15 S Menantic Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964

$9,955,000
Price
9
Beds
3,944 Sq. Ft.
$2,524 / Sq. Ft.
3,944
Sq. Ft.
$2,524
per Sq. Ft.
Bird's eye view of a heavily wooded area and a large body of water
Bird's eye view of a heavily wooded area and a large body of water
a front view of a house with a yard
View of front of house featuring covered porch, a chimney, and a shingled roof
a front view of a building with a yard
a view of a house with a yard
a view of house with outdoor space
a view of a lake in a backyard
a yard with water view
a living room with furniture and a floor to ceiling window
a living room with furniture a flat screen tv and floor to ceiling window
a living room with furniture and a large window
a view of a dining room with furniture window and wooden floor
15A
a living room with furniture and a large window
15A
a bedroom with a bed and a bookshelf
a bathroom with a sink toilet and shower
15A
a bedroom with a bed and wooden floor
a bed room with a bed tv and a window
a bathroom with a granite countertop sink a mirror and shower
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances a stove a microwave and cabinets
a outdoor dining space with furniture and window
a view of a dining room with furniture and wooden floor
15A
a living room with furniture and a window
15A
a spacious bedroom with furniture and a large window
13
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop a refrigerator and a sink
a kitchen with a refrigerator and potted plant
13
a bedroom with a bed and a window
13
a bedroom with a bed and large windows
a bathroom with a sink a toilet and mirror
a bathroom with a sink a toilet and a mirror
a bedroom with a bed and a dresser
a front view of a house with a yard
a view of a backyard with plants
a view of a field with a tree
a backyard of a house with lots of green space

Description

For the first time in over a century, this extraordinary collection of generationally owned properties is being offered together as a singular and rare opportunity. Nestled along the serene and picturesque Menantic Creek, these three separate parcels combined total 4.9 acres, which have been combined into one sale, presenting an unrivaled waterfront retreat. The Menantic Creek, known as Hurricane Hole for boat protection during storms, offers boating access to both the North and South Forks and a...For the first time in over a century, this extraordinary collection of generationally owned properties is being offered together as a singular and rare opportunity. Nestled along the serene and picturesque Menantic Creek, these three separate parcels combined total 4.9 acres, which have been combined into one sale, presenting an unrivaled waterfront retreat. The Menantic Creek, known as Hurricane Hole for boat protection during storms, offers boating access to both the North and South Forks and a short run to Montauk. For the boating enthusiast, this offering includes a 100-foot stationary dock, complete with a 6-foot-wide walkway with a bench, as well as a 12-foot plastic ramp leading to a 30x6 ft. floating dock with three anchor pilings. Two moorings on the creek are also available, pending reapplication. At the heart of this offering is 15A Menantic Road, a legally designated two-family residence with a breathtaking 3,944 square feet of meticulously renovated living space. This refined home features five bedrooms, 4 plus 2 1/2 baths, and a 483-square-foot garage, all thoughtfully designed to maximize the stunning creek views. Taxes: $12,206.00

Adjacent to this residence is 15 Menantic Road, a pristine and vacant 1.3-acre parcel, offering endless potential to further enhance this exceptional estate. Taxes: $4,325.00
Completing the trio is 13 Menantic Road, a charming 1930s bungalow with two bedrooms and one bath set on 1.47 acres and a brand new two story 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home with attached two car garage in the final stages of completion. Taxes: $8,521.00

What truly sets this estate apart is its extraordinary arboretum-like setting, adorned with a curated collection of rare and mature specimen trees, including Copper Beech, Southern Magnolia, White Birch, Monkey Puzzle, Dawn Redwoods, Linden, Osage Orange, Red Japanese Maple, and Dogwood. The natural beauty of this land is simply unparalleled. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a waterfront compound with limitless potential—a legal multi-family residence, a historic bungalow, a new construction home and an untouched parcel—all in one of the most coveted locations. A truly rare find for the discerning buyer seeking exclusivity, natural beauty, and unparalleled waterfront living.
  1. Listed by Paula M. Jerman • Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
    P: (631)-288-1050 paulajerman@danielgale.com

Property Details for 15 South Menantic Road

City/Township
Shelter Island
View
Water
Architectural Style
Contemporary
Garage Spaces
2.00
Waterfront
Yes
LISTING UPDATED: 05/30/2025 02:05 PM

Property Details for 15 South Menantic Road

StatusActive
MLS #842673
Days on Market278
Taxes$25,052 / year
HOA Fees-
Condo/Co-op Fees-
Compass TypeSingle Family
MLS TypeSingle Family
Year Built1983
Lot Size4.90 AC / 213,444 SF
CountySuffolk County

Location

Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, Paula M. Jerman
Add your commute

Building Information for 15 South Menantic Road

Stories-Year Built1983Building Size-Lot Size4.90 AC / 213,444 SF

Payment Calculator

$51,279 per month

30 year fixed, 6.28% Interest

Principal and Interest

$49,191

Property Taxes

$2,088

HOA Dues

$0

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Property Information for 15 South Menantic Road

