1401 Mckinstrys Mill Road

Closed 8/30/23

Sold

Last Sold Price

$457,500

3 beds2 baths1,936 sqft

1401 Mckinstrys Mill Rd, New Windsor, MD 21776

Single FamilyProperty Type

1.38 acresLot Size

1889Year Built

$236/sq ftPrice per sq ft

6 carsParking Spaces

Description

Oh my! This is such a BEAUTY! Built in 1866 this charming colonial home will allow you to step back in time. Some of the unique features include charming full front porch with room for rocking chairs, a back screened in porch and upper level screened in porch, 2 interior stairways to the upper level (one is believed to have lead to the private servant quarters) , original hardwood floors, 2 original (non-functional) fireplaces, German lap siding, sun porch with back pantry, Stone foundation, original...Oh my! This is such a BEAUTY! Built in 1866 this charming colonial home will allow you to step back in time. Some of the unique features include charming full front porch with room for rocking chairs, a back screened in porch and upper level screened in porch, 2 interior stairways to the upper level (one is believed to have lead to the private servant quarters) , original hardwood floors, 2 original (non-functional) fireplaces, German lap siding, sun porch with back pantry, Stone foundation, original doors and hardware, Central air conditioning, walk out basement, original columns on the front porch too! AND - the original barn is standing! You have so much wonderful history here. Some of the updates include....water heater 2018, furnace w/i 10 years, painted inside/outside 5 years ago, bathroom remodeled 5 years ago, metal roof 5 years old, oil tank 2-3 yrs old, Septic newer (conventional), windows reglazed 3 years ago, internet rewired (tower stream), some replacement windows, corian counters in kitchen, stainless appliances, and so much more! Originally, when built, this was a second home to a wealthy merchant. Years later, 3-4 generations of Howards and Senseneys made this home. The current owners have cherished this property for 40 years. Who will be next? It's a great home and wait til you see the views!

Listed by: Stephanie A Myers 410.259.0525 stephanie.myers@lnf.com • Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.

Listing closed: 08/30/2023 12:00 AM • Source: BRIGHT, MLS#: MDCR2014992

Recent comparable sales

Median sold price

$414,900

Avg days on market

Sale-to-list ratio

99.3%

1/74

$351,000

Sold 08/29/25

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,733
Square Feet: 0.11
Acres

210 High Street, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/31

$414,900

Sold 06/30/26

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,694
Square Feet: 0.33
Acres

1183 Jo Apter Place, New Windsor, MD 21776

a front view of a house with a yard and garage

1/67

$445,000

Sold 09/18/25

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1,786
Square Feet: 0.32
Acres

1188 Jo Apter Place, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/49

$420,000

Sold 02/04/25

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1,820
Square Feet: 0.33
Acres

1174 Jo Apter Place, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/38

$430,000

Sold 05/21/26

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1,892
Square Feet: 0.38
Acres

3190 Vista Court, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/35

$390,000

Sold 09/11/26

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 2,291
Square Feet: 0.20
Acres

315 College Avenue, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/37

$370,000

Sold 11/10/25

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1,618
Square Feet: 1
Acres

1912 Old New Windsor Road, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/38

$375,000

Sold 04/30/26

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 936
Square Feet: 0.43
Acres

1038 Green Valley Road, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/44

$485,000

Sold 09/18/26

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2,050
Square Feet: 1.53
Acres

118 South Clear Ridge Road, New Windsor, MD 21776

Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage¹

Location

Homepage
MD
Carroll County
New Windsor
21776
1401 Mckinstrys Mill Rd

Listing Courtesy of Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.

Sold By Next Step Realty

Add your commute

Payment Calculator

Get preapproved with
OriginPoint Mortgage or Rocket Mortgage¹

$2,663 per month

30 year fixed, 7.03% Interest

Principal and Interest

$2,442

Property Taxes

$220

HOA Dues

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Property Information for 1401 Mckinstrys Mill Road

