959 Garrett Mill Road

Closed 7/14/26

Sold

Last Sold Price

$1,995,000

6 beds6 baths7,463 sqft$267/sqft

959 Garrett Mill Rd, Newtown Square, PA 19073

Single FamilyProperty Type

1.6 acresLot Size

2001Year Built

$267/sq ftPrice per sq ft

3 carsParking Spaces

Description

A once in a lifetime opportunity to own a piece of Willistown history & one of the most custom built homes you'll ever see! Welcome to Shady Grove School House, ca 1850, named after the large white oak trees nearby. This one room schoolhouse stands proudly on a gorgeous 1.6 acre with a custom home attached built in 2001, creating a one of a kind 7,500+ square foot home which the current owners have done an unbelievable job renovating. The level of detail throughout doesn't resonate until you see...A once in a lifetime opportunity to own a piece of Willistown history & one of the most custom built homes you'll ever see! Welcome to Shady Grove School House, ca 1850, named after the large white oak trees nearby. This one room schoolhouse stands proudly on a gorgeous 1.6 acre with a custom home attached built in 2001, creating a one of a kind 7,500+ square foot home which the current owners have done an unbelievable job renovating. The level of detail throughout doesn't resonate until you see it in person. The best materials used throughout, unlacquered brass door knobs, Hardie siding, Tuscan Versilia marble are just to name a few. The home is perfectly perched offering stunning views from every window, with preserved land across the street. The beautiful flow, bringing the outdoors in with it's many access points for enjoying the private Timbertech decks that hug the home. Entertaining is a delight & each room flows seamlessly into the next with arched doorways, dental moldings & deep sills, perfectly replicating the original school house detail. The bluestone walkway & circular patio out front greet you. The 2 story center hall foyer is spectacular with natural light pouring in from all angles. The main level provides an exceptional layout for ease of every day as well as the best entertaining layout possible. Greet your guests in the foyer, utilize the schoolhouse space with it's high ceilings with wood beam detail, reception room size & gorgeous stone fireplace. The open concept kitchen, great room, butlers pantry & bar makes for a great holiday set up. The kitchen design with perfectly curated materials & appliances makes it so special. Sub zero fridge/freezer, 2 paneled dishwashers, 48 inch wolf range, upgraded lighting, 2 tone inset cabinets, unlacquered brass hardware & large center island make it a show stopper. The large great room with large fireplace/hearth has a beautiful lacquered bar with mirrored backsplash, sub zero wine fridge & 2 beverage drawers & built-in ice maker, allowing your guests to help themselves. The formal dining room with dentil moldings & paneled walls & living room with a fireplace are located off the entry foyer. The first floor also offers a primary bedroom option with a large bedroom that has a new full bath with walk-in shower, walk-in closet, fireplace and built ins. Also on the first floor is a large mudroom area, laundry room with cabinetry, washtub & plenty of counter space, a half bath for guests, the perfect butlers pantry with stunning wallpaper & a back staircase. On the 2nd floor you'll find a large primary suite with a sitting room with it's own balconette, large bedroom with Carrera surround fireplace (double sided in the bed and large bath) & 2 walk-in closets. Plenty of additional bedroom suites with full baths & jack and jill's make the layout extremely versatile, depending on your needs. Each room has large closets with plenty of space for larger furniture. 3rd floor offers a 7th bedroom option if needed & has been recently updated with plush carpeting, drywall & lighting. Tons of attic storage space. The basement of the home is unfinished, yet plumbing is easily accessible if you wanted to add more living space. The systems have been updated & made more efficient to include 3 new AC units, 2 LED air purification, new furnaces, new hot water heater, whole house generator & whole house surge protectors. The 3 car detached garage offers a wide open loft space, just waiting to be finished into an office, studio or added living space. Some other recent upgrades include new roofing, removal of stucco & the addition of Hardie, an electric fence, the careful rebuilding of the schoolhouse cupola, repointing of chimneys, new window, doors, gorgeous hardscape added, electric fence, light automation & much more! You truly have to see this home in person to appreciate its beauty, flow, scale and quality. The best of everything & one you can't' miss.

