, 2025	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #1907199083	$490,000	+3.8% / yr
Jun 6, 2025	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #225019804	$485,000	—
Apr 15, 2021	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #221006450	$416,900	—
Apr 15, 2021	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #221006450		—
Apr 6, 2021	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #1460307102	$416,900	+11.8% / yr
Mar 8, 2021	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #221006450	$416,900	—
Sep 12, 2019	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #652833053	$350,000	+4.9% / yr
Sep 12, 2019	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #219029702	$350,000	—
Aug 8, 2019	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #219029702		—
Aug 8, 2019	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #219029702	$339,000	—
Dec 4, 2015	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #562051122	$291,900	+7.0% / yr
Dec 4, 2015	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #215037099	$291,900	—
Dec 1, 2015	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #215037099		—
Oct 14, 2015	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #215037099	$291,900	—
Nov 18, 2013	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #213033456	$254,000	—
Nov 15, 2013	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #373755159	$254,000	—
Oct 4, 2013	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #213033456		—
Sep 13, 2013	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #213033456	$264,900	—
Aug 31, 2001	Permanently Off Market Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #2124642	$208,999	—
Jul 31, 2001	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #2124642	$208,999	—
Nov 30, 1998	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #9829746	$149,000	—
Oct 28, 1998	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #9829746		—
Oct 3, 1998	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #9829746	$149,900	—
Mar 31, 1995	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #63885	$125,500	—
Feb 17, 1995	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #63885		—
Feb 5, 1995	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #63885	$125,900	—

Date	Event & Source	Price
07/25/2025	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #225019804	$490,000
07/25/2025	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #225019804	—
07/22/2025	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #1907199083	$490,000 +3.8% / yr
06/06/2025	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #225019804	$485,000
04/15/2021	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #221006450	$416,900
04/15/2021	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #221006450	—
04/06/2021	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #1460307102	$416,900 +11.8% / yr
03/08/2021	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #221006450	$416,900
09/12/2019	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #652833053	$350,000 +4.9% / yr
09/12/2019	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #219029702	$350,000
08/08/2019	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #219029702	—
08/08/2019	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #219029702	$339,000
12/04/2015	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #562051122	$291,900 +7.0% / yr
12/04/2015	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #215037099	$291,900
12/01/2015	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #215037099	—
10/14/2015	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #215037099	$291,900
11/18/2013	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #213033456	$254,000
11/15/2013	Sold (Public Record) Public Record #373755159	$254,000
10/04/2013	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #213033456	—
09/13/2013	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #213033456	$264,900
08/31/2001	Permanently Off Market Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #2124642	$208,999
07/31/2001	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #2124642	$208,999
11/30/1998	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #9829746	$149,000
10/28/1998	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #9829746	—
10/03/1998	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #9829746	$149,900
03/31/1995	Sold Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #63885	$125,500
02/17/1995	Contract Signed Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #63885	—
02/05/1995	Listed (Active) Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS #63885	$125,900

For completeness, we often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

Public Records for 91 Nottingham Road

Taxable ValueLand$64,260Additions$73,570Total$137,830

Tax Record2024$6,186 ($515 / month)

Home Facts

Beds3Baths2Total Finished SqFt1,466 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt1,466 SqFtStories1Lot Size11,626 SqFtStyleSingle Family ResidenceYear Built1941Year Renovated1941CountyFRANKLINAPN010-086379

Schools near 91 Nottingham Road

This home is within Columbus City School District.


Rating	School	Type	Grades	Distance
7/10	Indian Springs Elementary School	Public - Serves this home	K to 5	0.5 mi
6/10	Dominion Middle School	Public - Serves this home	6 to 8	2.8 mi
4/10	Whetstone High School	Public - Serves this home	9 to 12	0.6 mi
3/10	Columbus Online Academy	Public - Nearby school	7 to 12	11.4 mi
NR	Columbus Scioto 6-12	Public - Nearby school	6 to 12	10.8 mi
3/10	Eastmoor Academy	Public - Choice school	9 to 12	8.8 mi
NR	Tree of Life-Indianola Branch	Private - Nearby school	PK to 5	0.9 mi
NR	Worthington Christian Westview Elementary School	Private - Nearby school	1 to 5	0.9 mi
NR	Bishop Watterson High School	Private - Nearby school	9 to 12	0.7 mi