Property Details

Taxes: $2,645 / year
MLS Type: Residential / Fee Simple
County: Carroll County
Tax ID Number: 0711005349
Ownership: Fee Simple
Condo Coop Association: No
HOA: No
Structure Type: Detached
Style: Traditional, Colonial
Levels/Stories: 3
Waterfront: No
Garage: No
Subdivision: NONE AVAILABLE
Subdivision: NONE AVAILABLE (CARROLL MD)
Legal Subdivision: NEW WINDSOR ELECTION DISTRICT
Total Parking Spaces: 6
Central Air: Yes
Basement: Yes
Room Count: 7
Above Grade Finished SQFT: 1,936.00
Above Grade Fin SQFT Source: Assessor
Below Grade Finished SQFT: .00
Below Grade Fin SQFT Source: Assessor
Below Grade Unfinished SQFT: 680.00
Below Grade Unfin SQFT Source: Assessor
Total Below Grade SQFT: 680.00
Total Below Grade SQFT Source: Assessor
New Construction: No
Property Condition: Very Good

Building Information

Stories: 3
Year Built: 1889
Lot Size: 1.38 AC / 60,113 SF

Location

Location

In City Limits: No
School District Name: CARROLL COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS

School District County ID: 121139051837
SchoolDistrictSource: 3rd Party
Elementary School: ELMER A. WOLFE (CARROLL MD)
ElementarySchoolSource: 3rd Party
Middle Or Junior School: NEW WINDSOR (CARROLL MD)
MiddleSchoolSource: 3rd Party
High School: FRANCIS SCOTT KEY SENIOR (CARROLL MD)
HighSchoolSource: 3rd Party
County: CARROLL

Waterfront / Water Access

Waterfront / Water Access

Water View: No
Water Access: No

Water Oriented: No
Navigable Water: No
Tidal Water: No
Riparian Rights Y/N: No

Association / Community Info

Association / Community Info

Senior Community: No

Taxes and Assessment

Taxes and Assessment

Tax Year: 2023
Tax Assessed Value: $231,500

Year Assessed: 2023
County Tax: $2,585
Improvement Assessed Value: $100,400
Land Assessed Value: $133,800
Clean Green Assessed: No
Land Use Code: R
Zoning: RESIDENTIAL
Automatically Update Tax Values Y/N: Yes
TaxDataUpdatedYN: No

Lease Information

Lease Information

Concessions: No

Rooms

Main

# Bedrooms Count Main Level: 0
# Bathrooms Count Main Level: 1

# Bathrooms Full Main Level: 0
# Bathrooms Half Main Level: 1

All Upper Levels

# Bedrooms Count All Upper Levels: 3
# Bathrooms Count All Upper Levels: 1

# Bathrooms Full All Upper Levels: 1

Upper Level 1

# Bedrooms Count Upper Level: 3
# Bathrooms Count Upper Level: 1

# Bathrooms Full Upper Level: 1

Rooms

Room List: Living Room, Dining Room, Bedroom 2, Bedroom 3, Kitchen, Bedroom 1, Laundry, Bathroom 1, Half Bath
Stories: Lower 1, Main, Upper 1

Rooms Information

Room 1

Room Type: Living Room
Room Level: Main

Room Exists: Yes
Room Features: Flooring - HardWood, Crown Molding

Room 2

Room Type: Dining Room
Room Level: Main

Room Exists: Yes
Room Features: Flooring - HardWood, Formal Dining Room

Room 3

Room Type: Kitchen
Room Level: Main

Room Exists: Yes
Room Features: Flooring - Vinyl, Kitchen - Country, Countertop(s) - Solid Surface, Kitchen - Eat-in, Kitchen - Gas Cooking