Summary
Location and General Information
  • Village: Dering Harbor
  • Senior Community YN: No
  • Directions: GPS
  • Property Attached: Yes
  • Structure Type: true
  • Levels: Two
  • State Or Province: NY
School Information
  • School District: Shelter Island
  • Elementary School: Contact Agent
  • Middle Or Junior School: Shelter Island School
  • High School District: Shelter Island
  • High School: Shelter Island School
Rental
Rental
  • Lease Considered: No
Unit Information
Unit Information
  • Building Units Total: 1
Room Information
Room 1 Information
  • Room Type: Bathroom 4
Taxes and HOA Information
Taxes and HOA Information
  • Parcel Number: 0700-018-00-03-00-012-002
  • Tax Assessed Value: $1,808,000.00
  • Association: No
Interior and Exterior Features
Interior Features
  • Amenities: Back Yard, Basketball Court, Basketball Hoop, Boat Slip, Ceramic Tile, Contemporary, Creek, Deck, Dock, Dog Run, Eat in Kitchen, Electric Dryer Hookup, Entrance Foyer, Family Room, First Floor Full Bath, Formal Dining, Front Yard, Garage(s), Garden, Guest House, Hardwood Floors As Seen, Living Room, Mooring, Outbuilding, Patio, Playground, Primary Bathroom, Rain Gutters, Shed(s), Vinyl, Water View, Well, Wood Burning Stove
  • Interior Features: First Floor Full Bath, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, Primary Bathroom
  • Appliances: Convection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Cooktop, Electric Oven, Electric Water Heater, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer
  • Total Rooms: 16
  • Basement: Partially Finished, Storage Space
  • Attic Description: Full
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Fireplaces Total: 2
  • Fireplace Features: Family Room, Living Room, Wood Burning Stove
  • Location Amenities: Stainless Steel Appliances, Exposure East, Basketball Court, Dock/Mooring, Wood Burning Stove, Hardwood Floors As Seen, Eat in Kitchen, Entry Foyer, Foyer, Formal Dining Room, Garden, Out Building, Deck, Patio, Water View
  • Laundry Features: Electric Dryer Hookup
  • Spa: No
  • Flooring: Ceramic Tile, Hardwood, Vinyl
  • Living Area: 3,944.00
  • Basement: Yes
Exterior Features
  • Exterior Features: Basketball Court, Basketball Hoop, Boat Slip, Dock, Dog Run, Garden, Mooring, Playground, Rain Gutters
  • Exterior Property Features: Basketball Court, Basketball Hoop, Boat Slip, Dock, Dog Run, Garden, Mooring, Playground, Rain Gutters, Deck, Patio, Driveway, Garage, Shared Driveway, Back Yard, Front Yard, Cleared, Level
  • Elevation Certificate: No
  • Fencing: Back Yard,Front Yard
  • Patio And Porch Features: Deck,Patio
  • Construction Materials: Frame
  • Road Frontage Type: County Road
  • Road Responsibility: Public Maintained Road
  • Other Structures: Garage(s),Guest House,Outbuilding,Shed(s)
  • Waterfront Features: Creek
  • Horse: No
  • Pool Private: No
  • Direction Faces: East
Lot Information
  • Lot Features: Back Yard, Cleared, Front Yard, Garden, Level
  • Additional Parcel: Yes
  • Site Features: Back Yard, Cleared, Front Yard, Garden, Level
  • Building Area Units: Square Feet
Parking
  • Parking Features: Driveway, Garage, Shared Driveway
  • Garage: Yes
  • Carport: No
Utilities
  • Cooling: Central Air
  • Heating: Electric
  • Heat Fuel Type: Electric
  • Sewer: Cesspool
  • Water Source: Well
  • Utilities: Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Trash Collection Private, Water Connected
Green Features
  • Green Features: Convection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Cooktop, Electric Oven, Electric Water Heater, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer, Electric, Basketball Court, Basketball Hoop, Boat Slip, Dock, Dog Run, Garden, Mooring, Playground, Rain Gutters
Virtual Tour
Agent
Payment and Rate
  • Down Payment Resource: No

Public Records for 15 South Menantic Road

Taxable ValueLand$698,300Additions-Total$698,300
Tax Record2020$4,259 ($355 / month)
Home Facts
Beds0Lot Size56,628 SqFtStyleResidentialZoningCCountySUFFOLKAPN0700018000300012001

Schools near 15 South Menantic Road

This home is within Shelter Island Union Free School District.
Rating
School
Type
Grades
Distance
Shelter Island School
Public - PK to 12
Rating
School
Distance
Shelter Island School
PublicPK to 12

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

Similar Sold Homes

Explore Nearby Homes

More information about 15 South Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

15 South Menantic Road is a single family home for sale in Shelter Island, NY 11964. This property was listed for sale on March 31, 2025 by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, it's currently listed at $9,955,000. This listing's school district is Shelter Island Union Free School District. Nearby schools include Shelter Island School. 15 South Menantic Road is a 9-bed, 6-bath, 3,944 sqft single family home built in 1983.

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified, and Compass, Inc., its subsidiaries, affiliates and their agents and associated third parties expressly disclaims any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the discretion of the seller. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity. Subject to change at any time. Compass makes no guarantee, warranty or representation regarding the accuracy of any waterfront feature, water view or waterfront view.

Listing Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, Paula M. Jerman

Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 01/04/2026 08:26 AM. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker orMLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All informationshould be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed bythe office/agent presenting the information.