2421 Prospect St

Sarasota, FL 34239

$899,000
Price
3
Beds
972 Sq. Ft.
$925 / Sq. Ft.
972
Sq. Ft.
$925
per Sq. Ft.
Virtual Tour
Virtual Tour
a front view of a house with a yard and outdoor seating
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop sink stove top oven and cabinets
a room with lots of tables and chairs
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances a sink stove and refrigerator
a living room with furniture and a couch
a living room with stainless steel appliances kitchen view and a flat screen tv
a kitchen with a sink cabinets and wooden floor
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop a sink stove and refrigerator
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop a stove a sink and a microwave
a kitchen with granite countertop a sink stainless steel appliances and cabinets
a dining room with furniture and wooden floor
a bathroom with a toilet and a sink
a living room with furniture and a flat screen tv
a bathroom with a double vanity sink mirror and toilet
a bathroom with a shower
a bed sitting in a bedroom next to a window
a view of a workspace with furniture and a window
a view of a backyard with table and chairs under an umbrella
aerial view of a house with a yard
a view of a chairs and tables in the back yard of the house
an aerial view of a house
an aerial view of multiple house
an aerial view of a house with a yard and lake view
a group of people sitting in front of retail shops
a view of a house with a yard
a view of outdoor space with seating area
a view of a patio with table and chairs potted plants with wooden fence
front view of a house with a yard

Description

Welcome to 2421 Prospect Street in Arlington Park’s Tightly Held RUSTIC LODGE…This Architectural Masterpiece is Rooted in Sarasota’s Golden Era of Homebuilding…the 1950s Marked a Time When Homes Were Designed & Built with Longevity & Craftsmanship—This Residence is a Beautiful Reflection of That Legacy…Approached Not as a Renovation but as a Custom Crafted Rebuild... A Design-Conscious Modern Builder Honored the Original Vision While Elevating the Home to Meet Today’s Expectations for Style, Comfort,...Welcome to 2421 Prospect Street in Arlington Park’s Tightly Held RUSTIC LODGE…This Architectural Masterpiece is Rooted in Sarasota’s Golden Era of Homebuilding…the 1950s Marked a Time When Homes Were Designed & Built with Longevity & Craftsmanship—This Residence is a Beautiful Reflection of That Legacy…Approached Not as a Renovation but as a Custom Crafted Rebuild... A Design-Conscious Modern Builder Honored the Original Vision While Elevating the Home to Meet Today’s Expectations for Style, Comfort, and Quality…the Integrity, Proportions, and Character Remain Intact, Now Enhanced by Refined Finishes, Seamlessly Integrated Contemporary Systems, Forward-Thinking Infrastructure, and Improvements Aligned with City of Sarasota Code…Sleek, Clean, and Effortlessly Cool—As Though the 1950s Walked Into 2026 With Style…Expansive New PGT Impact Windows, Sliders, and Doors Bathe the Home in Light While Preserving Energy & Maintaining Tranquility Throughout the Day…Every Detail Has Been Carefully Considered, Including All New Plumbing with Cast Iron Replacement Beneath the Slab, All New Electrical Wiring, HVAC Ductwork, and Engineered Structural Enhancements to Create an Open Floorplan…Level Four+ Walls & Ceilings, Insulated Interior Walls in Key Areas, Freshly Blown Attic Insulation, Tankless Hot Water Heater, Fresh Interior & Exterior Paint, White Oak Plank Flooring with Four-Inch Baseboards, Frameless Glass Shower Doors, Custom Walk-In Closets, and Soft-Close Cabinetry Throughout…Curated Quartz Countertops Extend Across the Gourmet Chef’s Kitchen, Catering Pantry, Dry Bar, and Bathrooms…Additional Home Features Include Custom Tile Backsplashes, Substantial Kitchen Island with Tile Accent Lighting, and Vented Range Hood…Discreetly Integrated Throughout is a Fully Automated Smart Home System Offering Complete Flexibility—Including Remote Entry Keypads, Wireless Alarm, Ring Cameras, Motion Detectors, Panic Buttons, Remote-Control Ceiling Fans, USB & USB-C Outlets, Nest Thermostat, and Digitally Controlled Irrigation—Allowing the Home to Be Fully Automated or Enjoyed Traditionally at the Owner’s Preference…A Fully Screened Lanai with Custom Hardwood Tongue & Groove Ceiling Extends the Living Space Outdoors, Complemented by New Epoxy Flooring Leading to the Paver Patio with Pool, Spa, and Outdoor Living Concepts Available Upon Request…The Grounds Have Been Curated with a Six-Figure Landscape & Lighting Package Featuring Fully Fenced, Double-Gated Privacy, Mature Junipers, Clusia Hedges, Olive Trees, Bird of Paradise, and Fragrant Jasmine…A Three-Bedroom, One-and-a-Half-Bath Residence in the Heart & Soul of Arlington Park—Just Blocks to the Arlington Park & Aquatic Center Where You’ll Find Live Music Events Alongside Pickleball, Tennis, Basketball Courts, Playgrounds, a Dog Park, Walking Trails, and Two Pools…One Mile to Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Minutes From Downtown Sarasota, Siesta Key, Longboat Key, Anna Maria Island, UTC Mall, and a Depth of Dining & Cultural Offerings Favored by Locals…Just a Fifteen-Minute Drive to Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport…Weekly Rentals Are Allowed, Not in a Flood Zone, No Storm Damage Ever, No HOA, and Offered Turn-Key Furnished or Thoughtfully Curated to Buyer Preferences…Passed Down Through Only Two Owners Since the 1950s, This Home Represents Stewardship, Architectural Lineage, and Forward-Thinking Living…It’s Timeless, Intentional, and Unmistakably Rare…Schedule Your Private Tour and Live a Fuller Life!
  1. Listed by Bo Fuller • Brokerage DRE #1071481 • FULLER GROUP
    P: (941)-961-3100 C: (941)-961-3100 bo@fullergrouprealestate.com