Room 4

Room Type: Half Bath
Room Level: Main

Room Exists: Yes
Room Features: Flooring - Tile

Room 5

Room Type: Bedroom 1
Room Level: Upper 1

Room Exists: Yes
Room Features: Flooring - HardWood, Balcony Access

Room 6

Room Type: Bedroom 2
Room Level: Upper 1

Room Exists: Yes
Room Features: Flooring - HardWood

Room 7

Room Type: Bedroom 3
Room Level: Upper 1

Room Exists: Yes
Room Features: Flooring - HardWood

Room 8

Room Type: Bathroom 1
Room Level: Upper 1

Room Exists: Yes
Room Features: Flooring - Tile, Tub Shower

Room 9

Room Type: Laundry
Room Level: Lower 1

Room Exists: Yes

Building Info

Building Info

Total Finished SQFT: 1,936.00
Total Finished SQFT Source: Assessor

Tax Total Finished SQFT: 1,936.00
Total SQFT: 2,616.00
Total SQFT Source: Assessor
Construction Materials: Wood Siding
Roof: Metal
Ext Main Mid-res: http://bright-media01.prd.brightmls.com/bright/images/0000/8024/1780/0684/802417800684_512_384_WM_E22DegA0YXOL6k_7.jpg
Wall and Ceiling Types: 9'+ Ceilings, Plaster Walls
Flooring Type: Hardwood
Basement Type: Full, Unfinished, Walkout Level, Windows, Workshop
Foundation Details: Stone
Room and Floor: Bathrooms Half-Main Level-1, Bedrooms-Upper Level 1-1, Bedrooms-Upper Level 1-2, Bedrooms-Upper Level 1-3, Bathrooms Full-Upper Level 1-1
# Bathrooms Full: 1
# Bathrooms Half: 1
Other Structure: Barn

Lot / Land Information

Lot / Land Information

Lot Size Source: Assessor
Lot Features: Backs to Trees, Landscaping, Level, Partly Wooded, Private, Rural, Secluded

Fencing: Partially
Parcel ID: 11467608

Parking

Parking

Type Of Parking: Driveway
Driveway - # of Spaces: 6

Parking Features: Stone Driveway, Private

Interior Features

Interior Features

Interior Features: Additional Stairway, Attic, Built-Ins, Crown Moldings, Floor Plan - Traditional, Kitchen - Country, Kitchen - Eat-In, Pantry, Tub Shower, Upgraded Countertops, Wainscotting, Water Treat System, Wood Floors
Fireplace: Yes

Fireplaces Count: 2
Fireplace Features: Non-Functioning
Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Washer, Refrigerator, Water Heater, Exhaust Fan, Oven/Range - Gas, Stainless Steel Appliances, Water Conditioner - Owned, Air Cleaner
Accessibility Features: None
Door Features: Storm
Window Features: Replacement, Screens, Double Pane, Transom
Laundry Type: Basement, Has Laundry

Exterior Features

Exterior Features

Exterior Features: Exterior Lighting, Outbuilding(s)
Outdoor Living Structures: Porch(es), Roof, Screened, Balcony, Enclosed

Pool: No Pool

Utilities

Utilities

Utilities: Propane
Heating: Yes

Cooling Type: Central A/C
Cooling Fuel: Electric
Heating Type: Forced Air
Heating Fuel: Oil
Hot Water: Electric
Water Source: Well
Sewer Septic: On Site Septic
Internet Services: Fixed Wireless

Property History for 1401 Mckinstrys Mill Road

Date	Event & Source	Price	Appreciation
Aug 30, 2023	Closed BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	$457,500	—
Aug 29, 2023	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #1518148938	$457,500	—
Jul 31, 2023	Price Change BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	$460,000	—
Jul 28, 2023	Pending BRIGHT #MDCR2014992		—
Jul 24, 2023	Price Change BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	$449,900	—
Jun 30, 2023	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #MDCR2014992		—
Jun 18, 2023	Pending BRIGHT #MDCR2014992		—
Jun 16, 2023	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	$475,000	—

Date	Event & Source	Price
08/30/2023	Closed BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	$457,500
08/29/2023	Closed (Public Record) Public Record #1518148938	$457,500
07/31/2023	Price Change BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	$460,000
07/28/2023	Pending BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	—
07/24/2023	Price Change BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	$449,900
06/30/2023	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	—
06/18/2023	Pending BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	—
06/16/2023	Listed (Active) BRIGHT #MDCR2014992	$475,000

For completeness, we often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

Public records

1401 Mckinstrys Mill Road

Beds

Baths

1.5

Total Finished SqFt

1,936 SqFt

Above Grade Finished SqFt

1,936 SqFt

Stories

Lot Size

60,113 SqFt

Schools near 1401 Mckinstrys Mill Road

This home is within Carroll County Public Schools.


Rating	School	Type	Grades	Distance
6/10	Elmer A. Wolfe Elementary School	Public - Serves this home	PK to 5	2.9 mi
7/10	Northwest Middle School	Public - Serves this home	6 to 8	7.9 mi
8/10	Francis Scott Key High School	Public - Serves this home	9 to 12	4.0 mi
NR	Pride School	Public - Choice school	K to 5	8.2 mi
NR	Carroll County Career & Technology Center	Public - Choice school	11 to 12	8.8 mi
NR	Crossroads Middle School	Public - Choice school	6 to 8	8.9 mi


