945 Pencil Mill Road

Closed 8/2/16
Closed 8/2/16
Gallery Image 1
Gallery Image 2
Gallery Image 3
Gallery Image 4
Gallery Image 5
Gallery Image 6
Gallery Image 7
Gallery Image 8
Gallery Image 9
Gallery Image 10
Gallery Image 11
Gallery Image 12
Gallery Image 13
Gallery Image 14
Gallery Image 15
Gallery Image 16
Gallery Image 17
Gallery Image 18
Gallery Image 19
Gallery Image 20
Gallery Image 21
Sold
Last Sold Price
$235,000
2 beds1,029 sqft$228/sqft
945 Pencil Mill Rd, Castleton, VT 05735
Single FamilyProperty Type
30 acresLot Size
1970Year Built
$228/sq ftPrice per sq ft

Description

Quintessential Vermont retreat and cabin in the woods has been in the family since family built it in 1970! New Architectural Shingle roof May 2015 and tilt-in insulated windows too! Tranquil setting with 30 acres to explore and seasonal views of Lake Bomoseen from the top of the ridge. Impeccably cared for and maintained over the years. Enjoy living here year round and take advantage of the hunting, fishing, hiking and snowmobiling. Master bedroom and bath on the main level and lofted 2nd bedroom...Quintessential Vermont retreat and cabin in the woods has been in the family since family built it in 1970! New Architectural Shingle roof May 2015 and tilt-in insulated windows too! Tranquil setting with 30 acres to explore and seasonal views of Lake Bomoseen from the top of the ridge. Impeccably cared for and maintained over the years. Enjoy living here year round and take advantage of the hunting, fishing, hiking and snowmobiling. Master bedroom and bath on the main level and lofted 2nd bedroom with numerous skylights to star gaze at night.

    Sold By RE/MAX Four Seasons

    • Listed by: Sandi Reiber • Four Seasons Sotheby's Int'l Realty
    Listing closed: 08/02/2016 12:00 AM • Source: New England Real Estate Network, MLS#: 4432276

    Recent comparable sales

    Median sold price

    $370,000

    Avg days on market

    65

    Sale-to-list ratio

    87.4%

    Castleton, VT

    9 comparable properties found

    $270,000 | 4480 East Hubbardton Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/47
    1

    $270,000

    Sold 09/22/25

    2
    Bedrooms
    1,022
    Square Feet
    1.75
    Acres

    4480 East Hubbardton Road, Castleton, VT 05735

    $284,000 | 1150 Rte 30 South, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/30
    2

    $284,000

    Sold 06/25/25

    2
    Bedrooms
    1,092
    Square Feet
    3.03
    Acres

    1150 Rte 30 South, Castleton, VT 05735

    $181,000 | 2185 Drake Road, Unit 2, Castleton, VT 05732
    1/19
    3

    $181,000

    Sold 07/31/26

    2
    Bedrooms
    948
    Square Feet
    Unavailable
    Acres

    2185 Drake Road, Unit 2, Castleton, VT 05732

    $550,000 | 49 Rockview Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/43
    4

    $550,000

    Sold 06/03/26

    3
    Bedrooms
    1,001
    Square Feet
    0.35
    Acres

    49 Rockview Road, Castleton, VT 05735

    $485,000 | 29 Cliff Dwellers, Castleton, VT 05732
    1/41
    5

    $485,000

    Sold 10/24/25

    2
    Bedrooms
    742
    Square Feet
    0.1
    Acres

    29 Cliff Dwellers, Castleton, VT 05732

    $160,000 | 1052 Highway 4A, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/16
    6

    $160,000

    Sold 02/04/25

    2
    Bedrooms
    912
    Square Feet
    0.37
    Acres

    1052 Highway 4A, Castleton, VT 05735

    $370,000 | 4005 N Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/51
    7

    $370,000

    Sold 06/30/25

    2
    Bedrooms
    2,332
    Square Feet
    0.39
    Acres

    4005 N Road, Castleton, VT 05735

    $600,000 | 383 Johnson Spooner Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/36
    8

    $600,000

    Sold 07/11/25

    2
    Bedrooms
    1,614
    Square Feet
    0.66
    Acres

    383 Johnson Spooner Road, Castleton, VT 05735

    $432,500 | 658 Johnson Spooner Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/54
    9

