Sold
Last Sold Price
3 beds1 bath972 sqft$247/sqft
5 Rutgers St, Smithtown, NY 11787
0.25 acresLot Size
1957Year Built
$247/sq ftPrice per sq ft
Listing closed: 05/01/2001 08:00 AM

Recent comparable sales

Median sold price

$640,000

Avg days on market

17

Sale-to-list ratio

111.1%

Smithtown, NY

9 comparable properties found

$640,000 | 11 Gedney Avenue, Smithtown, NY 11787
1

$640,000

Sold 05/20/25

3
Bedrooms
920
Square Feet
0.23
Acres
a front view of a house with a yard and garage
2

$735,000

Sold 07/17/26

3
Bedrooms
943
Square Feet
0.23
Acres
3

$665,000

Sold 10/23/25

3
Bedrooms
1
Bathrooms
1,112
Square Feet
0.35
Acres
a view of a house with a yard
4

$750,000

Sold 03/02/26

3
Bedrooms
1,118
Square Feet
0.26
Acres
a front view of a house with a garden
5

$600,000

Sold 02/24/26

3
Bedrooms
1,113
Square Feet
0.38
Acres
6

$630,000

Sold 03/07/25

3
Bedrooms
1
Bathrooms
1,193
Square Feet
0.52
Acres
a house with trees in the background
7

$580,000

Sold 09/18/25

3
Bedrooms
1,000
Square Feet
0.5
Acres
8

$835,000

Sold 10/22/25

3
Bedrooms
1
Bathrooms
852
Square Feet
0.22
Acres
$601,000 | 33 Summit Drive, Smithtown, NY 11767
9

$601,000

Sold 08/24/26

3
Bedrooms
1,178
Square Feet
0.5
Acres

Location

Add your commute

Payment Calculator

$2,375 per month

30 year fixed, 6.71% Interest

Principal and Interest

$1,240

Property Taxes

$1,135

HOA Dues

$0

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Rocket Mortgage1

Property Information for 5 Rutgers Street

Property Details
Building Information
  • Stories: 1
  • Year Built: 1957
  • Lot Size: 0.25 AC / 10,890 SF

Property History for 5 Rutgers Street

DateEvent & SourcePriceAppreciation
May 1, 2001

Sold (Public Record)

Public Record #75419665

$240,000
DateEvent & SourcePrice
05/01/2001

Sold (Public Record)

Public Record #75419665

$240,000

For completeness, we often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

Public Records for 5 Rutgers Street

Taxable ValueLand$300Additions$5,508Total$5,808
Tax Record2024$13,623 ($1,135 / month)
Home Facts
Beds3Baths1Total Finished SqFt972 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt972 SqFtStories1Lot Size10,890 SqFtStyleSingle Family ResidenceYear Built1957Year Renovated1957CountySUFFOLKAPN0800-082.00-02.00-024.000

Schools near 5 Rutgers Street

This home is within Smithtown Central School District.
Rating
School
Type
Grades
Distance
Public - K to 5
Public - 6 to 8
Public - 9 to 12
Public - 6 to 8
Rating
School
Distance
Dogwood Elementary School
PublicK to 5

Nesaquake Middle School
Public6 to 8

Smithtown High School East
Public9 to 12

Great Hollow Middle School
Public6 to 8

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

New listings in 11787

$1,625,000 | 40 Friendly Road, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/38

Listing Courtesy of Serhant East End LLC, Damian Andraka SFR

Coming Soon

$1,625,000

5
Bedrooms
2,700
Square Feet
0.61
Acres
$759,000 | 90 Cornell Drive, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/26

Listing Courtesy of Signature Premier Properties, John D. Jacome CBR

Coming SoonOpen: 9/12 12:00PM - 02:00PM

$759,000

4
Bedrooms
1,376
Square Feet
0.23
Acres
$799,000 | 16 Dogwood Drive, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/36

Listing Courtesy of Exit Realty Achieve, Laura Kraker E-PRO SRS; Exit Realty Achieve, Mary Kate Furia ABR

Open: 9/11 05:00PM - 06:30PMNew

$799,000

4
Bedrooms
2,294
Square Feet
0.6
Acres
$1,199,000 | 5 Keystone Court, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/38

Listing Courtesy of Long Island Home Prop LLC, Elaine A. Halpin

New

$1,199,000

5
Bedrooms
3,301
Square Feet
0.46
Acres
$280,000 | 355 Highway 111, Unit 30, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/2

Listing Courtesy of Leading Edge R E Services, Anthony Rubino

New

$280,000

1
Bedrooms
900
Square Feet
$629,999 | 6 Sybil Place, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/26

Listing Courtesy of Signature Premier Properties, Lorraine Dee Donovan

Open: 9/12 11:00AM - 01:00PMNew

$629,999

3
Bedrooms
1,200
Square Feet
0.25
Acres
$689,000 | 8 Gedney Avenue, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/23

Listing Courtesy of Signature Premier Properties, John Cinque CBR HFR SRES

Open: 9/12 01:00PM - 03:00PMNew

$689,000

3
Bedrooms
920
Square Feet
0.32
Acres
$899,000 | 31 Dehan Street, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/42

Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Liberty, Agatha Lubas

Open: 9/13 01:00PM - 03:00PMNew

$899,000

3
Bedrooms
2,098
Square Feet
0.5
Acres
$749,999 | 6 North Avenue, Smithtown, NY 11787
1/30

Listing Courtesy of RE/MAX Integrity Leaders, Michael J. Scarito

Open: 9/12 12:00PM - 02:00PMNew

$749,999

4
Bedrooms
1,700
Square Feet
0.25
Acres

Nearby home values

AddressSold priceBedsBathsSqftLot (Sqft)
This home: 5 Rutgers Street, Smithtown, NY 11787
$240,000
3
1
972
10,890
$465,000
3
10,890
13,939
$625,000
3
1
1,254
11,761
$525,000
10,890
$84,562
4
2.5
2,297
11,761

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of any information, descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified through appropriate means, including, but not limited to, in person inspection and public records, and Compass International Holdings, its subsidiaries, affiliates and independently owned and operated franchisees, and their affiliated agents and associated third parties expressly disclaim any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the seller's discretion. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS. Information Copyright 2026, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved.