40 Dinah Rock Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964

$1,999,000
Last Sold Price
3
Beds
1,897 Sq. Ft.
$1,054 / Sq. Ft.
1,897
Sq. Ft.
$1,054
per Sq. Ft.
Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1
Sold 7/16/25
Sold 7/16/25
a swimming pool with outdoor seating and outdoor seating
a front view of a house with a yard
a aerial view of a house with a yard
a view of a playground with basketball court
a living room with furniture and a large window
a living room with furniture a fireplace and a flat screen tv
a living room with furniture a rug and a flat screen tv
a living room with furniture a fireplace and a large window
a living room with furniture and a fireplace
a view of an entryway with wooden floor
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop a sink a stove and a wooden floors
a kitchen with stainless steel appliances granite countertop a stove and a sink
a kitchen with a white stove top oven and furniture
a view of a dining room with furniture window and outside view
a dining room with furniture and window
a bedroom with a large bed and a potted plant
a bathroom with a sink a toilet a mirror and shower
a living room with furniture and a wooden floor
a bedroom with a bed and a flat screen tv
a bathroom with a shower sink and mirror
a bedroom with a bed a dresser and a window
a bedroom with a bed and a window
a bedroom with a bed and a window
a bathroom with a granite countertop sink toilet and shower
a view of a park with large trees
a view of a big house with a big yard and large trees
an aerial view of a house with a yard and tree s
a aerial view of a house with a yard
a view of lake and mountain

Description

Picture a rural drive through farm fields and vineyards to a short ferry boat ride from Greenport's harbor, then a scenic meander along Shelter Island's picturesque coves. Continue passing through a golf course and arrive at your home in Hay Beach, across the street from a sandy shoreline with a magnificent sunset and bay views directly in front of your home. This could be you this year. The 1900 sq ft 3+ bedroom 3 bath shingled home is 100% turn-key renovated on a shy acre with a recently built...Picture a rural drive through farm fields and vineyards to a short ferry boat ride from Greenport's harbor, then a scenic meander along Shelter Island's picturesque coves. Continue passing through a golf course and arrive at your home in Hay Beach, across the street from a sandy shoreline with a magnificent sunset and bay views directly in front of your home. This could be you this year. The 1900 sq ft 3+ bedroom 3 bath shingled home is 100% turn-key renovated on a shy acre with a recently built 16 x 40' heated salt-water Gunite pool in a sprawling sunny yard. Once inside, soaring double-height 20 ft ceilings meet you at the front door in a welcoming foyer. A recent thorough transformation included new oak floors, new stair balustrade, newel posts and handrails, and three stunning new baths, and a fully reimagined modern kitchen. The luminous loft-like open plan great room features a wall of glass with French doors to the backyard deck and a hearth-sized wood-burning fireplace anchoring a spacious (yet cozy) living room and dining area. The recently completed kitchen boasts premium Bertazzoni appliances and a generous 10.5-foot prep island with seating, ideal for both casual meals and mingling with guests. On the ground floor, a large bonus room with an adjacent full bath functions as an extra 4th bedroom with a walk-in closet and ample room for a home office. Upstairs are 2 well-sized guest bedrooms, one with water views, which share a hall bathroom. Connected by a bridge overlooking the living room and foyer is the sexy primary suite, which has water views and a superb spa bath with a rain showerhead and body sprays. The unfinished lower level is partially above grade and presents as an easy future conversion to additional living space with a fireplace and plenty of natural light via windows and glass sliders offering access to the grassy backyard. This exceptional home combines tranquil living with proximity to many sandy beaches, Dering Harbor Village, and Gardiners Bay Country Club, providing an ideal setting to enjoy all the unique attractions Shelter Island offers.

Listing Agents

  1. Caroline Sarraf

    Caroline Sarraf

    Listing Agent

    Compass

    csarraf@compass.com

    P: (631)-871-6104

    CallTextEmail
  2. Cynthia Beck

    Cynthia Beck

    Alternative Listing Agent

    Compass

    cynthia.beck@compass.com

    P: (917)-951-8642

    CallTextEmail

Property Details for 40 Dinah Rock Road

Apartment Type
0
Garage Type
0
Attached Parking
0
Has Pool
Yes
Has Central AC
Yes
LISTING UPDATED: 08/08/2025 12:15 AM

Property Details for 40 Dinah Rock Road

StatusSold
MLS #921490
Days on Market54
Taxes$7,957 / year
HOA Fees-
Condo/Co-op Fees-
Compass TypeSingle Family
MLS TypeHouse (Detached)
Year Built2000
Lot Size0.92 AC / 40,075 SF
CountySuffolk County
Compensation Remarks2.5% buyer's broker compensation
Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1

Location

Sold By Saunders & Associates, Penelope A. Moore

Add your commute

Building Information for 40 Dinah Rock Road

Stories2Year Built2000Building Size-Lot Size0.92 AC / 40,075 SF

Payment Calculator

Get preapproved with Rocket Mortgage1

$10,406 per month

30 year fixed, 6.15% Interest

Principal and Interest

$9,743

Property Taxes

$663

HOA Dues

$0

The Payment Calculator is for illustrative purposes only.