    $432,500

    Sold 12/22/25

    2
    Bedrooms
    1,370
    Square Feet
    1.07
    Acres

    658 Johnson Spooner Road, Castleton, VT 05735

    Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1

    Location

    Add your commute

    Payment Calculator

    Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1

    $1,445 per month

    30 year fixed, 6.55% Interest

    Principal and Interest

    $1,194

    Property Taxes

    $251

    HOA Dues

    $0

    The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

    Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

    Rocket Mortgage1

    Property Information for 945 Pencil Mill Road

    Property Details
    • Taxes: $3,006 / year
    • MLS Type: Residential / Single Family
    • County: Rutland County
    • Parking: Parking Spaces 4
    • Zoning: unk
    Building Information
    • Stories: 1
    • Year Built: 1970
    • Lot Size: 30.00 AC / 1,306,800 SF
    Summary
    Location and General Information
    • Area Description: Near Snowmobile Trails, Rural
    • City: Castleton
    • County: VT-Rutland
    • Directions: Rte.4 west to Castleton 4 Corners. Take Rte. 30 north to North Road (across from Crystal Beach). Second left is Pencil Mill Road. #945 is one mile in on the left.
    • Latitude: 43.665510625686
    • Longitude: -73.183636889665
    • Road Frontage: Yes
    • Seasonal: No
    • State: VT
    • Zip: 05735
    Taxes and HOA Information
    • SPAN Number: 12904010995
    • Tax - Gross Amount: $3,005.66
    • Tax Year: 2015
    • Taxes TBD: No
    School Information
    • School - High: Choice
    • School - District: Addison Rutland
    • School - Elementary: Castleton Elementary School
    • School - Middle/Jr: Fair Haven Grade School
    Parking
    • Garage: No
    • Garage Capacity: .00
    • Driveway: Crushed Stone
    Property
    Lot Information
    • Lot - Sqft: 1306800.0
    • Lot Size Acres: 30.0
    • Road Frontage Length: 260.0
    • Square Feet Apx Finished Above Grade: 1029.0
    • Square Feet Apx Finished AG Source: Public Records
    • Square Feet Apx Finished Below Grade: 0.0
    • Square Feet Apx Finished BG Source: Public Records
    • Square Feet Apx Tot BG Source: Public Records
    • Square Feet Apx Tot Below Grade: 712.0
    • Square Feet Apx Total Finished: 1029.0
    • Square Feet Apx Unfinished Below Grade: 712.0
    Property and Assessments
    • Property Class: Residential
    • Property Type: Single Family
    • Flood Zone: No
    • Foundation: Concrete
    • Surveyed: Yes
    • Year Built: 1970
    Utilities
    • Electric Company: GMP
    • Electric: 100 Amp
    • Sewer: 1000 Gallon, Private, Septic
    Interior and Exterior Features
    Exterior Features
    • Color: Brown
    • Features - Exterior: Outbuilding, Porch - Covered, Shed
    • Roads: Public
    • Roof: Shingle - Architectural
    Interior Features
    • Appliances: Range - Electric, Refrigerator
    • Basement: Yes
    • Basement Access Type: Interior
    • Basement Description: Concrete, Full, Stairs - Interior, Unfinished
    • Baths - Total: 1
    • Baths - Full: 1
    • Half Baths: 0
    • Three Quarter Bath: 0
    • Rooms - Total: 5
    • Bedrooms - Total: 2
    • Equipment: Smoke Detector
    • Features - Interior: Blinds, Ceiling Fan, Fireplace - Wood, Fireplaces - 1, Kitchen/Dining, Natural Woodwork, Skylight, Vaulted Ceiling, Window Treatment
    • Flooring: Softwood
    • Heat Fuel: Oil
    • Heating: Hot Air
    • Total Stories: 1.5
    Room Information
    Room 1
    • Room Dimensions: 12x8
    • Room Level: 1
    • Room Type: Kitchen
    Room 2
    • Room Dimensions: 12x8
    • Room Level: 1
    • Room Type: Dining Room
    Room 3
    • Room Dimensions: 20x16
    • Room Level: 1
    • Room Type: Living Room
    Room 7
    • Room Dimensions: 15x8
    • Room Level: 1
    • Room Type: Master Bedroom
    Room 13
    • Room Dimensions: 17x16
    • Room Level: 2
    • Room Type: Other
    Room 14
    • Room Dimensions: 20x8
    • Room Level: 1
    • Room Type: Other
    Room 15
    • Room Dimensions: 8x6
    • Room Level: 1
    • Room Type: Other

    Property History for 945 Pencil Mill Road

    DateEvent & SourcePriceAppreciation
    Aug 4, 2016

    Sold (Public Record)

