Peyton Wallace, Agent in Greater Boston - Compass

Peyton Wallace

Licensed Real Estate Broker | Co-Founder of The MV Team

$150M+ Closed Sales on Martha's Vineyard


CarMax chief picks up an $8 million view

Former Jacqueline Onassis Kennedy parcels in Aquinnah return to market

$15M Martha's Vineyard compound on Oyster Pond

Social Media



University of Pennsylvania

About Peyton

Co-Founder of The MV Team

Peyton Wallace prides himself in his dynamic level of service combined with a unique and informed perspective of the market, specifically the luxury real estate market on Martha's Vineyard. Peyton is exceptionally qualified to provide accurate data, industry perspectives and detailed current market conditions as well as a focused understanding of the luxury consumer. Peyton brings many added-value skills to the process of buying and selling properties, and has consulted in numerous situations to clients who value his insights and opinions tremendously.

Peyton covers the complete gamut of services for residential brokerage on Martha's Vineyard. From representing sellers through a comprehensive marketing plan to representing buyers with an educated view of the current market, he strives to provide the highest quality service and go beyond the expected. His services extend far beyond the close of each transaction and his foundation in business are long-term relationships based on trust.

With over 13 years experience as a licensed real estate broker on Martha's Vineyard and over $150 million in sales on-island, Peyton is a gifted, knowledgeable professional with an exceptional array of abilities and marketing savvy. He has guided buyers and sellers successfully through both difficult markets, like that seen in 2008-2009, and more robust periods. Also, he has experience with the luxury market in Manhattan, where he was a REBNY member and worked recently on a WSJ top 100 team. He still holds real estate licenses in Massachusetts, New York, and Connecticut, and has a wide network of contacts spanning multiple markets.

Peyton received a BA in History from the University of Pennsylvania, where he captained the varsity golf team and achieved Academic All-American status for his final two years. Born and raised in Philadelphia, he spent summers with his family on the Edgartown Great Pond. He graduated high school from San Francisco University High School, and his immediate family resides in Manhattan, the Bay Area and Santa Fe, New Mexico. He resides in West Tisbury with his wife Christina and their two children.


22 Lelands Path, Edgartown

Set on a commanding perch above the shores of Katama Bay, this luxurious 10,000 sf gambrel home, designed by renowned architect Patrick Ahearn, awaits the buyer searching for the best of coastal estates in New England. With nearly 6 acres private and over 40 acres of surrounding conservation parcels, peace and serenity are what define this Martha’s Vineyard residence. Manicured lawns and meadows, comforting oak and pine trees, swans frolicking in nearby waters, sweeping water views, magical sunsets, and extensive sandy beaches combine to create relaxing outdoor environs. The interior of the home features a rarely achieved level of quality with views of the water readily available from every room. The master bedroom suite offers a breathtaking private outdoor space and luxurious bathroom, while guests can choose from multiple private bedroom suites with grand proportions. The home also features a beautifully appointed kitchen, extensive custom millwork, and smart home technology.


44 Forest Road, West Tisbury

The quintessential Seven Gates waterfront compound, this outstanding retreat awaits amidst Martha’s Vineyard’s most beautiful surrounds. With jaw-dropping views and immediate sandy beachfront, the property features a main residence and barn designed and built by South Mountain Company. Immaculately kept, the structures are virtually turn-key. The interiors offer rich details, displaying highest level craftsmanship, and elegant design, perfect for relaxation and enjoying the sensory delights of the seaside. Views of the Sound and Elizabeth Islands are readily available from nearly every room, including from the guest suite above the barn. Just off the main house is an inviting pool area, complete with bluestone patio, extensive stone walls and hardscape. The property is set within the one of the most incomparable private areas of the Island. Seven Gates Farm has a rich history, and comprises approximately 1600 acres.

Peyton Wallace’s Listings

Peyton Wallace’s Recent Transactions