Property Details for 2421 Prospect Street

Architectural Style
Bungalow, Cape Cod, Coastal, Craftsman, Elevated, Florida, Patio, Ranch, Traditional
Subdivision Name
RUSTIC LODGE 2
Township
36
Carport Spaces
1
View
Garden, Trees/Woods
Waterfront
No
Furnished
Negotiable
LISTING UPDATED: 01/26/2026 07:30 PM

Property Details for 2421 Prospect Street

StatusActive
MLS #A4677367
Days on Market9
Taxes$4,592 / year
HOA Fees-
Condo/Co-op Fees-
Compass TypeSingle Family
MLS TypeResidential / Single Family Residence
Year Built1956
Lot Size0.14 AC / 5,964 SF
CountySarasota County

Location

Listing Courtesy of FULLER GROUP, Bo Fuller
Add your commute

Virtual Tour

Building Information for 2421 Prospect Street

Stories1Year Built1956Building Size-Lot Size0.14 AC / 5,964 SF

Payment Calculator

$4,764 per month

30 year fixed, 6.15% Interest

Principal and Interest

$4,382

Property Taxes

$383

HOA Dues

$0

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Property Information for 2421 Prospect Street

Summary
Location and General Information
  • Building Area Source: Public Records
  • Building Area Total: 1476.0
  • Building Area Units: Square Feet
  • Community Features: Fishing, Water Access, Association Recreation - Owned, Clubhouse, Dog Park, Fitness Center, Golf Carts OK, Park, Playground, Pool, Sidewalks, Tennis Court(s), Wheelchair Access
  • Direction Faces: South
  • Directions: Head toward Hillview St 0.5 Turn right onto Bahia Vista St 0.7 mi Turn right onto S Shade Ave 0.1 mi Turn left at the 2nd cross street onto Prospect St Destination will be on the left
  • Elementary School: Alta Vista Elementary
  • Middle Or Junior School: Brookside Middle
  • High School: Sarasota High
  • Other Equipment: Irrigation Equipment
  • Mls Major Change Type: Price Decrease
  • Listing Service: Full Service
  • Road Frontage Type: Street Paved
  • Senior Community: No
  • SW Subdiv Community Name: Rustic Lodge
  • Unit Number: No
  • Street Number: 2421
  • Street Name: PROSPECT
  • Street Suffix: STREET
  • State: FL
  • City: SARASOTA
Parking
  • Carport: Yes
  • Garage: No
  • Parking Features: Covered, Deeded, Driveway, Off Street, On Street, Open, Other, RV Parking
Taxes and HOA Information
  • Association Approval Required: No
  • Association: No
  • CDD: No
  • Tax Block: B
  • Tax Book Number: 2-41
  • Tax Legal Description: LOT 6 & W 4 FT OF LOT 8 & E 2 FT OF LOT 4 BLK B RUSTIC LODGE NO 2
  • Tax Lot: 6
  • Tax Year: 2025
Property
Lot Information
  • Additional Parcels: No
  • Lot Features: Historic District, City Lot, Landscaped, Level, Near Golf Course, Near Marina, Private, Sidewalk
  • Parcel Number: 2035020094
  • Total Acreage: 0 to less than 1/4
  • Water Access: No
  • Water Extras: No
  • Zoning: RSF4
  • Living Area: 972
Property and Assessments
  • Year Built Numeric: 1956
  • Flood Zone Code: X
  • Flood Zone Date: 03-27-2024
  • Flood Zone Panel: 12115C0134G
  • Homestead: Yes
  • New Construction: No
  • Property Condition: Completed
  • Public Survey Range: 18