    Public Record #596834102

    		$235,000—
    Aug 2, 2016

    Sold

    New England Real Estate Network #4432276

    		$235,000—
    Aug 2, 2016

    Pending

    New England Real Estate Network #4432276

    		—
    DateEvent & SourcePrice
    08/04/2016

    Sold (Public Record)

    Public Record #596834102

    $235,000
    08/02/2016

    Sold

    New England Real Estate Network #4432276

    $235,000
    08/02/2016

    Pending

    New England Real Estate Network #4432276

    —

    For completeness, we often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

    Public Records for 945 Pencil Mill Road

    Taxable ValueLand$113,800Additions$103,100Total$216,900
    Tax Record2024$3,823 ($319 / month)
    Home Facts
    Beds2Total Finished SqFt1,029 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt1,029 SqFtStories2Lot Size1,306,800 SqFtStyleSingle Family ResidenceYear Built1970ZoningR2ACountyRUTLANDAPN(040) 020100002Fireplace TypeHas Fireplace

    Schools near 945 Pencil Mill Road

    This home is within Slate Valley Unified Union School District #62.
    Rating
    School
    Type
    Grades
    Distance
    Castleton Elementary School
    		Public - PK to 6
    Fair Haven Uhsd #16
    		Public - 7 to 12
    Castleton Village School
    		Public - 6 to 8
    Rating
    School
    Distance
    Castleton Elementary School
    PublicPK to 6

    Fair Haven Uhsd #16
    Public7 to 12

    Castleton Village School
    Public6 to 8

    School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

    Similar Homes

    New listings in 05735

    $577,777 | 10 Old Town Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/28

    $577,777

    2
    Bedrooms
    1,152
    Square Feet
    0.69
    Acres

    10 Old Town Road, Castleton, VT 05735

    $1,499,000 | 2427 Monument Hill Road, Hubbardton, VT 05735
    1/60

    $1,499,000

    5
    Bedrooms
    5,006
    Square Feet
    86
    Acres

    2427 Monument Hill Road, Hubbardton, VT 05735

    $99,779 | 81 Cramton Road, Unit L8, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/6

    $99,779

    2
    Bedrooms
    880
    Square Feet
    Unavailable
    Acres

    81 Cramton Road, Unit L8, Castleton, VT 05735

    $99,779 | 81 Cramton Road, Unit LOT 17, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/7

    $99,779

    2
    Bedrooms
    880
    Square Feet
    Unavailable
    Acres

    81 Cramton Road, Unit LOT 17, Castleton, VT 05735

    $269,000 | 21 A Preston Lane, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/17

    $269,000

    1
    Bedrooms
    2,525
    Square Feet
    0.4
    Acres

    21 A Preston Lane, Castleton, VT 05735

    $739,900 | 587 Johnson Spooner Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/52

    $739,900

    3
    Bedrooms
    2,890
    Square Feet
    0.9
    Acres

    587 Johnson Spooner Road, Castleton, VT 05735

    $429,000 | 10 Sevigny Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/32

    $429,000

    2
    Bedrooms
    784
    Square Feet
    0.93
    Acres

    10 Sevigny Road, Castleton, VT 05735

    $49,900 | 81 Cramton Road, Unit 6, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/14

    $49,900

    2
    Bedrooms
    980
    Square Feet
    Unavailable
    Acres

    81 Cramton Road, Unit 6, Castleton, VT 05735

    $539,000 | 53-55 Highway 30, Castleton, VT 05735
    1/29

    $539,000

    4
    Bedrooms
    6,557
    Square Feet
    0.44
    Acres

    53-55 Highway 30, Castleton, VT 05735

    Nearby home values

    AddressSold priceBedsBathsSqftLot (Sqft)
    This home: 945 Pencil Mill Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    $235,000
    2
    1,029
    1,306,800
    628 Pencil Mill Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    –
    3
    2.5
    1,901
    406,415
    887 Pencil Mill Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    $107,000
    3
    871
    468,270
    916 Pencil Mill Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    $121,000
    3
    2
    1,726
    805,860
    0 Pencil Mill Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    $9,250
    –
    –
    –
    179,902
    836 Pencil Mill Road, Castleton, VT 05735
    $255,000
    2
    1,404
    411,641

    Explore Nearby Homes

    No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of any information, descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified through appropriate means, including, but not limited to, in person inspection and public records, and Compass International Holdings, its subsidiaries, affiliates and independently owned and operated franchisees, and their affiliated agents and associated third parties expressly disclaim any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the seller's discretion. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity.

    Listing Courtesy of Four Seasons Sotheby's Int'l Realty

    Copyright 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this Site comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated 09/05/2026 06:13 AM