Listed by: Erica L Deuschle 610.608.2570 erica@trustthepineapple.com • Keller Williams Main Line

Listing closed: 07/14/2026 12:00 AM • Source: BRIGHT, MLS#: PACT2125520

Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage¹

Location

Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Main Line

Sold By Keller Williams Main Line

Add your commute

Payment Calculator

Get preapproved with
OriginPoint Mortgage or Rocket Mortgage¹

$11,680 per month

30 year fixed, 6.55% Interest

Principal and Interest

$10,140

Property Taxes

$1,540

HOA Dues

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Property Information for 959 Garrett Mill Road

Property Details

Taxes: $18,477 / year
MLS Type: Residential / Fee Simple
County: Chester County
Tax ID Number: 54-06 -0075
Ownership: Fee Simple
Condo Coop Association: No
HOA: No
Structure Type: Detached
Style: Traditional
Levels/Stories: 2
Waterfront: No
Garage: Yes
Subdivision: RADNOR HUNT
Subdivision: RADNOR HUNT (CHESTER PA)
Municipality: WILLISTOWN TWP
Total Parking Spaces: 3
Central Air: Yes
Basement: Yes
Above Grade Finished SQFT: 7,463.00
Above Grade Fin SQFT Source: Assessor
Below Grade Finished SQFT: .00
Below Grade Fin SQFT Source: Assessor
Below Grade Unfinished SQFT: .00
Below Grade Unfin SQFT Source: Assessor
Total Below Grade SQFT: .00
Total Below Grade SQFT Source: Assessor
New Construction: No

Building Information

Stories: 2
Year Built: 2001
Lot Size: 1.60 AC / 69,696 SF

Location

School District Name: GREAT VALLEY
School District County ID: 300200397337

SchoolDistrictSource: 3rd Party
Elementary School: SUGARTOWN (CHESTER PA)
ElementarySchoolSource: 3rd Party
Middle Or Junior School: GREAT VALLEY (CHESTER PA)
MiddleSchoolSource: 3rd Party
High School: GREAT VALLEY (CHESTER PA)
HighSchoolSource: 3rd Party
County: CHESTER
MLS Area: Willistown Twp (10354)

Waterfront / Water Access

Water View: No
Water Access: No

Water Oriented: No
Navigable Water: No
Tidal Water: No
Riparian Rights Y/N: No

Association / Community Info

Senior Community: No

Taxes and Assessment

Tax Year: 2025
Tax Assessed Value: $602,570

Year Assessed: 2026
County Tax: $3,111
Improvement Assessed Value: $527,890
City Town Tax: $168
Land Assessed Value: $74,680
Clean Green Assessed: No
Land Use Code: R10
Zoning: RESIDENTIAL
Tax Lot: 0075
School Tax: $15,196
Automatically Update Tax Values Y/N: Yes

Rooms

Main

# Bedrooms Count Main Level: 1
# Bathrooms Count Main Level: 2

# Bathrooms Full Main Level: 1
# Bathrooms Half Main Level: 1

All Upper Levels

# Bedrooms Count All Upper Levels: 5
# Bathrooms Count All Upper Levels: 4

# Bathrooms Full All Upper Levels: 4

Upper Level 1

# Bedrooms Count Upper Level: 5
# Bathrooms Count Upper Level: 4

# Bathrooms Full Upper Level: 4

Rooms

Stories: Main, Upper 1

Building Info

Total Finished SQFT: 7,463.00
Total Finished SQFT Source: Assessor

Tax Total Finished SQFT: 7,463.00
Total SQFT: 7,463.00
Total SQFT Source: Assessor
Construction Materials: Frame, Masonry
Ext Main Mid-res: http://bright-media02.prd.brightmls.com/bright/images/0000/8049/1594/3678/804915943678_512_384_WM_gMjN6Ln5qNIsMt1A.jpg
Basement Type: Daylight, Partial, Unfinished
Foundation Details: Block, Stone
Room and Floor: Bedrooms-Main Level-1, Bathrooms Full-Main Level-1, Bathrooms Half-Main Level-1, Bedrooms-Upper Level 1-1, Bedrooms-Upper Level 1-2, Bedrooms-Upper Level 1-3, Bedrooms-Upper Level 1-4, Bedrooms-Upper Level 1-5, Bathrooms Full-Upper Level 1-1, Bathrooms Full-Upper Level 1-2, Bathrooms Full-Upper Level 1-3, Bathrooms Full-Upper Level 1-4
# Bathrooms Full: 5
# Bathrooms Half: 1
Other Structure: Above Grade, Below Grade