  • Public Survey Section: 29
Utilities
  • Green Energy Efficient: Appliances, Construction, Doors, Incentives, Insulation, Lighting, Thermostat, Water Heater, Windows
  • Sewer: Public Sewer
  • Utilities: BB/HS Internet Available, Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Fiber Optics, Phone Available, Public, Sewer Connected, Street Lights, Underground Utilities, Water Connected
  • Water Source: Public
Interior and Exterior Features
Exterior Features
  • Construction Materials: Asbestos, Block, Stucco, Wood Frame
  • Exterior Features: Courtyard, Dog Run, Fire Pit, Garden, Irrigation System, Lighting, Misting System, Outdoor Grill, Permeable Paving, Private Entrance, Private Mailbox, Private Yard, Rain Gutters, Sidewalk, Sliding Doors
  • Fencing: Wood
  • Foundation Details: Slab
  • Levels: One
  • Other Structures: Shed(s), Storage
  • Patio And Porch Features: Covered, Enclosed, Patio, Porch, Rear Porch, Screened
  • Pool Private: No
  • Pool: Community
  • Pool Private: Yes
  • Roof: Membrane, Shingle
  • Security Features: Closed Circuit Camera(s), Security Fencing/Lighting/Alarms, Security Lights, Security System, Security System Owned, Smoke Detector(s), Touchless Entry
  • Vegetation: Mature Landscaping, Trees/Landscaped
  • Waterfront Feet Total: 0
  • Number Of Stories: 1
Interior Features
  • Bedrooms Total: 3
  • Bathrooms Full: 1
  • Additional Rooms: Attic, Den/Library/Office, Interior In-Law Suite w/No Private Entry
  • Appliances: Bar Fridge, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Water Heater, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Ice Maker, Kitchen Reverse Osmosis System, Microwave, Other, Range, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Tankless Water Heater, Washer, Water Filtration System, Water Purifier, Wine Refrigerator
  • Cooling: Central Air, Humidity Control
  • Fireplace Features: Free Standing, Gas, Outside
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Flooring: Epoxy, Luxury Vinyl
  • Green Indoor Air Quality: Air Filters MERV 10+, Integrated Pest Management, No/Low VOC Cabinets/Counters, No/Low VOC Flooring, No/Low VOC Paint/Finish, Non Toxic Pest Control, Ventilation
  • Heating: Central, Electric, Heat Pump
  • Interior Features: Built-in Features, Ceiling Fan(s), Dry Bar, Eating Space In Kitchen, Living Room/Dining Room Combo, Open Floorplan, Pest Guard System, Primary Bedroom Main Floor, Smart Home, Solid Wood Cabinets, Split Bedroom, Stone Counters, Thermostat, Walk-In Closet(s), Window Treatments
  • Laundry Features: Electric Dryer Hookup, Inside, Laundry Room, Washer Hookup
  • Living Area Source: Builder
  • Living Area Units: Square Feet
  • Room Count: 7.0
  • Water View: No
  • Window Features: Blinds, Double Pane Windows, Drapes, ENERGY STAR Qualified Windows, Insulated Windows, Low-Emissivity Windows, Storm Window(s), Tinted Windows, Window Treatments, Wood Frames
  • Bathrooms Half: 1
Rental
Rental Information
  • Minimum Lease Period: 0
  • Pets Allowed: Cats OK, Dogs OK, Yes