Rating	School	Distance
6/10	Elmer A. Wolfe Elementary School PublicPK to 5 Serves this home	2.9 mi
7/10	Northwest Middle School Public6 to 8 Serves this home	7.9 mi
8/10	Francis Scott Key High School Public9 to 12 Serves this home	4.0 mi
NR	Pride School PublicK to 5 Choice school	8.2 mi
NR	Carroll County Career & Technology Center Public11 to 12 Choice school	8.8 mi
NR	Crossroads Middle School Public6 to 8 Choice school	8.9 mi

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

New listings in 21776

1/38

$500,000

3
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,640
Square Feet: 1
Acres

3012 Merle Court, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/63

$525,000

5
Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 2,771
Square Feet: 1.76
Acres

3050 Hooper Road, New Windsor, MD 21776

a front view of a residential apartment building with a yard

1/45

Virtual Tour

$420,000

3
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2,320
Square Feet: 0.07
Acres

2807 Town View Circle, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/48

$649,900

4
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2,794
Square Feet: 0.17
Acres

2728 Town View Circle, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/55

$559,900

4
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 3,328
Square Feet: 0.19
Acres

2820 Town View Circle, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/45

$449,000

2
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,544
Square Feet: 0.30
Acres

2896 Town View Circle, New Windsor, MD 21776

$529,900 | 2828 Graybill Court, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/70

Open: 10/10 01:00PM - 03:00PM

$529,900

5
Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 2,774
Square Feet: 0.36
Acres

2828 Graybill Court, New Windsor, MD 21776

a front view of a house with a garden and trees

1/71

Active Under Contract

$594,900

4
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2,840
Square Feet: 1.52
Acres

1423 Hallowell Lane, New Windsor, MD 21776

1/31

$345,900

4
Bedrooms: 2
Bathrooms: 1,772
Square Feet: 0.26
Acres

1326 Old New Windsor Road, New Windsor, MD 21776

Nearby home values

Address	Sold price	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot (Sqft)
This home: 1401 Mckinstrys Mill Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	$457,500	3	2	1,936	60,113
1470 Mckinstrys Mill Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	–	–	2	2,088	51,009
1495 Mckinstrys Mill Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	–	–	2.5	2,222	69,260
1475 Mckinstrys Mill Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	–	–	1	1,440	67,082
1460 Marble Quarry Road, Union Bridge, MD 21791	$190,000	3	2	–	33,889
1485 Mckinstrys Mill Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	–	–	3	1,680	60,113
1440 Marble Quarry Road, Union Bridge, MD 21791	$150,000	–	1	1,260	34,335
4504 Sams Creek Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	–	–	2.5	2,092	310,583
1470 Marble Quarry Road, Union Bridge, MD 21791	–	–	–	–	57,499
1291 Mckinstrys Mill Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	–	–	1.5	2,992	4,268,444
1494 Mckinstrys Mill Road, Union Bridge, MD 21791	–	–	1	3,540	196,020
4400 Sams Creek Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	$115,000	–	1	1,088	76,230
1310 Marble Quarry Road, Union Bridge, MD 21791	$40,000	–	1.5	2,738	4,380,394
4500 Sams Creek Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	–	–	1	1,592	31,036
1401 Marble Quarry Road, Union Bridge, MD 21791	–	–	1	1,066	43,560
4404 Sams Creek Road, New Windsor, MD 21776	$268,000	3	1	1,172	19,620

Explore Nearby Homes

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of any information, descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified through appropriate means, including, but not limited to, in person inspection and public records, and Compass International Holdings, its subsidiaries, affiliates and independently owned and operated franchisees, and their affiliated agents and associated third parties expressly disclaim any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the seller's discretion. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Listing Courtesy of Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.

© 2026 Bright MLS. All rights reserved. All information is deemed reliable, but accuracy is not guaranteed. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in IDX and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided is for the consumer’s personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated on 08/30/2023 11:46 AM

1401 Mckinstrys Mill Rd, New Windsor, MD 21776

New Windsor, MD

Property Details

Building Information

Location

Waterfront / Water Access

Association / Community Info

Taxes and Assessment

Lease Information

Rooms

Rooms Information

Building Info

Lot / Land Information

Parking

Interior Features

Exterior Features

Utilities

Beds

Baths

Total Finished SqFt

Above Grade Finished SqFt

Stories

Lot Size

Explore Nearby Homes

Homes in Nearby 21776 Neighborhoods

Homes in Nearby 21776 Cities

Homes in Nearby 21776 Zip Codes