Lot / Land Information

Lot Size Source: Assessor
Lot Size Dimensions: 0.00 x 0.00

Lot Dimensions Source: Assessor
Parcel ID: 354287

Parking

Type Of Parking: Driveway, Detached Garage
Num of Detached Garage Spaces: 3

Total Garage Spaces: 3
Garage Features: Garage - Front Entry, Additional Storage Area

Interior Features

Fireplace: Yes
Fireplaces Count: 5

Accessibility Features: None
Virtual Tour URL Unbranded: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/3b7bq3r6z1p9jlam9b4wt/AGiWSfdPs_iFlCywzLczEHE?dl=0&e=1&preview=959+Garrett+no+branding+music+2.mp4&rlkey=xqkyscgielevhyoxsuw0n2qnb&st=gue8fewk

Exterior Features

Pool: No Pool

Utilities

Heating: Yes
Cooling Type: Central A/C

Cooling Fuel: Electric
Heating Type: Forced Air
Heating Fuel: Propane - Owned
Hot Water: Propane
Water Source: Well
Sewer Septic: On Site Septic

Confidential Data

Listing Office

List Agent AOR: Tri-County Suburban REALTORS
List Agent URL: www.trustthepineapple.com

Property History for 959 Garrett Mill Road

Date	Event & Source	Price	Appreciation
Jul 14, 2026	Closed BRIGHT #PACT2125520	$1,995,000	—
Jul 2, 2026	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #1945583152	$1,995,000	+9.3% / yr
May 18, 2026	Pending BRIGHT #PACT2125520		—
May 18, 2026	Active Under Contract BRIGHT #PACT2125520		—
May 13, 2026	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT2125520	$2,150,000	—
Mar 29, 2021	Closed BRIGHT #PACT526510	$1,400,000	—
Mar 29, 2021	Closed BRIGHT #PACT526510	$1,250,000	—
Mar 23, 2021	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #695370633	$1,250,000	—
Mar 23, 2021	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #1457019805	$1,250,000	-1.8% / yr
Jan 17, 2021	Pending BRIGHT #PACT526510		—
Jan 1, 2021	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT526510	$1,495,000	—
Aug 2, 2017	Withdrawn BRIGHT #1008018318	$1,500,000	—
Apr 29, 2016	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1008018318	$1,650,000	—
Dec 22, 2015	Withdrawn BRIGHT #1007793126	$1,695,000	—
Mar 26, 2015	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1007793126	$1,695,000	—
Dec 11, 2014	Withdrawn BRIGHT #1007585744	$1,795,000	—
Apr 8, 2014	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1007585744	$1,899,000	—
Mar 27, 2014	Expired BRIGHT #1009751568	$1,975,000	—
Jul 12, 2013	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1009751568	$1,975,000	—
Feb 24, 2011	Withdrawn BRIGHT #1009159144	$2,100,000	—
Sep 14, 2010	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1009159144	$2,100,000	—
Jun 7, 2006	Closed BRIGHT #1003525105	$1,650,000	—
May 3, 2006	Pending BRIGHT #1003525105		—
Apr 13, 2006	Withdrawn BRIGHT #PACT340524	$2,150,000	—
Apr 12, 2006	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1003525105	$1,859,900	—
Mar 1, 2006	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #201005429	$1,650,000	-74.1% / yr
Jan 12, 2006	Expired BRIGHT #PACT327970	$2,450,000	—
Jan 11, 2006	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT340524	$2,150,000	—
Dec 29, 2005	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #201005428	$2,075,000	+5.3% / yr
May 10, 2005	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT327970	$2,450,000	—
Sep 20, 2002	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #103128923	$1,750,000	—
Aug 21, 2002	Closed BRIGHT #PACT155196	$1,750,000	—
Jun 5, 2002	Pending BRIGHT #PACT155196		—
Apr 16, 2002	Expired BRIGHT #PACT309586	$1,750,000	—
Apr 16, 2002	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT155196	$1,750,000	—
Apr 16, 2001	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT309586	$1,750,000	—
Jun 15, 2000	Closed BRIGHT #1000006168	$427,000	—
Feb 17, 2000	Pending BRIGHT #1000006168		—
Feb 9, 2000	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1000006168	$430,000	—
Jul 17, 1992	Closed BRIGHT #PACT457410	$270,000	—
Apr 10, 1992	Pending BRIGHT #PACT457410		—
Mar 2, 1992	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT457410	$329,000	—

Date	Event & Source	Price
07/14/2026	Closed BRIGHT #PACT2125520	$1,995,000
07/02/2026	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #1945583152	$1,995,000 +9.3% / yr
05/18/2026	Pending BRIGHT #PACT2125520	—
05/18/2026	Active Under Contract BRIGHT #PACT2125520	—
05/13/2026	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT2125520	$2,150,000
03/29/2021	Closed BRIGHT #PACT526510	$1,400,000
03/29/2021	Closed BRIGHT #PACT526510	$1,250,000
03/23/2021	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #695370633	$1,250,000
03/23/2021	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #1457019805	$1,250,000 -1.8% / yr
01/17/2021	Pending BRIGHT #PACT526510	—
01/01/2021	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT526510	$1,495,000
08/02/2017	Withdrawn BRIGHT #1008018318	$1,500,000
04/29/2016	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1008018318	$1,650,000
12/22/2015	Withdrawn BRIGHT #1007793126	$1,695,000
03/26/2015	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1007793126	$1,695,000
12/11/2014	Withdrawn BRIGHT #1007585744	$1,795,000
04/08/2014	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1007585744	$1,899,000
03/27/2014	Expired BRIGHT #1009751568	$1,975,000
07/12/2013	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1009751568	$1,975,000
02/24/2011	Withdrawn BRIGHT #1009159144	$2,100,000
09/14/2010	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1009159144	$2,100,000
06/07/2006	Closed BRIGHT #1003525105	$1,650,000
05/03/2006	Pending BRIGHT #1003525105	—
04/13/2006	Withdrawn BRIGHT #PACT340524	$2,150,000
04/12/2006	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1003525105	$1,859,900
03/01/2006	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #201005429	$1,650,000 -74.1% / yr
01/12/2006	Expired BRIGHT #PACT327970	$2,450,000
01/11/2006	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT340524	$2,150,000
12/29/2005	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #201005428	$2,075,000 +5.3% / yr
05/10/2005	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT327970	$2,450,000
09/20/2002	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #103128923	$1,750,000
08/21/2002	Closed BRIGHT #PACT155196	$1,750,000
06/05/2002	Pending BRIGHT #PACT155196	—
04/16/2002	Expired BRIGHT #PACT309586	$1,750,000
04/16/2002	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT155196	$1,750,000
04/16/2001	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT309586	$1,750,000
06/15/2000	Closed BRIGHT #1000006168	$427,000
02/17/2000	Pending BRIGHT #1000006168	—
02/09/2000	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #1000006168	$430,000
07/17/1992	Closed BRIGHT #PACT457410	$270,000
04/10/1992	Pending BRIGHT #PACT457410	—
03/02/1992	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #PACT457410	$329,000

For completeness, we often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

Public Records for 959 Garrett Mill Road

Taxable ValueLand$74,680Additions$527,890Total$602,570

Tax Record2026$1,848 ($154 / month)

Home Facts

Beds5Baths5.5Total Finished SqFt7,463 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt7,463 SqFtStories2Lot Size69,696 SqFtStyleSingle Family ResidenceYear Built2001Year Renovated2001ZoningRUCountyCHESTERAPN5406 00750000

Schools near 959 Garrett Mill Road

This home is within Great Valley School District.


Rating	School	Type	Grades	Distance
7/10	Sugartown El School	Public - Serves this home	K to 4	3.3 mi
10/10	Great Valley Middle School	Public - Serves this home	7 to 8	6.9 mi
10/10	Great Valley High School	Public - Serves this home	9 to 12	6.9 mi
8/10	Great Valley 5/6 Center	Public - Nearby school	5 to 6	5.8 mi


Rating	School	Distance
7/10	Sugartown El School PublicK to 4 Serves this home	3.3 mi
10/10	Great Valley Middle School Public7 to 8 Serves this home	6.9 mi
10/10	Great Valley High School Public9 to 12 Serves this home	6.9 mi
8/10	Great Valley 5/6 Center Public5 to 6 Nearby school	5.8 mi

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

New listings in 19073

$1,075,000 | 758 Darby Paoli Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/69