Property History for 2421 Prospect Street

DateEvent & SourcePriceAppreciation
Jan 26, 2026

Price Change

MFRMLS #A4677367

$899,000—
Jan 23, 2026

Price Change

MFRMLS #A4677367

$950,000—
Jan 19, 2026

Listed (Active)

MFRMLS #A4677367

$1,085,000—
Aug 9, 2023

Sold

MFRMLS #D6130490

$360,000—
Aug 7, 2023

Sold (Public Record)

Public Record #1516237678

$360,000—
Jul 18, 2023

Pending

MFRMLS #D6130490

—
May 5, 2023

Listed (Active)

MFRMLS #D6130490

$399,900—
DateEvent & SourcePrice
01/26/2026

Price Change

MFRMLS #A4677367

$899,000
01/23/2026

Price Change

MFRMLS #A4677367

$950,000
01/19/2026

Listed (Active)

MFRMLS #A4677367

$1,085,000
08/09/2023

Sold

MFRMLS #D6130490

$360,000
08/07/2023

Sold (Public Record)

Public Record #1516237678

$360,000
07/18/2023

Pending

MFRMLS #D6130490

—
05/05/2023

Listed (Active)

MFRMLS #D6130490

$399,900

For completeness, Compass often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

Public Records for 2421 Prospect Street

Taxable ValueLand-Additions-Total-
Tax Record2025$4,321 ($360 / month)
Home Facts
Beds2Baths1Total Finished SqFt918 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt918 SqFtStories1Lot Size5,964 SqFtStyleSingle Family ResidenceYear Built1956Year Renovated2011ZoningRSF4CountySARASOTAAPN2035-02-0094

Schools near 2421 Prospect Street

This home is within Sarasota.
Rating
School
Type
Grades
Distance
Alta Vista Elementary School
Public - PK to 5
Brookside Middle School
Public - 6 to 8
Sarasota High School
Public - 9 to 12
Suncoast School For Innovative Studies
Charter - K to 5
Rating
School
Distance
Alta Vista Elementary School
PublicPK to 5

Brookside Middle School
Public6 to 8

Sarasota High School
Public9 to 12

Suncoast School For Innovative Studies
CharterK to 5

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

Similar Sold Homes

Explore Nearby Homes

More information about 2421 Prospect Street, Sarasota, FL 34239

2421 Prospect Street is a single family home for sale in Sarasota, FL 34239. This property was listed for sale on January 19, 2026 by FULLER GROUP, it's currently listed at $899,000. It has been on the market for a total of 9 days and was last sold on August 9, 2023. This listing's school district is Sarasota. Nearby schools include Alta Vista Elementary School, Brookside Middle School and Sarasota High School. 2421 Prospect Street is a 3-bed, 2-bath, 972 sqft single family home built in 1956.

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified, and Compass, Inc., its subsidiaries, affiliates and their agents and associated third parties expressly disclaims any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the discretion of the seller. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Listing Courtesy of FULLER GROUP, Bo Fuller

The information is being provided in part by Southwest Florida Multiple Listing Service, Broker Reciprocity Program ("BR Program") of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. ("Naples MLS"), under License No. NCOMPN2, and MarcoMls. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than the identification of potential properties for purchase. Copyright 2026 Southwest Florida Multiple Listing Service and MarcoMls. All Rights Reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale displayed on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program ("BR Program") of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. ("Naples MLS"), under License No. NCOMPN2 and MarcoMls. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than Compass are marked with the "BR House" logo. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the brokerage firm with which the seller has listed the property. The properties displayed may not be all the properties listed with brokerage firms participating in the Naples MLS BR Program, or contained in the database compilation of Naples MLS.