Rating	School	Distance
7/10	Indian Springs Elementary School PublicK to 5 Serves this home	0.5 mi
6/10	Dominion Middle School Public6 to 8 Serves this home	2.8 mi
4/10	Whetstone High School Public9 to 12 Serves this home	0.6 mi
3/10	Columbus Online Academy Public7 to 12 Nearby school	11.4 mi
NR	Columbus Scioto 6-12 Public6 to 12 Nearby school	10.8 mi
3/10	Eastmoor Academy Public9 to 12 Choice school	8.8 mi
NR	Tree of Life-Indianola Branch PrivatePK to 5 Nearby school	0.9 mi
NR	Worthington Christian Westview Elementary School Private1 to 5 Nearby school	0.9 mi
NR	Bishop Watterson High School Private9 to 12 Nearby school	0.7 mi

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

New listings in 43214

$465,000 | 4249 Rowanne Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/40

Contingent

$465,000

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 2,022
Square Feet: 0.34
Acres

4249 Rowanne Road, Columbus, OH 43214

$575,000 | 217 Garrett Place, Columbus, OH 43214

1/43

New

$575,000

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1,962
Square Feet: 0.11
Acres

217 Garrett Place, Columbus, OH 43214

$579,900 | 111 Erie Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/43

Listed By Coldwell Banker RealtyOpen: 8/20 05:00PM - 07:00PM

$579,900

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 2,028
Square Feet: 0.21
Acres

111 Erie Road, Columbus, OH 43214

$639,900 | 448 East Dunedin Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/79

Coming SoonOpen: 8/23 02:00PM - 04:00PM

$639,900

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,737
Square Feet: 0.18
Acres

448 East Dunedin Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/46

$294,900

2
Bedrooms: 1
Bathrooms: 1,105
Square Feet: 0.12
Acres

367 West Kanawha Avenue, Columbus, OH 43214

$299,000 | 374 Rosslyn Avenue, Columbus, OH 43214

1/34

Open: 8/23 02:00PM - 04:00PM

$299,000

2
Bedrooms: 1
Bathrooms: 1,339
Square Feet: 0.13
Acres

374 Rosslyn Avenue, Columbus, OH 43214

$279,900 | 503 Chase Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/39

Listed By Coldwell Banker RealtyContingent

$279,900

2
Bedrooms: 1
Bathrooms: 771
Square Feet: 0.16
Acres

503 Chase Road, Columbus, OH 43214

1/8

$359,000

2
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 914
Square Feet: 0.11
Acres

639 Morse Road, Columbus, OH 43214

$1,049,000 | 331 Charleston Avenue, Columbus, OH 43214

1/13

Contingent

$1,049,000

6
Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 4,238
Square Feet: 0.44
Acres

331 Charleston Avenue, Columbus, OH 43214

Nearby home values

Address	Sold price	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot (Sqft)
This home: 91 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$490,000	3	2	1,466	11,761
101 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$386,000	5	4	3,318	9,147
81 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$410,000	4	2	2,230	11,761
73 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$232,000	3	2	1,920	7,405
88 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$291,900	3	2	1,784	7,405
94 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	–	3	2	1,536	7,879
4655 Rustic Bridge Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$684,000	4	2	2,088	11,515
65 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	–	4	2	1,177	7,809
115 Oak Street, Columbus, OH 43214	$208,200	4	3	2,088	0
115 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$208,000	4	3	2,088	0
80 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$294,800	3	2	2,055	7,840
88 Sheffield Road, Columbus, OH 43214	–	3	2.5	1,864	7,749
100 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH 43214	–	2	2	1,581	9,347
94 Sheffield Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$198,000	2	1	1,341	7,405
100 Sheffield Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$173,000	3	2	1,217	0
80 Sheffield Road, Columbus, OH 43214	$360,000	3	1	1,434	7,405

Explore Nearby Homes

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of any information, descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified through appropriate means, including, but not limited to, in person inspection and public records, and Compass International Holdings, its subsidiaries, affiliates and independently owned and operated franchisees, and their affiliated agents and associated third parties expressly disclaim any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the seller's discretion. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Listing Courtesy of RE/MAX Premier Choice

IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Columbus, OH

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Explore Nearby Homes

Homes in Nearby Old Beechwold Neighborhoods

Homes in Nearby Old Beechwold Cities

Homes in Nearby Old Beechwold Zip Codes