Open: 8/23 02:00PM - 03:30PMNew

$1,075,000

4
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 3,372
Square Feet: 1.75
Acres

758 Darby Paoli Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073

$429,900 | 405 Hempstead Circle, Unit 1012, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/35

Coming SoonOpen: 8/22 12:00PM - 04:00PM

$429,900

4
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2,368
Square Feet: 0.66
Acres

405 Hempstead Circle, Unit 1012, Newtown Square, PA 19073

$2,650,000 | 4 Harrison Drive, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/10

Coming SoonOpen: 8/27 12:00PM - 02:00PM

$2,650,000

5
Bedrooms: 6
Bathrooms: 6,895
Square Feet: Unavailable
Acres

4 Harrison Drive, Newtown Square, PA 19073

$1,195,000 | 3723 Rosemont Pass, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/35

Listed By CompassOpen: 8/23 02:00PM - 04:00PM

$1,195,000

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 3,228
Square Feet: 0.12
Acres

3723 Rosemont Pass, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/22

$365,000

2
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,135
Square Feet

1102 Pritchard Place, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/64

$1,595,000

5
Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 4,277
Square Feet: 1.73
Acres

361 Malin Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073

$2,200,000 | 857 Briarwood Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/77

Virtual Tour

$2,200,000

5
Bedrooms: 6
Bathrooms: 6,050
Square Feet: 2.66
Acres

857 Briarwood Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073

$1,225,000 | 1710 Cold Spring Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/34

Virtual Tour

$1,225,000

5
Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 4,117
Square Feet: 1.3
Acres

1710 Cold Spring Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073

1/6

$350,000

4
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2,800
Square Feet: 0.25
Acres

1500 Meadow Hunt Lane, Newtown Square, PA 19073

Nearby home values

Address	Sold price	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot (Sqft)
This home: 959 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	$1,995,000	6	6	7,463	69,696
944 Garrett Mill Road, Malvern, PA 19355	$4,050,000	6	7	6,875	757,944
980 Garrett Mill Road, Malvern, PA 19355	$2,700,000	–	7	3,600	–
982 Garrett Mill Road, Malvern, PA 19355	$1,510,000	–	–	–	871,200
955 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	$375,000	4	1	1,826	115,434
951 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	$387,000	2	2	1,826	106,722
929 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	–	–	–	–	1,451,332
988 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	$2,700,000	5	6	9,142	805,860
981 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	–	–	–	–	100,188
961 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	–	–	–	–	–
940 Garrett Mill Road, Malvern, PA 19355	–	–	–	–	1,359,072
986 Garrett Mill Road, West Chester, PA 19380	–	4	2	2,002	113,256
928 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	$4,408,769	7	9	–	209,088
992 Garrett Mill Road, West Chester, PA 19380	$375,000	3	3	3,056	618,857
994 Garrett Mill Road, Newtown Square, PA 19073	$1,350,000	4	3	3,892	605,484
1002 Garrett Mill Road, West Chester, PA 19380	$925,000	5	3	3,350	348,480

Explore Nearby Homes

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of any information, descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified through appropriate means, including, but not limited to, in person inspection and public records, and Compass International Holdings, its subsidiaries, affiliates and independently owned and operated franchisees, and their affiliated agents and associated third parties expressly disclaim any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the seller's discretion. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Main Line

Based on information from one of the following Multiple Listing Services: BRIGHT, Greater LeHigh Valley Regional MLS, Greator Scranton Board of REALTORS® and Pocono Mountains Association of REALTORS®. Information being provided is for the visitor’s personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties visitor may be interested in purchasing. The data contained herein is copyrighted by BRIGHT, Greater LeHigh Valley Regional MLS, Greator Scranton Board of REALTORS® and Pocono Mountains Association of REALTORS® is protected by all applicable copyright laws. Any dissemination of this information is in violation of copyright laws and is strictly prohibited. Property information referenced on this web site comes from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the MLS. This web site may reference real estate listing(s) held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent who owns this web site. For the avoidance of doubt, the accuracy of all information, regardless of source, is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be personally verified through personal inspection by and/or with the appropriate professionals.

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Explore Nearby Homes

Homes in Nearby Willistown Township - Chester County Neighborhoods

Homes in Nearby Willistown Township - Chester County Cities

Homes in Nearby Willistown Township - Chester County Zip Codes