Know your buying power with a preapproval and custom rate in minutes

Rocket Mortgage1

Property Information for 40 Dinah Rock Road

Summary
Location and General Information
  • Latitude: 41.100887
  • Longitude: -72.33677
  • Property Township: Shelter Island
  • Property Zone Type: 0
  • View Water: Yes
  • Hamlet ID: 119
Taxes and HOA Information
  • Tax Year: 2024
  • Percentage of Tax that is Deductable: 0.0
  • Parcel ID: 0700-001.000-0001-028.000
Property
Lot Information
  • Land Frontage in Feet: 0.0
  • Property Class: 210
Property and Assessments
  • Residential Style: Traditional
  • Renovation Year: 2023
  • Construction Type: 0
  • Commercial Type: 0
Utilities
  • Sewer Type: Private Septic
  • Water Source Type: Private Well
Interior and Exterior Features
Exterior Features
  • Exterior Deck: Yes
  • Pool Gunite: Yes
  • Pool Heated: Yes
  • Pool Inground: Yes
  • Pool Salt Water: Yes
  • Pool Size: 16 x 40
  • Roof Asphalt: Yes
  • Siding Cedar Shake: Yes
  • Attic Type: 0
Interior Features
  • Appliance Dishwasher: Yes
  • Appliance Dryer: Yes
  • Appliance Oven: Yes
  • Appliance Refrigerator: Yes
  • Appliance Stainless Steel: Yes
  • Appliance Washer: Yes
  • Basement Area Square Footage: 0.0
  • Basement Type: Full
  • Basement Unfinished: Yes
  • Basement Walkout: Yes
  • Floor Hardwood: Yes
  • Heat AC Zones: Yes
  • Heat Fuel Propane: Yes
  • Heat Type Forced Air: Yes
  • Interior Amps: 0
  • Kitchen Counter Type: 700
  • Kitchen Type: Open
  • Room Bonus: Yes
  • Room Den: Yes
  • Room en Suite: Yes
  • Room First Floor Bath: Yes
  • Room Foyer: Yes
  • Room Great: Yes
  • Room Kitchen: Yes
  • Room Living: Yes
  • Room Master Bedroom: Yes
  • Room Private Guest: Yes
  • Room Walk in Closet: Yes
  • Number of Fireplaces: 2.0
  • Number of Garage Spaces: 0.0
  • Number of Lots: 0.0
  • Number of Rooms: 0.0
  • Number of Stories: 2.0
  • Number of Units: 0.0

Property History for 40 Dinah Rock Road

DateEvent & SourcePriceAppreciation
Jun 10, 2022

Sold (Public Record)

Public Record #1523165049

$1,610,000—
DateEvent & SourcePrice
06/10/2022

Sold (Public Record)

Public Record #1523165049

$1,610,000

For completeness, Compass often displays two records for one sale: the MLS record and the public record.

Public Records for 40 Dinah Rock Road

Taxable ValueLand$557,700Additions$611,900Total$1,169,600
Home Facts
Beds3Baths2Total Finished SqFt1,897 SqFtAbove Grade Finished SqFt1,897 SqFtStories2Lot Size40,075 SqFtStyleSingle Family ResidenceYear Built2000Year Renovated2015ZoningAACountySUFFOLKAPN0700-001.00-01.00-028.000Fireplace TypeHas Fireplace

Schools near 40 Dinah Rock Road

This home is within Shelter Island Union Free School District.
Rating
School
Type
Grades
Distance
Shelter Island School
Public - PK to 12
Rating
School
Distance
Shelter Island School
PublicPK to 12

School ratings and boundaries are provided by GreatSchools.org and Pitney Bowes. This information should only be used as a reference. Proximity or boundaries shown here are not a guarantee of enrollment. Please reach out to schools directly to verify all information and enrollment eligibility.

Similar Homes

Similar Sold Homes

Explore Nearby Homes

No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified, and Compass, Inc., its subsidiaries, affiliates and their agents and associated third parties expressly disclaims any liability in connection therewith. Photos may be virtually staged or digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. Offers of compensation are subject to change at the discretion of the seller. No financial or legal advice provided. Equal Housing Opportunity. Subject to change at any time. Compass makes no guarantee, warranty or representation regarding the accuracy of any waterfront feature, water view or waterfront view.

The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS. Information Copyright 2026, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved.